Question 1
1 markA student's theory is that an alpha particle loses some energy each time it ionises an atom, and that alpha particles ionise so many air molecules that they lose all their energy in a few centimetres of air.
She has a sealed source that emits only alpha particles, a Geiger-Müller tube and counter, and a metre rule.
Which hypothesis is based on her theory?
Choose your answer.
- A As the tube is moved away from the source, the count rate will fall steadily until it reaches background at about 1 m.
- B Beyond a few centimetres from the source, the count rate will fall sharply to the background count rate.
- C The count rate will be the same at every distance up to 1 m, because alpha particles travel in straight lines.
- D The count rate will increase as the tube is moved further away, because the alpha particles spread out.
Model answer
B
If every alpha particle loses all its energy in a few centimetres of air, then when the tube is further away than this no alpha particles reach it, so the count rate drops sharply to the background count rate.
Explanation
A hypothesis is a testable prediction that follows from a theory. Here the theory says alpha particles have a short, definite range in air, so the hypothesis is that the count rate drops to background beyond that range. The student can test it by measuring the count rate at increasing distances with the metre rule and comparing it with the background count rate.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B / beyond a few centimetres from the source, the count rate will fall sharply to the background count rate
The only correct answer is B: if the alpha particles lose all their energy in a few centimetres of air, none of them reach the tube when it is further away than this, so only background radiation is counted. A is not correct because the theory predicts that the alpha particles are all stopped within a few centimetres, not that the count falls gradually over 1 m; C is not correct because the theory says the alpha particles are stopped by the air, so the count rate cannot stay the same; D is not correct because spreading out means fewer alpha particles reach the tube further away, not more. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.