Researchers often use random allocation in independent groups designs and counterbalancing in repeated measures designs to control extraneous variables.
Describe and evaluate these two research procedures.
Model answer
Random allocation is used in independent groups designs. Each participant has an equal chance of being placed in either condition, for example by drawing names from a hat or using a random number generator, so that participant variables such as ability or motivation should be spread evenly between the groups. Counterbalancing is used in repeated measures designs. Half of the participants complete the conditions in the order A then B, and the other half in the order B then A, so that order effects such as practice or boredom are balanced out across the conditions.
One strength of random allocation is that the researcher cannot choose who goes into each condition, which removes researcher bias. Because participant variables should be spread evenly, any difference between the groups is more likely to be caused by the IV, increasing validity. However, random allocation does not guarantee equal groups: with small samples, chance could still put more able participants in one condition. It also cannot be used when the groups already exist, such as two school classes, or when the IV is a characteristic such as age.
Counterbalancing allows researchers to keep the benefits of repeated measures, where the same people take part in both conditions, while reducing the problem of order effects. However, it does not remove order effects: every participant still experiences practice or tiredness in their second condition. It only balances them out, which works if the order effects are similar in both directions.
Overall, both procedures improve validity, but neither can control extraneous variables completely.
Explanation
Level 3 answers describe both procedures accurately, including which design each is used with and what it controls, and then evaluate each one, for example that random allocation cannot guarantee equal groups and that counterbalancing balances order effects rather than removing them. Answers that only describe the procedures, or evaluate just one of them, stay in Level 2 or below.