Question 1
1 markA teacher uses a loaf of raisin bread as a model of the expanding universe. As the dough rises, every distance between two raisins doubles in 1 hour.
At the start, raisin P is 2.0 cm from raisin Q, and raisin R is 6.0 cm from raisin Q.
How does the mean speed at which raisin R moves away from raisin Q during the hour compare with the mean speed at which raisin P moves away from raisin Q?
Choose your answer.
- A one third as fast
- B the same speed
- C three times as fast
- D nine times as fast
Model answer
C
Q to P: 2.0 cm → 4.0 cm, so 2.0 cm per hour.
Q to R: 6.0 cm → 12.0 cm, so 6.0 cm per hour.
6.0 ÷ 2.0 = 3, so three times as fast.
Explanation
When everything expands by the same factor, the increase in each distance is proportional to the starting distance, so the speed at which two raisins separate is proportional to the distance between them. Astronomers see the same pattern for galaxies: the more distant a galaxy, the faster it moves away, which is evidence that the universe is expanding. Thinking that all the raisins move apart at the same speed (option B) is the commonest error.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
C / three times as fast
The only correct answer is C: in 1 hour the distance from Q to P increases from 2.0 cm to 4.0 cm (a mean speed of 2.0 cm per hour) and the distance from Q to R increases from 6.0 cm to 12.0 cm (6.0 cm per hour), so R moves away three times as fast; as with galaxies, the raisins that are further apart move apart faster. A is not correct because it is the ratio of the speeds turned upside down; B is not correct because, although every distance doubles, a larger distance increases by more in the same time; D is not correct because the ratio of the speeds is equal to the ratio of the starting distances (3), not to its square. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.