Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/16

Agriculture and collectivisation

Practise 20 exam-style questions on Agriculture and collectivisation for Edexcel GCSE History (Russia and the Soviet Union 1917-41). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 20 questions
  • 4–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

4 marks

Source B: From a secret directive sent on 22 January 1933 by the Central Committee of the Communist Party and the Council of People's Commissars (the Soviet government) to Party and government leaders in the North Caucasus, Ukraine and several regions of Russia and Belorussia (translated for this course). It was signed by Molotov, the head of the government, and by Stalin. The Kuban was part of the North Caucasus region and had a large Ukrainian population; the OGPU was the secret police. The directive was first published in the 1990s, after the Soviet archives were opened.

Information has reached the Central Committee and the Council of People's Commissars that in the Kuban and in Ukraine a mass departure of peasants 'in search of bread' has begun, to the Central Black Earth region, the Volga, the Moscow region, the Western region and Belorussia. The Central Committee and the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR have no doubt that this departure of peasants, like the departure from Ukraine last year, has been organised by enemies of Soviet power, Socialist Revolutionaries and agents of Poland, for the purpose of agitation 'through the peasants' in the northern regions of the USSR against the collective farms and against Soviet power in general. Last year the Party, Soviet and Cheka [secret police] bodies of Ukraine failed to notice this counter-revolutionary scheme of the enemies of Soviet power. This year a repetition of last year's mistake cannot be allowed.

... Second. The Central Committee and the Council of People's Commissars instruct the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine ... not to allow a mass departure of peasants from Ukraine to other regions, or entry into Ukraine from the North Caucasus.

Third. The Central Committee and the Council of People's Commissars instruct the OGPU representatives in the Moscow region, the Central Black Earth region, the Western region, Belorussia, the Lower Volga and the Middle Volga to arrest the 'peasants' of Ukraine and the North Caucasus who have made their way north and, after the counter-revolutionary elements have been picked out, to return the rest to their places of residence.

Source C: From an article by Gareth Jones, 'Ruin of Russian Agriculture', published in the Financial News, a London newspaper for business readers, on 13 April 1933. Jones, a Welsh journalist who spoke Russian, had walked through villages in the USSR in March 1933. It was the third of three articles in which he assessed the results of the First Five-Year Plan.

In the eyes of responsible foreign observers and of peasants, the famine in Russia to-day is far worse than that of 1921. ...

The writer has visited villages in the Moscow district, in the Black Earth district, and in North Ukraine, parts, which are far from being the most badly hit in Russia. He has collected evidence from peasants and foreign observers and residents concerning the Ukraine, Crimea, North Caucasia, Nijni-Novgorod district, West Siberia, Kazakstan, Tashkent area, the German Volga and Ukrainian colonists, and all the evidence proves that there is a general famine threatening the lives of millions of people. The Soviet Government tries its best to conceal the situation, but the grim facts will out. ...

What are the causes of the famine? The main reason for the catastrophe in Russian agriculture is the Soviet policy of collectivisation. ... In the first place, the policy of creating large collective farms, where the land was to be owned and cultivated in common, led to the land being taken away from more than two-thirds of the peasantry, and incentive to work disappeared. Moreover, last year nearly all the crops were violently seized, and the peasant was left almost nothing for himself.

Interpretation 1: From Hunger Across the Union: The Soviet Famine of 1932-33 by Graham Tunnicliffe (fictional), published in 1999.

The famine of 1932-33 struck many parts of the Soviet Union, not Ukraine alone. Kazakhstan lost a larger share of its people than any other republic, and there was mass starvation in the North Caucasus, along the Volga and in western Siberia. Everywhere the causes were much the same. Forced collectivisation had destroyed the peasants' will to work and much of the livestock, the harvest of 1932 was poor, and Moscow went on demanding grain at almost any cost to feed the towns and the army and to pay for imports. Stalin was ruthless and indifferent to the lives of peasants, and he refused to admit that there was a famine at all. But the evidence suggests that his aim was to extract grain, not to destroy a nation.

Interpretation 2: From The Black Years: Ukraine and the Famine by Catherine Nettleford (fictional), published in 2015.

In Ukraine the famine was made far worse by decisions aimed at Ukrainians and at Ukraine itself. Stalin feared that he might 'lose Ukraine', and he treated the failure to meet grain targets there as sabotage by nationalists. In late 1932 villages that fell behind were put on blacklists and cut off from all supplies, and in January 1933 peasants were stopped from leaving Ukraine and the Kuban to look for food. At the same time the Ukrainian Communist Party was purged, and policies that had encouraged the Ukrainian language and culture were reversed. For many historians, and for Ukraine itself, which officially recognises the famine, the Holodomor, as genocide, these measures show a deliberate attack on the Ukrainian nation.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about whether the famine of 1932-33 was deliberately directed against Ukraine. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 2 seems to have relied on evidence like Source B, the secret directive of January 1933. It singles out peasants from 'in the Kuban and in Ukraine', blames their flight on 'agents of Poland' and other 'enemies of Soviet power', and orders that they be stopped from leaving and arrested if they reach the north. This fits Interpretation 2's view that Stalin treated Ukraine's problems as 'sabotage by nationalists' and that 'in January 1933 peasants were stopped from leaving Ukraine and the Kuban'. The author of Interpretation 1 is closer to evidence like Source C, in which Jones describes 'a general famine' with evidence from the North Caucasus, West Siberia, Kazakhstan and the Volga, caused by collectivisation and by crops being 'violently seized'. This matches Interpretation 1's view that the famine 'struck many parts of the Soviet Union, not Ukraine alone' and that the causes were 'much the same' everywhere.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details: the directive's measures against peasants from Ukraine and the Kuban with Interpretation 2, and Jones's evidence of famine across many regions with Interpretation 1. Weaker answers simply say which source each historian 'used', or describe the difference again. Remember that historians still disagree about Stalin's intentions, so a reason based on 'one historian is biased' is not valid.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different evidence. Source B supports Interpretation 2: the directive of 22 January 1933, signed by Stalin and Molotov, singles out peasants from 'in the Kuban and in Ukraine', blames their search for food on 'enemies of Soviet power, Socialist Revolutionaries and agents of Poland', criticises the Ukrainian Party and police for failing to stop it 'last year', and orders that peasants be kept in Ukraine and the North Caucasus and arrested if they reach the north; this matches Interpretation 2's view that Stalin saw Ukraine's problems as 'sabotage by nationalists' and that 'in January 1933 peasants were stopped from leaving Ukraine and the Kuban'. Source C supports Interpretation 1: Jones reports evidence of 'a general famine' from many regions, including 'Crimea, North Caucasia ... West Siberia, Kazakstan' and the Volga, and names collectivisation and the violent seizure of 'nearly all the crops' as the causes; this matches Interpretation 1's view that the famine 'struck many parts of the Soviet Union, not Ukraine alone' and that the causes 'were much the same' everywhere: collectivisation and Moscow's demand for grain. The interpretations may differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 compares Ukraine with other regions, especially Kazakhstan, and looks at the causes common to them all, while Interpretation 2 concentrates on measures that applied to Ukraine and the Kuban. They may differ because they use different kinds of evidence: secret orders from Moscow that were first published in the 1990s (like Source B) against reports from observers at the time (like Source C), which could see the suffering but not the decisions behind it. They may differ because they ask different questions: Interpretation 1 asks what Stalin's main aim was (to extract grain), Interpretation 2 asks what the effect of his measures was on Ukrainians as a nation. Historians still disagree about intent; both interpretations accept that the famine was man-made and that Stalin's policies caused it. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 2 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view without explaining it, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.

Question 2

4 marks

Source B: From a speech by Stalin to the First All-Union Congress of Collective-Farm Shock Workers (the best workers of the collective farms) in Moscow on 19 February 1933, at the height of the famine. The 'scramble and injustice' were the old divisions between rich and poor peasants in the villages. This English translation was published in Moscow in 1947 in Problems of Leninism, a collection of Stalin's writings.

By developing collective-farm construction we have succeeded in abolishing this scramble and injustice; we have smashed the yoke of kulak bondage, brought this vast mass of poor peasants into the collective farms, given them material security there, and raised them to the level of middle peasants, having at their disposal collective-farm land, enjoying the privileges granted to collective farms and the use of tractors and agricultural machinery.

And what does this mean? It means that no less than twenty million of the peasant population, no less than twenty million poor peasants have been rescued from poverty and ruin, have been rescued from kulak bondage, and have attained material security thanks to the collective farms. ...

Of course, not so long ago, the Soviet government had a slight misunderstanding with the women collective farmers. That was over the cow. But now this business about the cow has been settled, and the misunderstanding has been removed. ... We have reached the position where the majority of the collective farm households have a cow each.

Source C: From an article by Gareth Jones published in the Western Mail, a newspaper in Cardiff, on 10 April 1931. Jones, a Welsh journalist who spoke Russian, had spent three weeks in the USSR in the summer of 1930. Here he describes a conversation on a train crossing the North Caucasus and then sums up the difficulties facing the Soviet government in the countryside.

Two peasants, in their rough sheepskin coats, were furious. The train rattled along across the North Caucasian steppes. We were talking about the Soviet policy of making the peasants give up their land and join collective farms. "It's a dog's life," they said. "It would be better to be under the earth than to live now. They force us to join collective farms. The very best, those who worked day and night, were sent to Siberia and the Urals, and their houses were taken from them. They won't let us keep more than one cow. What's the use of working? It's terrible." ...

In agriculture the Government have had to face the opposition of masses of the peasants. There are probably at this moment many Communists being murdered in the villages ... The wholesale massacre of cattle and pigs which followed upon the violent campaign of collectivisation a year ago has caused a shortage of live-stock which will affect Russia for several years.

Interpretation 1: From New Lives in the Collective Farm by Kenneth Easterbrook (fictional), published in 1979.

Not all peasants opposed the collective farms. For many of the poorest villagers, landless labourers and families without a horse, the collective farm offered something: a share of land and machinery, an end to dependence on richer neighbours, and new jobs as tractor drivers, brigade leaders and clerks, many of them filled by young people and women. Some young peasants, educated in Soviet schools and the Communist Youth League, saw collectivisation as progress. Once the government allowed collective farmers to keep household plots and cows of their own, many families came to accept the new system, even if they never loved it.

Interpretation 2: From The Silent Village: Peasants and Collectivisation by Louise Frobisher (fictional), published in 2008.

The great majority of peasants, rich and poor alike, hated the collective farms. They joined because they were afraid: they had seen their neighbours deported as 'kulaks', and they knew that anyone who refused could be next. Peasants called the new system a 'second serfdom'. They showed their feelings by slaughtering their animals, by working as little as possible in the collective fields, and by leaving whenever they could: when Stalin allowed them to leave in March 1930, millions did so within months. What looked like acceptance was the silence of people who had no choice.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the attitudes of peasants to the collective farms in the years 1930-33. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which Stalin claims that collectivisation had 'smashed the yoke of kulak bondage' and that 'no less than twenty million poor peasants' had been 'rescued from poverty and ruin', and that the 'misunderstanding' over 'the cow' had been settled. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the collective farm gave the poorest peasants 'an end to dependence on richer neighbours' and that families accepted it once they could keep 'household plots and cows of their own'. The author of Interpretation 2 seems to have used evidence like Source C, in which peasants tell Jones 'They force us to join collective farms', that the hardest workers 'were sent to Siberia', and ask 'What's the use of working?', while Jones describes 'the wholesale massacre of cattle and pigs'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that peasants joined 'because they were afraid' and showed their hatred by slaughtering animals and working 'as little as possible'.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details, such as Stalin's 'twenty million poor peasants' with Interpretation 1 and the angry peasants on Jones's train with Interpretation 2. Answers can also explain differences of focus, for example the poorest and youngest peasants against the majority. Simply saying that one historian 'used' a source, or describing the difference again, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Stalin claims that collectivisation 'smashed the yoke of kulak bondage', gave the poor peasants 'material security' and the use of 'tractors and agricultural machinery', that 'no less than twenty million poor peasants' had been 'rescued from poverty and ruin', and that the 'misunderstanding' with women over 'the cow' had been settled, with 'the majority of the collective farm households' having a cow; this matches Interpretation 1's view that for the poorest villagers the collective farm 'offered something', including 'an end to dependence on richer neighbours', and that families accepted the system once they could keep 'household plots and cows of their own'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: the peasants on the train are 'furious', say 'They force us to join collective farms', that the hardest workers 'were sent to Siberia and the Urals', and ask 'What's the use of working?', while Jones reports 'the opposition of masses of the peasants', Communists 'murdered in the villages' and 'the wholesale massacre of cattle and pigs'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that peasants joined 'because they were afraid', 'had seen their neighbours deported', slaughtered their animals and worked 'as little as possible'. A student may note that Source B was a public speech by Stalin to selected 'shock workers' at the height of the famine, which an author like the author of Interpretation 2 would treat with suspicion, while Source C records what peasants said privately. The interpretations may also differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 concentrates on particular groups (the poorest, the young, women given new jobs) and on the later concessions (plots and cows), while Interpretation 2 generalises about 'the great majority of peasants, rich and poor alike' and about the period of forced collectivisation. They may differ because they treat outward behaviour differently: Interpretation 1 takes joining and staying as a sign of acceptance, while Interpretation 2 sees 'the silence of people who had no choice'. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.

Question 3

12 marks

Explain why there was widespread peasant opposition to collectivisation in the years 1929-33.

You may use the following in your answer:
- the seizure of livestock
- the closing of village churches

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

There was widespread peasant opposition to collectivisation in 1929-33 because it took away the peasants' land, animals and independence, attacked their religion, and was carried out by force.

Firstly, collectivisation took away what the revolution had given the peasants. In 1917-18 they had seized the landlords' estates and divided the land among their families. Now their strips were merged into large collective fields and the village commune, which had run village life for centuries, was abolished in 1930. To many peasants this felt like a return to serfdom, and some joked that the initials of the Communist Party stood for 'the second serfdom'.

Secondly, the seizure of livestock struck at the heart of peasant life. Horses, cows and tools were handed over to the collective farm, and in early 1930 some officials even took chickens and pigs. Women in particular fought to keep their family cow, which fed their children. Rather than give their animals away for nothing, millions of peasants slaughtered them: by Stalin's own figures the number of horses fell by about half between 1929 and 1933.

Thirdly, collectivisation was accompanied by an attack on religion. Church bells were removed, churches were closed and priests arrested. For peasants whose lives centred on the Church this was an outrage, and rumours spread that the collective farm was the work of the Antichrist. Even Stalin, in 'Dizzy with Success', mocked officials who began by 'removing the church bells'.

Fourthly, peasants opposed it because it was forced on them. Although it was meant to be voluntary, Party activists, workers sent from the towns and the OGPU used threats, and anyone who refused could be labelled a 'kulak' and deported. By March 1930 over half of all households had been pushed into collective farms in a few months, without the tractors that had been promised.

Finally, collective farming offered peasants little reward. The state took most of the harvest, especially in 1932, and pay in 'labour days' was uncertain and small, so many saw no reason to work hard.

The result was resistance on a huge scale. In 1930 the OGPU recorded over 13,000 riots and protests, many led by women, and when Stalin allowed peasants to leave the collective farms in March 1930, millions did so. Opposition was widespread because collectivisation threatened almost everything that mattered to the peasants.

Explanation

Top answers explain why peasants opposed collectivisation, linking each reason (loss of land, seizure of animals, the attack on the Church, force and poor rewards) to its effect on peasant life, and use the forms of resistance as evidence rather than as a list. They go beyond the two stimulus points with reasons such as the loss of the land gained in 1917 or the fear of being labelled a kulak. Avoid suggesting that only kulaks resisted.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Loss of land: peasants had gained the landlords' land in 1917-18 and saw collectivisation as taking it back; the village commune (mir) was abolished in 1930 and strips and boundaries were swept away. Seizure of livestock and tools: horses, cows and implements were 'socialised', and in early 1930 some officials took even poultry and small animals; peasants, especially women, defended their cows; many slaughtered animals rather than hand them over (Stalin's own figures show horses falling from about 34 million in 1929 to about 17 million in 1933 and cattle from about 68 to about 38 million; credit as evidence of opposition when linked). Attack on the Church: church bells were removed (Stalin mocked this in 'Dizzy with Success'), churches closed and priests arrested, which offended deeply held beliefs; rumours spread that the collective farm was the work of the Antichrist. Force and fear: collectivisation was 'voluntary' only in name; Party activists, urban workers (the 25,000ers) and the OGPU used threats, and peasants who refused could be labelled kulaks or 'kulak henchmen' and deported; dekulakisation removed respected neighbours. Loss of independence and pay: collective farmers lost control of their work and harvest; grain procurement took most of the crop, especially in 1932; pay in 'labour days' was uncertain and often small; peasants called the system a 'second serfdom'. Speed and chaos: in a few months of 1929-30 the share of households in collective farms rose to over half (about 58 per cent by 1 March 1930), without machines or preparation. Forms and scale of opposition (credit when linked to reasons): the OGPU recorded over 13,000 mass disturbances in 1930 involving about two million or more peasants; women's riots (bab'i bunty); attacks on officials; mass withdrawals after 'Dizzy with Success' (down to about a quarter of households by the autumn of 1930); passive resistance and theft in 1932-33; armed revolts in parts of Ukraine, the North Caucasus and Central Asia; in Kazakhstan the forced settlement of nomads caused mass flight. Answers that only list forms of resistance without explaining why peasants opposed collectivisation should not go beyond Level 2. Do not credit claims that only the kulaks opposed collectivisation or that most peasants joined willingly.

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 4

20 marks

Interpretation 1: From Tractors on the Steppe: The Mechanisation of Soviet Farming by Howard Illingworth (fictional), published in 1974.

The machine was the great promise of collectivisation, and by 1941 that promise had largely been kept. In 1928 Soviet agriculture had about 27,000 tractors; by 1940 it had over half a million, together with about 180,000 combine harvesters, almost none of which had existed before. Most of these machines were concentrated in some 7,000 Machine Tractor Stations, which ploughed, sowed and harvested for the collective farms and trained hundreds of thousands of tractor drivers and mechanics. The new tractor works at Stalingrad, Kharkov and Chelyabinsk supplied the countryside on a scale no peasant could have imagined in 1928. The large fields of the collective farms made it possible to use machines that could never have worked on the old peasant strips. Mechanisation was the foundation on which Soviet agriculture was rebuilt.

Interpretation 2: From The Machine and the Commissar by Rachel Ibbotson (fictional), published in 2006.

Mechanisation achieved far less than Soviet propaganda claimed. The new tractors did little more than replace the horses that had been slaughtered or had died in 1929-33, and for most of the 1930s the total draught power available to Soviet farms was hardly greater than in 1929. Many tractors stood idle for lack of spare parts, fuel or trained drivers, and much of the work in the fields was still done by hand and by horse. The real importance of the Machine Tractor Stations was political. The collective farms had to pay them in grain for their work, which became one of the ways in which the state took the harvest, and in 1933-34 each station had a political department to watch over the farms it served. The MTS were less a tool of modern farming than a tool of control.

How far do you agree with Interpretation 2 about the importance of mechanisation for Soviet agriculture in the years 1929-41? Explain your answer, using both interpretations and your knowledge of the historical context.

Spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this question.

Model answer

Interpretation 2 argues that mechanisation 'achieved far less than Soviet propaganda claimed' and that the Machine Tractor Stations were 'less a tool of modern farming than a tool of control'. I largely agree with it for the years before 1935, but it underestimates how far mechanisation had changed Soviet farming by 1941.

Interpretation 2 is convincing about the early 1930s. When peasants were forced into collective farms, millions of animals were slaughtered: by Stalin's own figures the number of horses fell from about 34 million in 1929 to about 17 million in 1933. The first tractors therefore mainly filled the gap left by the lost horses, which is why historians estimate that the total draught power on Soviet farms was not much greater than in 1929 for much of the decade. Many machines broke down, and in 1933 Stalin himself admitted that tractors were 'badly utilized'. Interpretation 2 is also right that the MTS were political. They, not the farms, owned the machines, the farms paid them in grain, and in January 1933 each MTS was given a political department that could purge collective-farm officials. In the middle of the famine, these departments helped to make sure that grain reached the state.

However, Interpretation 1 is right that mechanisation grew on a huge scale. Agriculture had only about 27,000 tractors in 1928 but over half a million by 1940, and the number of MTS rose from about 2,500 at the end of 1932 to about 7,000 by 1940. New tractor factories at Stalingrad, Kharkov and Chelyabinsk supplied them, and hundreds of thousands of young peasants were trained as tractor and combine drivers. By the late 1930s much of the ploughing, sowing and threshing in the grain regions was done by machine, and the large collective fields made this possible, as Interpretation 1 says.

The interpretations differ because of the evidence they choose. Interpretation 1 uses impressive figures of growth and calls mechanisation a 'foundation', while Interpretation 2 measures tractors against the horses that were lost and stresses control, describing the MTS as 'a tool of control'.

Overall, I agree with Interpretation 2 more than Interpretation 1, using the criterion of what mechanisation actually added to Soviet farming in the 1930s. Because tractors at first only replaced lost horses, their main importance before 1935 was as a means of controlling the farms and collecting grain. By 1941, however, mechanisation had grown so much that Interpretation 1 is right that it had laid the basis for modern Soviet agriculture.

Explanation

Top answers test Interpretation 2's claims with precise knowledge, comparing the growth in tractors with the loss of horses and explaining how the MTS controlled the farms through ownership of machines, payments in grain and the political departments of 1933-34. They use Interpretation 1's figures as the counter-argument and reach a judgement with clear criteria, perhaps that the answer changes over the decade. Weaker answers describe the MTS without engaging with the interpretations.

Mark scheme
  1. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO4: 16 marks.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation reviewing the alternative views in coming to a substantiated judgement. Precise analysis of the interpretations is shown, indicating how the differences of view are conveyed and deploying this material to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is precisely selected to support the evaluation. An overall judgment is justified and the line of reasoning is coherent, sustained and logically structured.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation, agreeing or disagreeing with the interpretation. Good analysis of the interpretations is shown indicating difference of view and deploying this to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is used directly to support the evaluation. An overall judgement is given with some justification and a line of reasoning is generally sustained.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Answer offers valid evaluative comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Some analysis is shown in selecting and including details from both interpretations to support this comment. Some relevant contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation. An overall judgement is given but its justification is insecure or undeveloped and a line of reasoning is not sustained.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Answer offers simple valid comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Limited analysis of one interpretation is shown by selection and inclusion of some detail in the form of simple paraphrase or direct quotation. Generalised contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Interpretation 2 argues that mechanisation achieved 'far less than Soviet propaganda claimed' and that the main importance of the MTS was political control. Points that support Interpretation 2: the number of horses fell from about 34 million in 1929 to about 17 million in 1933 (Stalin's figures of 1934; accept 'about half'), so the first tractors mainly replaced lost draught power; historians estimate that total draught power (animals and tractors together) was not much greater than in 1929 until the later 1930s (accept a general statement); breakdowns, shortages of spare parts and fuel, poor maintenance and untrained drivers were common (Stalin himself said in 1933 that machines and tractors were 'badly utilized'); harvesting, weeding and much else were still done by hand, and horses were still widely used in 1941; the collective farms paid the MTS in kind (in grain) for their work, which became a growing part of state grain collections; political departments (politotdely) were set up in the MTS in January 1933, with powers to purge collective-farm officials, and were absorbed into the ordinary Party structure at the end of 1934; the MTS, not the farms, owned the machines, so farms depended on the state; the 'grain front' remained under state command. Points that counter it (including Interpretation 1): tractors in agriculture rose from about 27,000 in 1928 to about 530,000 in 1940 (accept about half a million) and combine harvesters to about 180,000; the number of MTS grew from a few dozen in 1929 to about 2,500 at the end of 1932 and about 7,000 by 1940; new tractor plants at Stalingrad (1930), Kharkov (1931) and Chelyabinsk (1933); the MTS trained large numbers of tractor and combine drivers (Stalin claimed in 1934 that about 1.9 million tractor drivers, combine operators and other specialists had been trained); large collective fields allowed machinery to be used; ploughing, sowing and threshing in the grain regions were increasingly mechanised by the late 1930s; harvests improved after 1934, with record official figures in 1937. How the views are conveyed: Interpretation 1 uses figures of growth and words such as 'great promise' and 'foundation'; Interpretation 2 compares tractors with the horses lost and uses the image of 'a tool of control'. A substantiated judgement might argue that mechanisation was real and grew fast but at first only made up for the losses of 1929-33, so its main importance in the 1930s was as a means of state control and grain collection; or that by 1941 it had laid the basis of modern farming; credit any reasoned judgement supported from both interpretations and own knowledge, with clear criteria (output, draught power, efficiency, control). Answers that describe the MTS without analysing the interpretations, or that judge their reliability, should not go beyond Level 2. Do not credit claims that collective farms owned their own tractors in the 1930s or that horses had disappeared by 1941.

    Pearson's marking instructions (part of the mark scheme): No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the interpretations. In all levels, the second sentence relates to analysis and while the rest relate to evaluation. The following rules will apply: In Level 1, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis without evidence of evaluation should be awarded 1 mark. In other levels, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis (but that also fully meet the descriptors for evaluation of the level below) should be awarded no more than the bottom mark in the level.

  2. 4 marks

    SPaG. Spelling, punctuation, grammar and the use of specialist terminology (4 marks).
    High performance (4 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with effective control of meaning overall. Learners use a wide range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with general control of meaning overall. Learners use a good range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Threshold performance (1 mark): Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with some control of meaning and any errors do not significantly hinder meaning overall. Learners use a limited range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    0 marks: The learner writes nothing. The learner's response does not relate to the question. The learner's achievement in SPaG does not reach the threshold performance level, e.g. errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar severely hinder meaning.

    SPaG is marked separately from the 16 marks for the answer, on the whole response.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.