Figure 1 - Renting in Calderbridge
Calderbridge is a city (invented) with a fast-growing population of students and young workers. Average rents have risen much faster than wages, and many young people now spend almost half their take-home pay on rent. The city council wants to set a maximum rent of £900 a month for a one-bedroom flat. Landlords' groups say a cap would lead some landlords to sell their flats or to stop repairing them. Tenants' groups say a cap would stop rents rising beyond what people can afford.
Table 1 shows data about one-bedroom flats in Calderbridge.
Using Figure 1 and Table 1, assess whether a maximum rent of £900 a month would benefit tenants in Calderbridge.
Model answer
A maximum rent of £900 a month would bring clear benefits to many tenants. Average rents rose from £780 to £1,040 between 2021 and 2025, a rise of 33.3%, while young people's average take-home pay rose by only 16.2%, from £1,850 to £2,150. Rent therefore rose from about 42% of take-home pay to about 48%. The cap is £140 below the current average rent, about 13.5% lower, which would bring rent back to around 42% of take-home pay. Tenants who already have flats would have more income left for food, travel and saving, which would reduce poverty and inequality among young people in the city.
However, a maximum price set below the equilibrium price creates excess demand. At £900, more people would want to rent their own one-bedroom flat, while fewer flats would be offered, because some landlords would find renting less profitable and sell their flats or use them for something else. The number of flats available to rent is already falling, from 12,400 to 11,900, and a cap could speed this up. The result would be a shortage: long searches, landlords choosing the tenants they prefer, and possibly illegal extra charges paid 'under the table'. Landlords whose income is capped may also stop repairing their flats, so quality falls. Students and young workers moving to the city could find it very hard to get anywhere to live, even though they are the group the policy is meant to help.
Overall, I think a maximum rent would benefit tenants who already have a flat, at least in the short run, but would harm people looking for a flat, so it would not benefit tenants as a whole for long. In the short run the supply of rented flats is quite inelastic, because flats cannot disappear overnight, so the shortage might be small at first, but it would grow as landlords leave the market. Whether the cap benefits tenants overall depends on how far below the equilibrium rent it is, how quickly landlords respond, and whether the council also increases the supply of homes, for example by building more, which would tackle the cause of high rents rather than the symptom.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer uses maximum-price analysis (a cap below equilibrium causes excess demand and a shortage) and the data (rents +33.3% vs pay +16.2%; rent rising from 42% to 48% of pay; fewer flats), weighs gains for existing tenants against losses for new tenants, and reaches a judgement that says what it depends on. Answers that only describe high rents, or ignore the table, are capped at 6 marks.