Figure 1 - Home broadband in Country Z
In Country Z (invented), three firms supply 88% of home broadband connections. The firms' combined profits have risen in recent years. The firms say these profits pay for new full-fibre networks, which give much faster and more reliable connections. A consumer group says the firms face too little competition and that prices are rising faster than they should.
Table 1 shows data for the three largest broadband firms in Country Z.
Using Figure 1 and Table 1, assess whether the high profits made by firms in an oligopoly such as the home broadband market in Country Z are bad for consumers.
Model answer
There is evidence that the high profits are bad for consumers. With three firms supplying 88% of connections, this is a concentrated oligopoly, so the firms are price makers and face little pressure to keep prices down. The average monthly price for basic broadband rose from £27 to £33, an increase of 22.2%, while the firms' combined profits rose from £1.9 billion to £2.8 billion, about 47%. Profits growing more than twice as fast as prices suggests the firms are using their market power to charge consumers more than it costs to supply them, transferring money from consumers to shareholders. With so few firms, they may avoid competing on price at all, simply following each other's price rises, and consumers have little choice.
However, the profits may also benefit consumers. The firms' investment in full-fibre networks doubled from £1.1 billion to £2.2 billion, and the share of homes able to get full fibre rose from 31% to 74%. In 2025 investment equalled about 79% of profits, compared with 58% in 2021, so a growing share of the profit is being put back into the network. Full fibre gives consumers much faster and more reliable connections, so part of the price rise buys a better product. Building a national network has very high fixed costs, and firms in a competitive market with low profits might not be able to afford it; large firms with economies of scale and high profits can.
Overall, I judge that the profits are not simply bad for consumers in this case, because most of them are being reinvested in a network that greatly improves quality. However, the evidence of rising prices in a market with little competition is a real concern. Whether the profits are bad for consumers depends on what happens once the network is finished: if investment then falls but prices and profits keep rising, consumers will lose out, and the government or a regulator may need to encourage new firms to enter or limit price rises.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer weighs the costs of oligopoly profits (higher prices, less choice, market power) against the benefits (investment, innovation, better quality), uses the data (prices +22%, profits +47%, investment doubled, full fibre 31% to 74%) and reaches a judgement that depends on whether profits are reinvested. Answers that assume high profits are always bad, or ignore the table, are capped at 6 marks.