Ashgrove Ceramics makes mugs in Stoke-on-Trent. At present 20 workers glaze the mugs by hand. The company is considering buying a robotic glazing machine. With the machine, only 8 workers would be needed on the glazing line, and the other 12 would lose their jobs. The glazing line runs for 2,000 hours a year. Ashgrove sells mainly to supermarkets and gift shops and faces strong competition from cheaper imported mugs, although some customers like the fact that its mugs are glazed by hand. Figure 1 shows the company's estimates.
Using Figure 1, assess whether Ashgrove Ceramics should buy the robotic glazing machine.
Model answer
The machine would raise labour productivity on the glazing line enormously. At present 20 workers glaze 600 mugs an hour, or 30 mugs per worker per hour. With the machine, 8 workers would glaze 720 mugs an hour, or 90 per worker per hour, a 200% rise, and total output would rise by 20%. This cuts the labour cost of glazing each mug from about 47p (£280 an hour ÷ 600 mugs) to about 16p (£112 ÷ 720). Over 2,000 hours a year, the wage bill for glazing would fall from £560,000 to £224,000, a saving of £336,000, or £306,000 after the machine's £30,000 running cost. The £400,000 machine would therefore pay for itself in about 1.3 years. Lower average costs would let Ashgrove either increase its profit or cut its prices, making it more competitive against cheaper imported mugs.
However, there are important costs. £400,000 is a large sum to pay up front; if Ashgrove borrows it, it pays interest, and the money cannot be used for anything else. Twelve workers would lose their jobs, which brings redundancy costs, and it may damage the morale and productivity of the workers who stay and the firm's reputation in the local community. If the machine breaks down, the whole glazing line stops. Also, the extra 20% output is only useful if Ashgrove can sell it; otherwise it would simply produce the same number of mugs with fewer workers. Finally, if customers value hand-glazed mugs, the brand could lose some of its appeal.
Overall, I think Ashgrove should buy the machine, because the cost savings are very large and the payback period of little more than a year is short, which matters in a competitive industry. However, this depends on the estimates being accurate and on whether its mugs sell on price rather than on being hand-made. To reduce the human cost, it should try to retrain some of the 12 workers for other jobs in the factory, such as packing the extra output or quality control.
Explanation
Level 3 answers use Figure 1 to calculate the change in productivity and the cost savings (and ideally the payback period), then weigh these against the up-front cost, job losses, risks and the importance of demand. The judgement should say what it depends on. Answers that consider only the benefits, or make no use of the data, cannot score more than 6.