Since more people started working from home for part of the week, fewer office workers buy their lunch in city centres. Figure 1 shows the effect on the market for sandwiches sold in a city centre.
Using Figure 1, analyse the effects of this change on the market for city-centre sandwiches.
Model answer
Working from home is a non-price factor, so it shifts the demand curve for city-centre sandwiches to the left, from D1 to D2: fewer sandwiches are demanded at every price because there are fewer office workers in the city centre at lunchtime.
At the original price P1 there is now excess supply: sandwich shops make more sandwiches than people want to buy, so they are left with unsold stock, which is wasted because sandwiches go off quickly. To reduce this, sellers cut their prices and make fewer sandwiches. As the price falls, quantity supplied contracts along the supply curve and quantity demanded extends along D2, until a new equilibrium is reached at the lower price P2 and the smaller quantity Q2.
As a result, the total revenue of sandwich sellers falls. Revenue is price × quantity, and both have fallen, from P1 × Q1 to P2 × Q2, so the revenue rectangle is smaller on both sides. Lower revenue means lower profits, so some sandwich shops may cut opening hours or staff, or close altogether, especially on Mondays and Fridays when fewer people come into the office. If shops close, supply would also fall over time.
Sellers may respond by trying to win back demand, for example by offering delivery, loyalty schemes or meal deals. Meanwhile, demand for sandwiches near people's homes in the suburbs may increase, so the change moves business from city-centre shops to local ones.
Explanation
Top answers read the figure correctly (a leftward shift of demand, with price falling from P1 to P2 and quantity from Q1 to Q2) and develop the chain: excess supply at P1, price cuts, movements along the curves, the new equilibrium and lower revenue (P2 × Q2 is smaller than P1 × Q1). Further consequences such as closures or changes to supply reach Level 3. Confusing the shift of demand with a shift of supply is a serious error.