Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a report sent by David R. Francis, the American Ambassador in Russia, to the US Secretary of State, 17 April 1917 (Western calendar; 4 April in the Russian calendar). Francis printed the report in his memoirs, Russia from the American Embassy, published in 1921. The 'Workingmen and Soldiers' Deputies' were the Petrograd Soviet.
For a week or ten days after our recognition of the Provisional Government the tension continued very great, as the Council of Ministers or Provisional Government was trying to establish itself but was so fearful of the consequences of a test of strength with the Workingmen and Soldiers' Deputies that it proceeded very cautiously. The soldiers were permitted to parade with banners and bands throughout the city and the workingmen if returning to work at all were making unreasonable demands as to wages and hours and in some or many instances were selecting their own foremen. There has been, however, no contest between these two authorities up to this time and I think there is likely to be none. The Provisional Government or Council of Ministers has been gaining strength from day to day; ... the entire situation is much better than it has been at any day since March 12th, when the first regiment mutinied. ... On Friday last, April 13th, this body [the Soviet's representatives] passed by an overwhelming majority a resolution favoring a vigorous prosecution of the war to a successful issue and either the same day or the day after adopted another resolution endorsing the Provisional Government.
Source C: From a letter written by Sir George Buchanan, the British Ambassador in Petrograd, to the Foreign Office in London on 21 May 1917 (Western calendar; 8 May in the Russian calendar). Buchanan published it in his memoirs, My Mission to Russia, in 1923. The 'note to the Powers' was Milyukov's note to the Allies about Russia's war aims, which led to protests in Petrograd in April 1917.
The last two weeks have been very anxious ones, as the victory which the Government had won over the Soviet in the matter of the note to the Powers was not nearly so complete as Miliukoff had imagined. So long as the Soviet maintained its exclusive right to dispose of the troops, the Government, as Prince Lvoff remarked, was 'an authority without power,' while the Workmen's Council was 'a power without authority.' Under such conditions it was impossible for Guchkoff, as Minister of War, and for Korniloff, as military governor of Petrograd, to accept responsibility for the maintenance of discipline in the army. They both, consequently, resigned, while the former declared that if things were to continue as they were the army would cease to exist as a fighting force in three weeks' time. Guchkoff's resignation precipitated matters, and Lvoff, Kerensky and Tereschenko came to the conclusion that, as the Soviet was too powerful a factor to be either suppressed or disregarded, the only way of putting an end to the anomaly of a dual Government was to form a Coalition.
Interpretation 1: From The Hopeful Spring: Russia, March-April 1917 by Owen Tredgold (fictional), published in 1977.
In its first weeks the Provisional Government enjoyed more support than any Russian government had known for years. Generals, civil servants and local councils accepted its authority, and Russia's allies hurried to recognise it. The leaders of the Petrograd Soviet, most of them Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries, had no wish to rule; they promised to support the new ministers as long as they kept to the programme agreed in March, and in the early spring the Soviets voted to back both the government and the defence of the country. 'Dual Control' existed, but in these weeks it worked more as an uneasy partnership than as a contest, and many observers believed that the government's position was growing stronger.
Interpretation 2: From Two Masters: Government and Soviet in 1917 by Miriam Pellatt (fictional), published in 2001.
From its first day the Provisional Government held office but not power. The men with rifles in the capital - the soldiers of the garrison and the armed workers of the factory districts - looked to the Petrograd Soviet, not to the ministers. Order Number 1 told the troops to obey the Duma's Military Commission (and so the new government) only when its orders did not contradict the Soviet's. Ministers could not move a single regiment without the Soviet's agreement. When they tried to act alone, as Milyukov did over Russia's war aims in April, soldiers and workers poured onto the streets and he was soon forced out of office. By May the government had to bring Soviet leaders into the cabinet simply to survive.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how much authority the Provisional Government had under 'Dual Control' in the spring of 1917. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason the interpretations differ is that their authors have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1, which argues that 'Dual Control' worked as 'an uneasy partnership' and that the government's position seemed to be 'growing stronger', fits evidence like Source B. Francis reported in April 1917 that there had been 'no contest between these two authorities', that the government 'has been gaining strength from day to day' and that the Soviet's representatives had voted for a resolution 'endorsing the Provisional Government'. Interpretation 2, which argues that the government 'held office but not power', fits Source C. Buchanan reported in May that, because the Soviet had the 'exclusive right to dispose of the troops', the government was 'an authority without power' and had to form a coalition because the Soviet was too powerful to be 'suppressed or disregarded'. The authors also focus on different periods: Interpretation 1 on the first weeks, Interpretation 2 on the whole spring, including the April crisis.
Explanation
Full marks need a reason that is explained and supported by matching details from a source and an interpretation, such as Francis's 'no contest between these two authorities' and Interpretation 1's 'uneasy partnership'. Showing that each author focuses on a different period is another valid reason. Simply saying 'the author used Source B' or 'the author is biased', or repeating the difference between the views, does not answer the question.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: Francis reports 'no contest between these two authorities', that the government 'has been gaining strength from day to day' and that the Soviet's representatives voted for the war and for 'a resolution endorsing the Provisional Government', which matches Interpretation 1's 'uneasy partnership', the Soviets voting 'to back both the government and the defence of the country' and the view that the government 'was growing stronger'. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: Buchanan reports Lvov's remark that the government was 'an authority without power', that the Soviet had the 'exclusive right to dispose of the troops' and was 'too powerful a factor to be either suppressed or disregarded', and that a coalition had to be formed, which matches Interpretation 2's 'held office but not power', ministers unable to 'move a single regiment' and the coalition formed 'simply to survive'. The interpretations may differ because they focus on different periods: Interpretation 1 concentrates on the first weeks ('in these weeks'), before the April crisis, while Interpretation 2 covers the whole spring, including Milyukov's note and the May coalition. They may differ because of a different emphasis: Interpretation 1 looks at who accepted the government's authority (generals, officials, allies, Soviet leaders), Interpretation 2 at who controlled force in Petrograd (the garrison, Order Number 1). Answers that simply assert that one author used Source B, or that one author is biased, without matching details from both a source and an interpretation, stay in Level 1. Reasons based only on the dates of publication or the titles of the books are not valid unless substantiated from the content. Repeating the main difference between the views (the DIFF4 task) without suggesting a reason scores 0. 'Dual Control' (the specification's term) is also called 'dual power'; accept either.