Figure 1 - Kerr's Cycles
Kerr's Cycles is a bike repair shop in Ashworth, a city (invented). For years it was one of only four bike repair businesses in the city. Since 2021, seven more have opened, including two mobile mechanics who repair bikes at customers' homes. To keep its customers, Kerr's has cut the price of a standard service, started online booking and begun selling refurbished bikes. The owner says: 'We are busier than ever, but we have to work harder for every pound.'
Table 1 shows data for Kerr's Cycles in 2021 and 2025.
Using Figure 1 and Table 1, assess whether increased competition has been harmful to a business such as Kerr's Cycles.
Model answer
Increased competition appears to have harmed Kerr's Cycles' profits. The number of bike repair businesses in Ashworth rose from 4 to 11, so customers can now easily switch to a rival, including mobile mechanics who come to their homes. To keep customers, Kerr's had to cut the price of a standard service from £65 to £52, a fall of 20%. Its revenue from services has not changed at all: £65 × 1,400 = £91 000 in 2021 and £52 × 1,750 = £91 000 in 2025. Yet doing 350 more services needs more staff time and parts, so costs have risen and profit has fallen from £38 000 to £29 000, about 24% lower. This is what the owner means by working harder for every pound. Lower profit leaves less money to invest in new equipment and makes the business more vulnerable if costs rise further.
On the other hand, competition has not been wholly harmful. Kerr's is busier than ever, carrying out 25% more services, which shows that it has kept its customers and attracted new ones despite seven new rivals. Competition has forced it to innovate: online booking makes it more convenient, and selling refurbished bikes gives it a new source of revenue that is not included in the service figures, so its total revenue may actually have risen. The growth in the number of repair firms may also reflect more people cycling, a growing market that Kerr's can benefit from. The business is still making a profit of £29 000.
Overall, I think competition has harmed Kerr's Cycles in the short run, because its prices and profits have been driven down, just as theory predicts for a firm in an increasingly competitive market. However, the harm is not as serious as it first looks, because the business has responded by becoming more efficient and diversifying. Whether competition is harmful in the long run depends on whether refurbished bike sales grow, whether even more firms enter the market, and whether £29 000 is enough profit for the owner to keep the business going.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer uses the data (price -20%, profit about -24%, services +25%, unchanged service revenue of £91 000) on both sides, explains why competition drives prices and profits down, and also why it can make a firm more efficient and innovative. The judgement should say whether the harm is short or long term and what it depends on. One-sided answers, or answers that ignore the table, are capped at 6 marks.