Figure 1 - Streaming and cinema in Country X
In Country X, more and more households pay for video streaming services, which offer thousands of films and series at home for a monthly fee. Some people argue that streaming is a substitute for going to the cinema. Others say a trip to the cinema is a different experience: a night out, with a big screen and new films that are often not available to stream until months later. Cinemas were closed for several months in 2021. Figure 1 shows data for Country X (invented data).
Using Figure 1, assess whether streaming services and cinema trips are close substitutes.
Model answer
Substitutes are goods or services that can be used instead of each other, so if streaming and cinema trips are close substitutes, the growth of streaming should reduce the demand for cinema trips. Some of the data support this. Since 2019 the number of households with streaming has risen from 11 million to 19 million (72.7%), but cinema admissions in 2025 were still only 126 million, 28% below the 175 million of 2019. This suggests that some people who used to go to the cinema now watch films at home instead. Streaming is also much cheaper per film for a family than several cinema tickets, and if films become available to stream soon after release, more people will wait.
However, the earlier data suggest they are not close substitutes. Between 2015 and 2019 the number of streaming households more than doubled, from 5 million to 11 million, yet cinema admissions rose from 160 million to 175 million. If they were close substitutes, admissions should have fallen. A cinema trip offers something streaming cannot: a night out, a big screen and new films that cannot yet be streamed. Streaming may even work as a complement, as series and trailers build interest in films that people then go to see.
The fall in admissions after 2019 may also have other causes. Cinemas were closed for months in 2021, which broke people's habits, and the average ticket price rose from £7.80 to £9.00, an increase of 15.4%. A higher ticket price reduces the quantity of cinema trips demanded, a movement along the demand curve that has nothing to do with streaming. Admissions are also recovering, rising 5% from 120 million in 2023 to 126 million in 2025.
Overall, I think streaming and cinema trips are only partial substitutes, not close ones. The years before 2020 show that cinema demand can grow alongside streaming, and the later fall can be explained partly by the closures and higher prices. They are closer substitutes for some consumers, such as families watching smaller films, than for others, such as young people going out to see big new releases. How close they are depends mainly on how soon films can be streamed after release and on the price of cinema tickets compared with a streaming subscription.
Explanation
Level 3 answers apply the meaning of substitutes and test it against the data: streaming more than doubled while admissions rose before 2020, but admissions stayed well below 2019 after the closures. They weigh other explanations (closures, a 15.4% rise in ticket prices, a movement along the demand curve) and reach a judgement that says it depends on the consumer, the type of film or the release window. Simply asserting that streaming 'killed the cinema' ignores the evidence.