A psychologist wants to study the reading habits of adults who borrow books from a city library. The library's computer system lists its 4,800 members in the order in which they joined. She plans to select every 40th member on the list to obtain a sample of 120.
Explain the strengths and weaknesses of using systematic sampling. In your answer, refer to the psychologist's study of library members.
Model answer
A strength of systematic sampling is that it avoids researcher bias. Once the psychologist has decided to select every 40th member, the list decides who is chosen, so she cannot pick people she knows or people who look like keen readers. It is also quick and simple here, because the library's computer system already lists all 4,800 members, and selecting every 40th name spreads the 120 participants across the whole list. As the list is in joining order, her sample will include both long-standing and recent members, so it is more likely to be representative than an opportunity sample of people in the library on one day.
However, systematic sampling needs a complete and up-to-date list, and the library's list may still include people who have moved away or no longer borrow books. It also does not guarantee that subgroups are represented in the right proportions: by chance her 120 members might contain too few older adults or too few men, which stratified sampling would avoid. If the list had a repeating pattern that matched the interval of 40, the sample could be badly biased. Finally, some selected members may not take part, and those who do may be the most enthusiastic readers.
Overall, systematic sampling is a sensible, practical choice for this study because a full list exists and the method removes researcher bias, but the psychologist should be cautious about generalising to all library members if many of those selected do not respond.
Explanation
Level 3 answers explain both strengths (no researcher bias, quick when a list exists, spread across the list) and weaknesses (needs a complete list, subgroups not guaranteed, patterns in the list, refusals), and keep linking them to the library's list of 4,800 members. Generic points with no reference to the library study cannot gain the AO2 marks.