Question 1
4 marksSource B: From 'A Letter to American Workingmen', written by Lenin in Moscow on 20 August 1918 and published in the Bolshevik newspaper Pravda two days later. This English translation was published in New York in December 1918. Ten days after writing the letter, Lenin was shot and wounded. The dates 1649 and 1793 refer to the English and French revolutions.
Its [the bourgeoisie's] servants charge us with the use of terroristic methods. - Have the English forgotten their 1649, the French their 1793? Terror was just and justified when it was employed by the bourgeoisie for its own purposes against feudal domination. But terror becomes criminal when workingmen and poverty stricken peasants dare to use it against the bourgeoisie. Terror was just and justified when it was used to put one exploiting minority in the place of another. But terror becomes horrible and criminal when it is used to abolish all exploiting minorities, when it is employed in the cause of the actual majority, in the cause of the proletariat and the semi-proletariat, of the working-class and the poor peasantry.
Source C: From My Disillusionment in Russia by Emma Goldman, published in the USA in 1923. Goldman was an anarchist who was deported from the USA to Soviet Russia in December 1919. At first she supported the Bolsheviks, but she left Russia, disillusioned, in December 1921. Here she describes what she learned in Petrograd in 1920. Zorin was a Communist official in Petrograd, and Goldman had met Lenin in Moscow. In January 1920 the Soviet government had announced that it was abolishing the death penalty.
But, then - had not Zorin told me that capital punishment had been abolished in Russia? Yet I learned shortly after my arrival that hundreds of people had been shot on the very eve of the day when the new decree went into effect, and that as a matter of fact shooting by the Tcheka had never ceased. ... And then, was not Lenin also guilty of the same methods? "Anarchists of ideas ... are not in our prisons," he had assured me. Yet at that very moment numerous Anarchists filled the jails of Moscow and Petrograd and of many other cities in Russia. In May, 1920, scores of them had been arrested in Petrograd, among them two girls of seventeen and nineteen years of age. None of the prisoners were charged with counter-revolutionary activities: they were "Anarchists of ideas," to use Lenin's expression. Several of them had issued a manifesto for the First of May, calling attention to the appalling conditions in the factories of the Socialist Republic.
Interpretation 1: From The Terror of Class: Russia, 1918-21 by Walter Kexby (fictional), published in 1983.
The Red Terror was, as its makers openly said, a class terror. Its targets were the old propertied and ruling classes: nobles, landowners, factory owners, merchants, priests, and the officers and officials of the tsar. When the Cheka took hostages after the attack on Lenin, it took them from the 'bourgeoisie'. One Cheka leader, Martin Latsis, even told his officers to ask first what class a suspect came from rather than look for evidence of what he had done. The Bolsheviks believed that the revolution would be safe only when these classes had lost their wealth and power for ever, and the terror was their means of breaking them.
Interpretation 2: From Any Critic an Enemy: The Victims of the Red Terror by Harriet Nafferton (fictional), published in 2015.
The Bolsheviks described the Red Terror as a war on the bourgeoisie, but its victims were far more varied. Socialists who had spent years fighting the tsar - Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries and anarchists - filled the Cheka's prisons. Workers who went on strike and peasants who resisted grain requisitioning were arrested, taken as hostages or shot, and the families of deserters were held to force them to return. The terror did not end when the Whites were defeated. In practice, anyone who criticised or resisted Bolshevik rule, whatever their class, could become an 'enemy of the people'.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about who the Red Terror was aimed at. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on what the Bolshevik leaders said about the terror, like Source B, where Lenin defends terror used 'against the bourgeoisie' 'to abolish all exploiting minorities'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that it was 'a class terror' aimed at 'the old propertied and ruling classes'. The author of Interpretation 2 may have relied on accounts of who was actually arrested, like Source C, where Goldman describes 'numerous Anarchists' in prison, not for 'counter-revolutionary activities' but for complaining about 'the appalling conditions in the factories'. This supports Interpretation 2's claim that socialists and anarchists 'filled the Cheka's prisons' and that anyone who 'criticised' Bolshevik rule could become a victim.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason, such as the use of different sources or a different focus (the Bolsheviks' stated aims v. the real victims), and prove it by matching specific details in the sources to specific details in the interpretations. Simply saying that one historian 'used Source B', or repeating the difference between the views, is not enough for Level 2.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Different weight given to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Lenin presents terror as something used 'against the bourgeoisie', 'to abolish all exploiting minorities', in the cause of 'the working-class and the poor peasantry', which matches Interpretation 1's view of 'a class terror' aimed at 'the old propertied and ruling classes'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Goldman describes 'numerous Anarchists' filling the jails, arrested not for 'counter-revolutionary activities' but for a manifesto about 'the appalling conditions in the factories', and says shooting 'had never ceased', which matches Interpretation 2's claim that socialists and anarchists 'filled the Cheka's prisons', that anyone who 'criticised' could become a victim, and that the terror 'did not end'. A historian relying on what the Bolsheviks said about the terror (like Source B) would see it as class war; one relying on accounts of who was actually arrested (like Source C) would see it as aimed at all critics. Different focus: Interpretation 1 focuses on the Bolsheviks' stated aims and on 1918 (hostages after the attack on Lenin, Latsis's instructions); Interpretation 2 focuses on the actual victims over a longer period, including after the Whites were defeated. Different scope: Interpretation 2 includes groups that Interpretation 1 leaves out (socialists, strikers, peasants, deserters' families). Level 2 needs an explained reason supported by details from the interpretations (and, for the sources reason, matching details from the sources). Answers that simply say 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without showing the match, or that only repeat the difference in view, stay in Level 1. Reasons based only on the publication dates or the titles of the books, or claims that a historian is 'biased', are not valid unless explained from the interpretations. Source B is Lenin's own defence of terror: answers use it as evidence of how the Bolsheviks presented the terror, and no credit is given for arguing that the terror was right or deserved.