Barkwell Foods and Tailby Petcare are two UK makers of tinned dog food. They plan to merge. They say the merged firm will gain economies of scale by buying meat and tins in bulk, closing the smaller of their two factories and running one advertising campaign instead of two. However, the two firms use different suppliers, recipes and computer systems, about 300 staff would have to move to the remaining factory or leave, and the merger may be investigated by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), which can investigate a merger that creates a firm with 25% or more of the supply of a product. Figure 1 shows data about the two firms (invented data).
Using Figure 1, assess whether the merger is likely to benefit Barkwell Foods and Tailby Petcare.
Model answer
The merger could bring large benefits to the two firms. Figure 1 forecasts that the merged firm's average cost will be 55p a tin, compared with 62p at Barkwell and 66p at Tailby, falls of about 11% and 17%. These savings come from economies of scale. Buying meat and tins in much larger quantities gives the merged firm more bargaining power with suppliers, so it pays less for each unit (purchasing economies). Closing the smaller factory means the remaining factory runs at a higher output, spreading its fixed costs over more tins (technical economies), and one advertising campaign costs less per tin than two (marketing economies). If prices to shops stayed at around 80p, the profit on each tin would rise from 18p at Barkwell and 16p at Tailby to about 25p. With 32% of UK dog food sales, the merged firm would also be the largest seller, giving it more power when it negotiates with supermarkets.
However, these benefits are not certain. The 55p figure is the firms' own forecast and may be optimistic. Combining two businesses with different suppliers, recipes and computer systems can cause diseconomies of scale: communication and coordination become harder, and the 300 staff who must move or leave may be less motivated, so costs may not fall as much as hoped. Closing a factory also brings one-off costs, such as redundancy pay. Finally, a 32% share is above the 25% level at which the CMA can investigate. The CMA could delay or block the merger, or require the firms to sell a brand or a factory, which would reduce the economies of scale.
Overall, I think the merger is likely to benefit the two firms, because the forecast fall in average cost is large and comes from several different economies of scale, so even part of it would raise their profit per tin. However, the size of the benefit depends on how well the two businesses are combined, on whether the forecast savings are realistic, and on the CMA's decision: if the firms had to sell one of the brands, much of the gain could be lost.
Explanation
Level 3 answers use Figure 1 to measure the forecast cost savings and the rise in profit per tin, explain the economies of scale behind them, and weigh these against diseconomies of scale, one-off costs and the risk of a CMA investigation (32% is above the 25% test). The best judgement says what the outcome depends on. Answers that consider only the benefits, or ignore the data, cannot score more than 6.