Read the following article.
BREAKFAST BOOSTS GRADES!
Researchers asked 500 Year 11 students how often they ate breakfast on school days and collected their mock exam grades. Students who ate breakfast every day had higher grades, on average, than students who rarely ate breakfast. 'Every school should make students eat breakfast,' said Dr Barraclough (fictional), who led the study.
How can your knowledge of correlation be used to explain why the headline may be misleading? Refer to the article in your answer.
Model answer
A correlation is a relationship between two co-variables that are measured rather than manipulated by the researcher. In a positive correlation, as one variable increases the other also tends to increase. Correlations show whether variables are related, but they cannot show that one variable causes a change in the other.
The study in the article is a correlation. The researchers did not decide which students ate breakfast; they simply measured how often students ate breakfast and collected their mock grades. They found a positive correlation: students who ate breakfast more often tended to have higher grades.
The headline 'Breakfast boosts grades!' is misleading because 'boosts' suggests that eating breakfast causes better grades, which a correlation cannot show. A third variable could explain both. For example, students from well-organised homes, with a regular morning routine and support with revision, may be more likely both to eat breakfast and to get good grades. The direction of the link is also unclear: students who are organised and motivated about school may be the ones who get up in time to eat breakfast.
This means Dr Barraclough's claim that schools should make students eat breakfast is not justified by this evidence. The large sample of 500 students suggests the link is worth investigating, but an experiment in which students were randomly allocated to eat breakfast or not, with other variables controlled, would be needed to test whether breakfast actually improves grades.
Explanation
Level 3 answers explain what a correlation is, show that the breakfast study is one (nothing was manipulated), and then analyse why the word 'boosts' claims a cause that the evidence cannot support, using a plausible third variable or the reverse direction. Weaker answers simply state 'correlation is not causation' without linking it to breakfast and grades.