Read the following information.
Two football fans watched the same match. Near the end, there was a collision in the penalty area and the referee did not award a penalty.
One week later, Callum, who supports the attacking team, says: 'Their defender pushed our striker over with both hands. It was a clear penalty.'
Liam, who supports the defending team, says: 'Their striker just dived. Our defender didn't even touch him.'
How can the theory of reconstructive memory be used to explain the differences between Callum's and Liam's accounts? Refer to Callum and Liam in your answer.
Model answer
The theory of reconstructive memory states that memory is not an exact copy of what happened. Instead, we store parts of an event and, when we recall it, we rebuild it using our schemas, which are our existing knowledge, beliefs and expectations. Bartlett called this 'effort after meaning': we change memories so that they make sense to us, which can make them inaccurate even though they feel true.
Callum and Liam saw the same collision, but because they support different teams they bring different expectations to it. Callum's schema is that his team's striker is often fouled, so when he reconstructs the event he adds details that fit this, such as the defender using both hands. Liam's schema is that the other team's striker dives, so he reconstructs a version in which there was no contact at all. A week has passed, so there has been more time for both memories to be rebuilt in line with what each fan believes.
The theory explains well why both fans can be confident yet give opposite accounts, and it is supported by Bartlett's War of the Ghosts study, in which people changed a story to fit their own culture. However, there may be other explanations. The fans might be deliberately biased out of loyalty rather than misremembering, they may have seen the collision from different angles, or they may have been influenced by other fans afterwards. Without a video we cannot tell which account is accurate, so reconstructive memory is a likely, but not certain, explanation.
Explanation
The top level needs all three skills: an accurate outline of reconstructive memory and schemas, a clear link from each fan's loyalty to the details he adds or removes, and analysis of how well the theory explains the accounts, including alternatives such as deliberate bias. Answers that only retell the conversation, or only describe the theory, cannot reach Level 3.