Porthaven is a seaside town in Cornwall. Over many years, the town has specialised in tourism: its beaches, harbour and coastal paths attract visitors, and most of its businesses are hotels, holiday lets, cafés, surf schools and gift shops. The town buys most of the goods it needs, such as food, fuel and building materials, from other parts of the UK. In 2020, when holidays were stopped for several months, many businesses in the town struggled to survive.
Figure 1 shows some data about Porthaven's economy (the town and the data are invented).
Using Figure 1, assess whether specialising in tourism has been good for Porthaven's economy.
Model answer
Specialising in tourism makes sense for Porthaven because its natural resources, its beaches, harbour and coastal paths, give it an advantage that inland towns do not have. Figure 1 shows that visitors spend £310 million a year in the town and that 46% of jobs are in tourism, so the industry provides a large share of local work and income. Through exchange, the town uses the money it earns from visitors to buy the food, fuel and materials it needs from other parts of the UK, which it could not produce as cheaply itself. In the summer, unemployment is only 2.1%, showing how much work tourism creates at its peak.
However, specialisation also brings costs. Because nearly half of all jobs depend on one industry, the town is very exposed when demand falls: the case shows that when holidays stopped in 2020, many businesses struggled to survive. Tourism is also seasonal, so unemployment rises from 2.1% in August to 7.8% in February, meaning many workers have no income for part of the year. Tourism jobs pay an average of £420 a week compared with £590 in other jobs, so incomes in the town are lower than they would be with a wider range of industries, and young people looking for better-paid careers may move away. The town also depends on other places for essentials, so it is hit by rises in their prices.
Overall, I think specialising in tourism has been good for Porthaven, because it uses the town's natural advantage and brings in £310 million a year that it could not earn from other industries. But the high winter unemployment and low pay show that relying so heavily on one industry has real costs, so the town would benefit from some diversification, such as attracting remote workers or year-round events. The judgement depends on how stable demand for UK holidays remains: if another shock like 2020 happened, the costs of over-specialisation would outweigh the benefits.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer explains specialisation and exchange in Porthaven's case, uses the data on both sides (£310 million and 46% of jobs against 7.8% winter unemployment and £420 v £590 pay) and reaches a judgement that explains what it depends on. Answers that ignore the figure, or only list advantages, are capped at 6.