Piaget's stage theory and the development of intelligence
Practise 32 exam-style questions on Piaget's stage theory and the development of intelligence for AQA GCSE Psychology (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.
32 questions
1–9 marks each
Instant marking
No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go
Sample questions with model answers
Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.
Question 1
1 mark
Which one of the following describes what the teddy puppet did in McGarrigle and Donaldson's 'naughty teddy study'?
Choose your answer.
Hid behind a wall so that a policeman doll could not see him
Messed up one of two rows of counters, as if by accident
Poured juice from a short wide glass into a tall thin glass
Rolled a ball of clay into a long sausage shape
Model answer
Messed up one of two rows of counters, as if by accident
Explanation
In the 'naughty teddy study' a teddy puppet spread out one of two identical rows of counters, so that the change looked accidental rather than deliberate. Hiding from a policeman doll belongs to Hughes' study of egocentrism, and pouring liquid or rolling clay are Piaget's own conservation tasks.
Mark scheme
1 mark
Messed up one of two rows of counters, as if by accident
Accept a clear shortened form, e.g. 'messed up a row of counters'. If more than one option is given, 0 marks.
Question 2
2 marks
Which two of the following are valid criticisms of Piaget's theory of cognitive development?
Choose two answers.
He underestimated what young children are able to do He based much of his research on small, unrepresentative samples He claimed that intelligence is fixed and cannot change He said children learn mainly by copying the behaviour of adults His ideas have had very little influence on education
Model answer
He underestimated what young children are able to do He based much of his research on small, unrepresentative samples
Explanation
Research such as Hughes' and McGarrigle and Donaldson's shows that children can do some things earlier than Piaget claimed, and much of his work used small samples, including his own children, from middle-class Swiss backgrounds. Piaget saw intelligence as developing through stages, not as fixed, and learning by copying adults is not his idea. His theory strongly influenced education through readiness and discovery learning, so the last option is false.
Mark scheme
1 mark
He underestimated what young children are able to do
Supported by studies such as Hughes' 'policeman doll study' and McGarrigle and Donaldson's 'naughty teddy study'. If more than two options are given, only mark the first two.
1 mark
He based much of his research on small, unrepresentative samples
e.g. his own children and middle-class Swiss children. If more than two options are given, only mark the first two.
Question 3
4 marks
Piaget claimed that children in the pre-operational stage cannot conserve.
Outline what Piaget meant by 'conservation' and explain why he believed that pre-operational children fail conservation tasks.
Model answer
Conservation is the understanding that the quantity of something, such as its number, mass or volume, stays the same even when its appearance changes, as long as nothing is added or taken away. Piaget tested it by showing a child two identical glasses of liquid, pouring one into a taller, thinner glass and asking whether there was still the same amount.
Piaget believed that pre-operational children (about 2 to 7 years) fail because they judge by appearance rather than logic. They focus on one feature, such as the height of the liquid, and ignore another, such as the width of the glass, and they cannot mentally reverse the change. He said conservation develops at about seven, in the concrete operational stage.
Explanation
A Level 2 answer defines conservation precisely (quantity stays the same despite a change in appearance) and explains the reason for failure: judging by appearance, focusing on one feature and not mentally reversing the change. Describing a conservation task helps, but the answer must also explain why young children get it wrong. Saying only that 'young children are not old enough' is too limited.
Mark scheme
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 - 4 marks. Level 2 Clear (3-4 marks): Clear and accurate knowledge and understanding of Piaget's concept of conservation with some detail. Relevant terminology is used consistently throughout. The answer demonstrates a high level of substantiated reasoning, and is clear, coherent and focused. Level 1 Basic (1-2 marks): Limited or muddled knowledge and understanding of Piaget's concept of conservation is present. Relevant terminology is occasionally used. The answer occasionally demonstrates substantiated reasoning, but may lack clarity, coherence, focus and logical structure. 0 marks: No relevant content.
Possible content (not a checklist): conservation is understanding that the quantity of something (number, mass, volume/liquid) stays the same even when its appearance changes, as long as nothing is added or taken away; Piaget's tasks: two identical rows of counters with one row spread out; two identical glasses of liquid with one poured into a taller, thinner glass; two identical balls of clay with one rolled into a sausage; the child is asked before and after the change whether there is the same amount; pre-operational children (about 2 to 7 years) judge by appearance rather than logic; they focus on one feature (e.g. the height of the liquid or the length of the row) and ignore others (centration); they cannot mentally reverse the change; conservation develops at about seven, in the concrete operational stage. Credit other relevant content. NOTE: A definition of conservation with no explanation of why pre-operational children fail cannot reach Level 2.
Question 4
6 marks
Piaget developed many of his ideas by observing and questioning his own children in detail as they grew up.
Explain the strengths and weaknesses of using case studies in psychological research. In your answer, refer to Piaget's research with his own children.
Model answer
A case study is a detailed, in-depth study of one person or a small group, often over a long period. One strength is that case studies produce rich, detailed data. Piaget observed and questioned his own children closely, day after day, so he could record the details of their behaviour, such as when they began to search for hidden objects, which a short experiment might miss. Another strength is that a case study can follow development over time. Because Piaget watched his children as they grew, he could see how their thinking changed from one stage to the next, which helped him to build his stage theory.
However, case studies use very small samples, so the findings may not generalise. Piaget's children came from one middle-class Swiss family, so their development may not represent children from other backgrounds or cultures. Case studies can also be affected by researcher bias. As their father, Piaget may have interpreted his children's behaviour in ways that fitted his ideas, and the children may have behaved differently with him than with a stranger. His questions were also not standardised, so the research would be difficult to replicate and its reliability cannot easily be checked.
Overall, case studies were useful for generating Piaget's ideas, but his conclusions needed testing with larger, more representative samples and standardised methods, which is why later studies such as Hughes' were so important.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer explains at least one strength and one weakness of case studies in general and links each one to Piaget's research with his own children, ending with a judgement. Generic points with no reference to Piaget cannot reach the top level. Watch the balance: two-thirds of the marks are for analysis and evaluation, so do not just describe what Piaget did.
Mark scheme
6 marks
Levels of response (6 marks). AO2 - 2 marks and AO3 - 4 marks. Level 3 Detailed (5-6 marks): AO2: Clear application of knowledge and understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of using case studies to Piaget's research with his own children. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of using case studies in psychological research is effective. Any conclusions drawn are sound and fully expressed. Relevant terminology is used consistently throughout. The answer demonstrates a high level of substantiated reasoning, and is clear, coherent and focused. Level 2 Clear (3-4 marks): AO2: Reasonable application of knowledge and understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of using case studies to Piaget's research with his own children. AO3: There may be some effective analysis and evaluation of the strengths and/or weaknesses of using case studies in psychological research. There may be an attempt to draw conclusions. Relevant terminology is usually used. The answer frequently demonstrates substantiated reasoning and is clear, generally coherent and focused although structure may lack some logic. Level 1 Basic (1-2 marks): AO2: Limited application of knowledge and understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of using case studies to Piaget's research with his own children. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of the strengths and/or weaknesses of using case studies in psychological research is of limited effectiveness or may be absent. Any attempts to draw conclusions are not always successful or present. Relevant terminology is occasionally used. The answer occasionally demonstrates substantiated reasoning, but may lack clarity, coherence, focus and logical structure. 0 marks: No relevant content.
Possible content (not a checklist): AO3 strengths - case studies give rich, detailed (often qualitative) data; they can follow a person over a long period, so changes over time can be tracked; they can generate new ideas and theories. AO3 weaknesses - very small samples, so findings may not generalise; the researcher's interpretation may be biased or subjective; methods are often not standardised, so the study is hard to replicate and reliability is hard to check. AO2 - Piaget could record in detail how his children behaved, day after day; he could watch their thinking change as they grew, which helped him to build his stage theory; his children came from one middle-class Swiss family, so they may not represent children from other backgrounds or cultures; as their father he may have interpreted their behaviour to fit his ideas, and they may have behaved differently with him; his questions were not standardised and differed from child to child; conclusion, e.g. useful for generating ideas, but needed testing with larger samples. Credit other relevant content. NOTE: Answers that do not refer to Piaget's research with his own children cannot reach Level 3. NOTE: Reference to Piaget 'observing his own children' alone is not enough by itself for relevant content because it is part of the question stem.
Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.
Ctrl + Enter to check
Study HelperHints first, answers after you try
Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.