Question 1
1 markSample P and sample Q have the same activity today. Both samples emit the same type of radiation.
Half-life of the isotope in P = 2 hours
Half-life of the isotope in Q = 2 years
Which statement compares the hazard from the two samples over the next week correctly?
Choose your answer.
- A P and Q are equally hazardous over the next week, because they have the same activity today and emit the same type of radiation.
- B P is less hazardous over the next week, because its activity falls to almost zero within a day, while that of Q hardly changes.
- C P is more hazardous over the next week, because its nuclei decay faster, so from now on it emits more radiation each second than Q does.
- D Q is less hazardous over the next week, because its nuclei decay more slowly, so it emits less radiation in total than P does.
Model answer
B: today both samples emit the same amount of radiation each second. The activity of P halves every 2 hours, so within a day it has fallen to almost zero, but the activity of Q hardly changes in a week, so Q emits far more radiation over the week.
Explanation
Equal activities mean equal hazards only at that moment. The isotope with the short half-life soon decays away, while the one with the long half-life keeps emitting radiation at almost the same rate for years, so over any time longer than a few hours it is the greater hazard. This is the opposite of comparing samples that contain the same number of nuclei, where the isotope with the shorter half-life has the greater activity at the start.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B / P is less hazardous over the next week, because its activity falls to almost zero within a day, while that of Q hardly changes
The only correct answer is B: today both samples emit the same amount of radiation each second, but the activity of P halves every 2 hours, so after one day (12 half-lives) it is less than 1/4000 of today's value, while the activity of Q falls by less than 1% in a week; so Q emits far more radiation in total over the week. A is not correct because the activities are only equal at the start: the activity of P soon falls far below that of Q; C is not correct because the faster decay of P's nuclei makes its activity fall quickly, so after today P never emits more radiation each second than Q; D is not correct because Q keeps emitting radiation at almost the same rate all week, so it emits much more radiation in total than P. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.