Question 1
4 marksSource A: From a speech by Stalin to a joint meeting of the Central Committee and the Central Control Commission of the Communist Party on 23 October 1927. The leaders of the United Opposition, including Trotsky and Zinoviev, had accused the Party leadership of hiding Lenin's 'Testament' (which Stalin calls his "will"), in which Lenin had suggested removing Stalin as General Secretary. At this meeting Trotsky and Zinoviev were expelled from the Central Committee. This English translation was published in Moscow in 1954.
It is said that in that "will" Comrade Lenin suggested to the congress that in view of Stalin's "rudeness" it should consider the question of putting another comrade in Stalin's place as General Secretary. That is quite true. Yes, comrades, I am rude to those who grossly and perfidiously wreck and split the Party. I have never concealed this and do not conceal it now. Perhaps some mildness is needed in the treatment of splitters, but I am a bad hand at that. At the very first meeting of the plenum of the Central Committee after the Thirteenth Congress I asked the plenum of the Central Committee to release me from my duties as General Secretary. The congress itself discussed this question. It was discussed by each delegation separately, and all the delegations unanimously, including Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev, obliged Stalin to remain at his post. ...
The opposition is trying to use Lenin's "will" as a trump card; but it is enough to read this "will" to see that it is not a trump card for them at all. On the contrary, Lenin's "will" is fatal to the present leaders of the opposition. ...
It is characteristic that there is not a word, not a hint in the "will" about Stalin having made mistakes. It refers only to Stalin's rudeness. But rudeness is not and cannot be counted as a defect in Stalin's political line or position.
Give two things you can infer from Source A about how Stalin dealt with his opponents' use of Lenin's 'Testament' in 1927.
Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:
Model answer
What I can infer: Stalin did not deny Lenin's criticism but turned it into a sign of his strength and loyalty to the Party.
Details in the source that tell me this: He says 'That is quite true' and then boasts that he is 'rude to those who grossly and perfidiously wreck and split the Party', presenting his opponents as 'splitters'.
What I can infer: Stalin turned the Testament against the opposition by reminding the Party that it criticised them too and that they had once supported him.
Details in the source that tell me this: He says the 'will' is 'fatal to the present leaders of the opposition' and that 'Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev' had themselves 'obliged Stalin to remain at his post'.
Explanation
Top answers infer Stalin's tactics from what he says, for example that admitting Lenin's criticism and then boasting about it shows he was turning a weakness into a strength, and back each inference with a precise quotation. A common mistake is to repeat Stalin's words without saying what they suggest. Own knowledge about the Thirteenth Congress earns no marks in this question.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid inference about how Stalin dealt with his opponents' use of Lenin's 'Testament' in 1927, e.g. he admitted the criticism openly rather than denying it / he turned the criticism of his rudeness into a sign of strength against the opposition / he presented the opposition as splitters and enemies of Party unity / he claimed that the Party, and even his rivals, had chosen to keep him in office, so he had the Party's backing / he turned the Testament against the opposition leaders by pointing to what it said about them / he played down Lenin's criticism as being about manners, not policy / by 1927 Stalin felt secure enough to discuss the Testament openly.
Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. Stalin admitted Lenin's criticism instead of denying it (1). 'That is quite true' (1). Stalin turned his rudeness into a virtue, a sign of firmness against the opposition (1). 'I am rude to those who grossly and perfidiously wreck and split the Party' (1). Stalin presented his opponents as splitters who threatened Party unity (1). He speaks of 'splitters' and those who 'wreck and split the Party' (1). Stalin claimed his position rested on the Party's will, not his own ambition (1). He says he 'asked ... to be released' but 'all the delegations unanimously ... obliged Stalin to remain at his post' (1). Stalin reminded the Party that his rivals had once supported him (1). The delegations that kept him in post included 'Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev' (1). Stalin used the Testament against the opposition leaders themselves (1). He says the 'will' is 'not a trump card' for them but 'fatal to the present leaders of the opposition' (1). Stalin played down Lenin's criticism as a matter of manners rather than politics (1). 'Not a hint ... about Stalin having made mistakes'; rudeness is not 'a defect in Stalin's political line' (1). By 1927 Stalin felt strong enough to face the issue openly before the Central Committee (1). He discusses the 'will' openly and quotes Lenin's criticism himself (1). An inference must go beyond the source: 'Stalin said he was rude' or 'Stalin said he asked to resign' only repeats the source. Own knowledge (e.g. that the Testament was read only to each delegation separately in 1924, or that Trotsky was expelled from the Party in November 1927) is not an inference from the source. Accept other appropriate alternatives.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. 'That is quite true' / 'I am rude to those who grossly and perfidiously wreck and split the Party' / 'splitters' / 'obliged Stalin to remain at his post' / 'including Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev' / 'fatal to the present leaders of the opposition' / 'not a hint ... about Stalin having made mistakes'.
Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a short quotation or a close reference to Source A or its provenance). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.
-
1 mark
A second valid inference about how Stalin dealt with his opponents' use of Lenin's 'Testament' in 1927, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).
The second inference must be a different point, not the first reworded (e.g. 'he made rudeness a virtue' and 'he boasted of being rude' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for paraphrase or own knowledge.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.
Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it.