Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/16

Moves towards totalitarianism

Practise 18 exam-style questions on Moves towards totalitarianism for Edexcel GCSE History (Russia and the Soviet Union 1917-41). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 4–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

4 marks

Source B: From 'A Letter to American Workingmen', written by Lenin in Moscow on 20 August 1918 and published in the Bolshevik newspaper Pravda two days later. This English translation was published in New York in December 1918. Ten days after writing the letter, Lenin was shot and wounded. The dates 1649 and 1793 refer to the English and French revolutions.

Its [the bourgeoisie's] servants charge us with the use of terroristic methods. - Have the English forgotten their 1649, the French their 1793? Terror was just and justified when it was employed by the bourgeoisie for its own purposes against feudal domination. But terror becomes criminal when workingmen and poverty stricken peasants dare to use it against the bourgeoisie. Terror was just and justified when it was used to put one exploiting minority in the place of another. But terror becomes horrible and criminal when it is used to abolish all exploiting minorities, when it is employed in the cause of the actual majority, in the cause of the proletariat and the semi-proletariat, of the working-class and the poor peasantry.

Source C: From My Disillusionment in Russia by Emma Goldman, published in the USA in 1923. Goldman was an anarchist who was deported from the USA to Soviet Russia in December 1919. At first she supported the Bolsheviks, but she left Russia, disillusioned, in December 1921. Here she describes what she learned in Petrograd in 1920. Zorin was a Communist official in Petrograd, and Goldman had met Lenin in Moscow. In January 1920 the Soviet government had announced that it was abolishing the death penalty.

But, then - had not Zorin told me that capital punishment had been abolished in Russia? Yet I learned shortly after my arrival that hundreds of people had been shot on the very eve of the day when the new decree went into effect, and that as a matter of fact shooting by the Tcheka had never ceased. ... And then, was not Lenin also guilty of the same methods? "Anarchists of ideas ... are not in our prisons," he had assured me. Yet at that very moment numerous Anarchists filled the jails of Moscow and Petrograd and of many other cities in Russia. In May, 1920, scores of them had been arrested in Petrograd, among them two girls of seventeen and nineteen years of age. None of the prisoners were charged with counter-revolutionary activities: they were "Anarchists of ideas," to use Lenin's expression. Several of them had issued a manifesto for the First of May, calling attention to the appalling conditions in the factories of the Socialist Republic.

Interpretation 1: From The Terror of Class: Russia, 1918-21 by Walter Kexby (fictional), published in 1983.

The Red Terror was, as its makers openly said, a class terror. Its targets were the old propertied and ruling classes: nobles, landowners, factory owners, merchants, priests, and the officers and officials of the tsar. When the Cheka took hostages after the attack on Lenin, it took them from the 'bourgeoisie'. One Cheka leader, Martin Latsis, even told his officers to ask first what class a suspect came from rather than look for evidence of what he had done. The Bolsheviks believed that the revolution would be safe only when these classes had lost their wealth and power for ever, and the terror was their means of breaking them.

Interpretation 2: From Any Critic an Enemy: The Victims of the Red Terror by Harriet Nafferton (fictional), published in 2015.

The Bolsheviks described the Red Terror as a war on the bourgeoisie, but its victims were far more varied. Socialists who had spent years fighting the tsar - Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries and anarchists - filled the Cheka's prisons. Workers who went on strike and peasants who resisted grain requisitioning were arrested, taken as hostages or shot, and the families of deserters were held to force them to return. The terror did not end when the Whites were defeated. In practice, anyone who criticised or resisted Bolshevik rule, whatever their class, could become an 'enemy of the people'.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about who the Red Terror was aimed at. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on what the Bolshevik leaders said about the terror, like Source B, where Lenin defends terror used 'against the bourgeoisie' 'to abolish all exploiting minorities'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that it was 'a class terror' aimed at 'the old propertied and ruling classes'. The author of Interpretation 2 may have relied on accounts of who was actually arrested, like Source C, where Goldman describes 'numerous Anarchists' in prison, not for 'counter-revolutionary activities' but for complaining about 'the appalling conditions in the factories'. This supports Interpretation 2's claim that socialists and anarchists 'filled the Cheka's prisons' and that anyone who 'criticised' Bolshevik rule could become a victim.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason, such as the use of different sources or a different focus (the Bolsheviks' stated aims v. the real victims), and prove it by matching specific details in the sources to specific details in the interpretations. Simply saying that one historian 'used Source B', or repeating the difference between the views, is not enough for Level 2.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Different weight given to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Lenin presents terror as something used 'against the bourgeoisie', 'to abolish all exploiting minorities', in the cause of 'the working-class and the poor peasantry', which matches Interpretation 1's view of 'a class terror' aimed at 'the old propertied and ruling classes'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Goldman describes 'numerous Anarchists' filling the jails, arrested not for 'counter-revolutionary activities' but for a manifesto about 'the appalling conditions in the factories', and says shooting 'had never ceased', which matches Interpretation 2's claim that socialists and anarchists 'filled the Cheka's prisons', that anyone who 'criticised' could become a victim, and that the terror 'did not end'. A historian relying on what the Bolsheviks said about the terror (like Source B) would see it as class war; one relying on accounts of who was actually arrested (like Source C) would see it as aimed at all critics. Different focus: Interpretation 1 focuses on the Bolsheviks' stated aims and on 1918 (hostages after the attack on Lenin, Latsis's instructions); Interpretation 2 focuses on the actual victims over a longer period, including after the Whites were defeated. Different scope: Interpretation 2 includes groups that Interpretation 1 leaves out (socialists, strikers, peasants, deserters' families). Level 2 needs an explained reason supported by details from the interpretations (and, for the sources reason, matching details from the sources). Answers that simply say 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without showing the match, or that only repeat the difference in view, stay in Level 1. Reasons based only on the publication dates or the titles of the books, or claims that a historian is 'biased', are not valid unless explained from the interpretations. Source B is Lenin's own defence of terror: answers use it as evidence of how the Bolsheviks presented the terror, and no credit is given for arguing that the terror was right or deserved.

Question 2

4 marks

Source B: From Through Bolshevik Russia by Ethel Snowden, published in London in 1920. Snowden, a British socialist, visited Russia for six weeks in May and June 1920 as a member of a delegation sent by the Labour Party and the Trades Union Congress. Here she writes about elections to the soviets. The Mensheviki were the Mensheviks.

There is not an ounce of democratic control in the politics of Russia. ... The elections are not free. If free, in my judgment there would not be a majority for the Communists. Voting is by show of hands, so that those who vote against the candidates chosen for them by the Executive of the Communist party or sent down from the People's Commissars become marked men and women. In spite of this, the Mensheviki have secured majorities in certain districts where their candidates were well-known and needed no electioneering to carry them in; for, had they needed that their case would have been hopeless. As all the halls belong to the Government it is the simplest device in the world to engage them for the sole use of Communist or approved candidates during an election. And as all the printing-presses likewise are the property and under the control of the Government, its opponents find it well-nigh impossible to have their case presented to the electors.

Source C: From My Disillusionment in Russia by Emma Goldman, published in the USA in 1923. Goldman, an American anarchist, lived in Soviet Russia from January 1920 to December 1921. In the spring of 1920 the Petrograd authorities asked her to help prepare rooms and supplies for a thousand people being deported from the USA. Here she describes trying to obtain what she needed. Raztrel means shooting.

Then began a chase over Petrograd. Materials were very scarce and it was most difficult to procure them owing to the unbelievably centralized Bolshevik methods. Thus to get a pound of nails one had to file applications in about ten or fifteen bureaus; to secure some bed linen or ordinary dishes one wasted days. Everywhere in the offices crowds of Government employees stood about smoking cigarettes, awaiting the hour when the tedious task of the day would be over. My co-workers of the War Prisoners' Bureau fumed at the irritating and unnecessary delays, but to no purpose. They threatened with the Tcheka, with the concentration camp, even with raztrel (shooting). The latter was the most favourite argument. Whenever any difficulty arose one immediately heard raztreliat - to be shot. But the expression, so terrible in its significance, was gradually losing its effect upon the people: man gets used to everything.

Interpretation 1: From Rule from the Summit: Russia, 1918-24 by Ambrose Ringwould (fictional), published in 1966.

By the early 1920s Soviet Russia was ruled from the top by a handful of Communist leaders. The soviets, which in theory held all power, had become a facade. Elections were held by a show of hands, candidates were chosen by the Party, and opposition parties found it almost impossible to hire a hall or print a leaflet. Real decisions were taken in Moscow by the Politburo, a committee of only a handful of leaders, and passed down through the Party to the soviets, the trade unions and the government departments, all of them run by Communists who followed the Party's instructions. Few states in history had concentrated so much power in so few hands.

Interpretation 2: From Lost in the Offices: Centre and Provinces in Soviet Russia, 1918-24 by Frances Bransdale (fictional), published in 2001.

It is easy to read the Party's rules and assume that Moscow controlled everything. In practice, the leaders struggled to make the state do what they wanted. The new bureaucracy grew enormously, but it was slow, wasteful and often corrupt: an order could pass through dozens of offices before anything happened. Local Party bosses and officials frequently ignored instructions or used their positions to look after themselves. Lenin himself complained in 1922 that the state machine was like a car that would not go where its driver steered it. Centralisation produced mountains of paperwork and endless delays more often than it produced real control.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the Bolshevik leaders controlled Soviet Russia in the years 1918-24. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

The interpretations may differ because their authors have focused on different aspects of Bolshevik rule and given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 focuses on political control, which is what Source B describes. Snowden says that voting was 'by show of hands', candidates were 'chosen ... by the Executive of the Communist party', and the government owned 'all the halls' and 'all the printing-presses'. This matches Interpretation 1's view that the soviets were 'a facade' and that opponents could not 'hire a hall or print a leaflet'. Interpretation 2 focuses on how the state worked in practice, which is what Source C describes. Goldman needed applications 'in about ten or fifteen bureaus' to get a pound of nails and saw officials idling, which matches Interpretation 2's claim that orders passed 'through dozens of offices' and centralisation produced 'endless delays' rather than real control.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason, such as a different focus (political control v. how the state worked in practice) or the use of different sources, and prove it by matching specific details in the sources to the interpretations. Simply stating that a historian 'used Source B', or repeating the difference between the views, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Different weight given to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Snowden says there is 'not an ounce of democratic control', voting is 'by show of hands', candidates are 'chosen ... by the Executive of the Communist party or sent down from the People's Commissars', and the government controls 'all the halls' and 'all the printing-presses', which matches Interpretation 1's soviets as 'a facade', elections 'by a show of hands', 'candidates ... chosen by the Party' and opponents unable to 'hire a hall or print a leaflet'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Goldman describes 'unbelievably centralized Bolshevik methods' that meant applications 'in about ten or fifteen bureaus' for a pound of nails, idle 'Government employees' and 'irritating and unnecessary delays', which matches Interpretation 2's slow, wasteful bureaucracy where 'an order could pass through dozens of offices' and centralisation 'produced mountains of paperwork and endless delays'. A historian who relied on evidence about how the Party controlled politics (like Source B) would stress the leaders' power; one who relied on evidence about how the state actually worked day to day (like Source C) would stress the limits of that power. Different focus: Interpretation 1 focuses on political control (elections, the soviets, the Politburo's decisions); Interpretation 2 focuses on whether orders were carried out in practice (the bureaucracy and local officials). Different scope: Interpretation 1 describes the system from the top, as the rules say it worked; Interpretation 2 deliberately looks beyond 'the Party's rules' to the provinces. Level 2 needs an explained reason supported by details from the interpretations (and, for the sources reason, matching details from the sources). Answers that simply say 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without showing the match, or that only repeat the difference in view, stay in Level 1. Reasons based only on publication dates or book titles are not valid unless explained from the interpretations.

Question 3

12 marks

Explain why the Bolsheviks launched the Red Terror in 1918.

You may use the following in your answer:
- the attempt on Lenin's life in August 1918
- the threat from the Whites

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

One reason the Bolsheviks launched the Red Terror was the attempt on Lenin's life. On 30 August 1918 Fanny Kaplan, a Socialist Revolutionary, shot and badly wounded Lenin in Moscow, and on the same day Moisei Uritsky, the head of the Petrograd Cheka, was assassinated. The Bolsheviks claimed these attacks were part of a wider counter-revolutionary plot, and they believed they had to strike back hard to show that their enemies could not get away with killing their leaders. Within days Izvestia called for mass terror, and on 5 September the Council of People's Commissars made terror official policy. In Petrograd alone several hundred hostages were shot.

A second reason was the threat from the Whites. By the summer of 1918 the Bolsheviks faced civil war on several fronts. The Czech Legion had revolted in May, anti-Bolshevik governments had appeared on the Volga and in Siberia, and Allied troops had landed at Archangel. When Kazan fell in August, it looked as if the regime might collapse. The leaders feared that enemies behind their own lines would help the Whites, so they used terror to 'secure the rear', arresting and shooting suspected plotters and taking hostages to deter revolts.

The Bolsheviks also faced enemies on the left. In July 1918 the Left Socialist Revolutionaries, their former partners in government, rose in Moscow and murdered the German ambassador, and a revolt led by the former SR Boris Savinkov broke out in Yaroslavl. This left the Bolsheviks ruling alone, without majority support: they had won only about a quarter of the votes in the Constituent Assembly elections. Because they could not rely on consent, they relied on fear.

Finally, terror fitted Bolshevik ideas. Lenin saw the revolution as a class war in which the 'dictatorship of the proletariat' had to crush the bourgeoisie by force, and the Bolsheviks admired the Jacobins of the French Revolution. The Cheka had existed since December 1917 for exactly this purpose. The crisis of August 1918 therefore gave the Bolsheviks the opportunity to turn a belief in class terror into an organised campaign, run by an enlarged Cheka, against anyone they saw as an enemy.

Explanation

Top answers explain how each factor led the Bolsheviks to use terror, going beyond the two stimulus points to cover at least one more aspect, such as Bolshevik ideology or the Left SR rising, with precise dates and examples. Weaker answers describe what the Red Terror did (executions, hostages) instead of explaining why it began, or drift into the Civil War in general. No judgement about the most important cause is needed.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The attempt on Lenin's life: on 30 August 1918 the Socialist Revolutionary Fanny Kaplan shot and badly wounded Lenin in Moscow, and on the same day Moisei Uritsky, head of the Petrograd Cheka, was assassinated (Volodarsky had been killed in June). The Bolsheviks presented these as part of a counter-revolutionary plot and answered with a public campaign of terror within days: the Izvestia appeal of 3 September and the Council of People's Commissars' decree 'On the Red Terror' of 5 September; in Petrograd several hundred hostages were shot. The threat from the Whites: by the summer of 1918 the Czech Legion had revolted (May), anti-Bolshevik governments had formed on the Volga and in Siberia, White armies were gathering in the south and Allied troops had landed in the north; Kazan fell in August. The regime feared collapse and used terror to 'secure the rear' against plots and revolts. Rival socialists: the Left SR rising in Moscow and the murder of the German ambassador Mirbach (July 1918), and the revolt in Yaroslavl led by the former SR Boris Savinkov, left the Bolsheviks ruling alone and facing enemies on the left as well as the right. Ideology: Lenin and other leaders saw the revolution as a class war in which the 'dictatorship of the proletariat' must crush the bourgeoisie by force; they admired the Jacobin Terror of the French Revolution, and the Cheka had existed since December 1917 to fight 'counter-revolution'. Lack of support: the Bolsheviks had won only about a quarter of the votes for the Constituent Assembly, so they relied on force rather than consent. Food crisis: grain requisitioning by armed detachments (from May 1918) provoked peasant resistance, and terror was used to enforce it. The White Terror: the Bolsheviks pointed to killings of Reds by the Whites (e.g. in Finland in 1918) to present their terror as retaliation. Answers may explain links, e.g. the attack on Lenin came at the worst point of the military crisis, which is why the response was so sweeping. No judgement about the most important reason is needed or rewarded. This question asks for the causes of the Red Terror: an argument that the terror was right or deserved is not an explanation of why it happened and gains no credit. Do not credit confusion with the terror of the 1930s under Stalin or the NKVD. The cap: answers that do not address three or more aspects of content cannot reach Level 4 (maximum 8 marks).

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 4

20 marks

Interpretation 1: From A Self-Inflicted Wound: Terror and the Bolsheviks, 1918-21 by Owen Sproatley (fictional), published in 1972.

The Red Terror did the Bolsheviks almost as much harm as good. It turned possible allies into enemies. Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries who offered to support the Reds against the Whites were still arrested and their newspapers closed, and workers who went on strike for more bread found themselves facing the Cheka. In the countryside, grain requisitioning backed by armed squads and the Cheka drove whole districts into revolt: by 1920-21 peasant armies were fighting the regime in Tambov province, in Ukraine and in western Siberia. Even foreign socialists who visited Russia in 1920 hoping to admire the revolution went home shocked by what they heard about the Cheka. Fear could silence opponents, but it could not make people work or grow grain. By March 1921, when the sailors of Kronstadt rose against the government, terror had left the Bolsheviks more isolated than at any time since 1917.

Interpretation 2: From Securing the Rear: The Cheka and Soviet Power, 1918-21 by Celia Wragby (fictional), published in 2009.

The Red Terror did exactly what its makers intended. In the summer of 1918 the Bolsheviks faced plots and risings behind their own lines, from the Left SR rising in Moscow to the revolt in Yaroslavl, at the very moment when the Czech Legion and the Whites were advancing. The terror 'secured the rear'. The Cheka arrested the leaders of rival parties, closed their newspapers and broke up underground organisations before they could act. It enforced the requisitioning of grain that fed the towns and the Red Army, and it made strikes and desertion dangerous. By 1921 the rival socialist parties had been reduced to small, hunted groups. Terror did not make the Bolsheviks popular, but it made organised resistance almost impossible, and it kept in power a party that most Russians had not voted for in 1917.

How far do you agree with Interpretation 2 about the effects of the Red Terror on the Bolshevik regime in the years 1918-21? Explain your answer, using both interpretations and your knowledge of the historical context.

Spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this question.

Model answer

Interpretation 2 argues that the Red Terror 'did exactly what its makers intended': it 'secured the rear', made organised resistance 'almost impossible' and kept in power a party most Russians had not voted for. Interpretation 1 argues instead that terror 'did the Bolsheviks almost as much harm as good', turning 'possible allies into enemies' and leaving them isolated by 1921. I agree with Interpretation 2 about the short-term effects of the terror, but Interpretation 1 is more convincing about its longer-term costs. The two historians also convey their views differently: Interpretation 2 piles up the terror's practical results in confident language, while Interpretation 1 dwells on what fear 'could not' do and ends with the Bolsheviks 'more isolated than at any time since 1917'.

Interpretation 2 is right that in 1918 the Bolsheviks faced enemies behind their own lines. In July the Left SRs rose in Moscow and murdered the German ambassador, and Savinkov led a revolt in Yaroslavl, while the Czech Legion and the Whites advanced on the Volga; Kazan fell in August. After Lenin was shot on 30 August, the decree of 5 September made terror official policy, and the Cheka took hostages, sent 'class enemies' to camps and shot suspected plotters. As Interpretation 2 says, the leaders of the Mensheviks and SRs were arrested and their newspapers closed, and by 1921 their remaining activists had been rounded up. The Cheka, which grew to at least 200,000 personnel including its own troops, also enforced grain requisitioning and made strikes dangerous. In this sense terror did strengthen the regime: no organised political opposition could challenge the Bolsheviks inside the territory they held.

However, Interpretation 1 shows that terror had serious costs. Many Mensheviks and SRs were willing to support the Reds against the Whites, yet they were still persecuted, so the Bolsheviks threw away possible allies. Requisitioning, enforced by armed squads and the Cheka, drove peasants into revolt: by 1920-21 there were risings in Tambov province, Ukraine and western Siberia. Workers who went on strike were arrested, and in February 1921 the factories of Petrograd were on strike again. Even visitors who sympathised with socialism, such as Ethel Snowden of the British Labour delegation of 1920, were shocked by the power of the Cheka. Then in March 1921 the Kronstadt sailors, who had helped the Bolsheviks to power in 1917, rose against them. Lenin had to replace requisitioning with a tax in kind, a sign that fear alone could not keep the country working.

Overall, I agree with Interpretation 2 only up to a point. If the criterion is short-term survival, terror was effective: it crushed organised opposition and helped to feed the towns and the army in 1918-19, when the regime was in greatest danger. But judged by 1921, Interpretation 1 is more convincing, because terror had helped to create the very discontent that exploded in Tambov and Kronstadt and forced Lenin to retreat. Terror kept the Bolsheviks in control, but at the price of turning much of the population against them.

Explanation

Top answers weigh the short-term and longer-term effects of the Red Terror on the regime, testing both interpretations with precise knowledge such as the risings of 1918, the repression of the socialist parties, the peasant revolts of 1920-21 and Kronstadt, and reach a judgement based on clear criteria. Weak answers describe the Red Terror without assessing its effects, write a general essay on why the Reds won the Civil War, or argue about whether the terror was right instead of what it did.

Mark scheme
  1. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO4: 16 marks.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation reviewing the alternative views in coming to a substantiated judgement. Precise analysis of the interpretations is shown, indicating how the differences of view are conveyed and deploying this material to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is precisely selected to support the evaluation. An overall judgment is justified and the line of reasoning is coherent, sustained and logically structured.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation, agreeing or disagreeing with the interpretation. Good analysis of the interpretations is shown indicating difference of view and deploying this to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is used directly to support the evaluation. An overall judgement is given with some justification and a line of reasoning is generally sustained.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Answer offers valid evaluative comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Some analysis is shown in selecting and including details from both interpretations to support this comment. Some relevant contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation. An overall judgement is given but its justification is insecure or undeveloped and a line of reasoning is not sustained.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Answer offers simple valid comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Limited analysis of one interpretation is shown by selection and inclusion of some detail in the form of simple paraphrase or direct quotation. Generalised contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Interpretation 2 argues that the Red Terror achieved its aims: it 'secured the rear', destroyed organised opposition and kept a minority party in power. Points from the interpretations and own knowledge that support Interpretation 2: in the summer of 1918 the regime faced the Left SR rising in Moscow and the murder of the German ambassador Mirbach (July), the Yaroslavl revolt led by Savinkov (July), the revolt of the Czech Legion (from May) and the fall of Kazan (August), and on 30 August Lenin was shot and Uritsky killed; after the decree of 5 September 1918 the Cheka took hostages, shot suspected plotters and sent 'class enemies' to camps; the leaders of the Mensheviks and SRs were repeatedly arrested and their newspapers closed, and their remaining activists were rounded up in 1921; the Cheka enforced grain requisitioning, broke strikes and pursued deserters; it grew from about 40 officials in December 1917 to at least 200,000 personnel, including its own troops, by 1921; the Bolsheviks won only about a quarter of the votes for the Constituent Assembly yet kept power; estimates of executions in 1918-22 range from tens of thousands to well over 100,000. Points that counter it (including Interpretation 1): Mensheviks and SRs who backed the Reds against the Whites in 1918-19 were still repressed, narrowing the regime's support; strikes were met with arrests; requisitioning enforced by armed squads and the Cheka provoked peasant risings in Ukraine (1919-21), Tambov province (from August 1920) and western Siberia (1921); foreign socialists such as Ethel Snowden, a member of the British Labour delegation of 1920, were shocked by what they heard; in March 1921 the Kronstadt sailors, who had backed the Bolsheviks in 1917, rose against them, and Lenin replaced requisitioning with a tax in kind (the start of the NEP) to end the risings, showing that fear alone could not keep the country working; the Reds' survival also owed much to the Red Army, the peasants' fear of a return of the landlords and the Whites' weaknesses. A substantiated judgement might argue that terror strengthened the regime in the short term by destroying organised opposition (Interpretation 2) but helped to create the crisis of 1921 (Interpretation 1); or that Interpretation 2 is more convincing for 1918-19 and Interpretation 1 for 1920-21. Criteria might include short-term and longer-term effects, and effects on different groups (rival parties, workers, peasants). Credit comment on how the views are conveyed, e.g. Interpretation 2's confident claim that terror 'did exactly what its makers intended' and Interpretation 1's emphasis on what terror 'could not' do. The question is about the effects of the Red Terror, not whether it was right: arguments that the terror was justified or deserved are not an evaluation of its effects and gain no credit. Answers that drift into a general account of why the Reds won the Civil War should be credited only where linked to the effects of terror. Do not credit confusion with Stalin's terror of the 1930s.

    Pearson's marking instructions (part of the mark scheme): No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the interpretations. In all levels, the second sentence relates to analysis and while the rest relate to evaluation. The following rules will apply: In Level 1, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis without evidence of evaluation should be awarded 1 mark. In other levels, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis (but that also fully meet the descriptors for evaluation of the level below) should be awarded no more than the bottom mark in the level.

  2. 4 marks

    SPaG. Spelling, punctuation, grammar and the use of specialist terminology (4 marks).
    High performance (4 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with effective control of meaning overall. Learners use a wide range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with general control of meaning overall. Learners use a good range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Threshold performance (1 mark): Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with some control of meaning and any errors do not significantly hinder meaning overall. Learners use a limited range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    0 marks: The learner writes nothing. The learner's response does not relate to the question. The learner's achievement in SPaG does not reach the threshold performance level, e.g. errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar severely hinder meaning.

    SPaG is marked separately from the 16 marks for the answer, on the whole response.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.