Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From Schooling the Revolution: Education in Stalin's Russia by Martin Mallender (fictional), published in 1966.
The main purpose of Soviet schools under Stalin was political. Every lesson was meant to produce loyal citizens who accepted the Party's version of the truth. History was rewritten to glorify Stalin, portraits of the leader hung in every classroom, and children learned songs thanking him for their happy childhood. Teachers who strayed from the approved textbooks risked dismissal or arrest. Out of school, the Young Pioneers and the Komsomol taught children that loyalty to the Party came before loyalty to their own families, and the boy Pavlik Morozov, who was said to have denounced his father, was held up as a hero. Education was, above all, a means of control.
Interpretation 2: From Literacy and Ambition: Soviet Schools, 1928-41 by Ruth Ashworthy (fictional), published in 2004.
Soviet education in the 1930s was driven above all by the needs of a country that was industrialising at breakneck speed. The government needed millions of skilled workers, technicians and engineers, and it could not wait for them. That is why it made four years of primary schooling compulsory from 1930, poured money into technical colleges and returned to traditional lessons, timetables and examinations in mathematics, science and Russian. The number of children in school rose dramatically, and by 1939 most adults could read and write. For millions of the children of workers and peasants, education opened the way to promotion as engineers, managers and Party officials.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about the aims of Soviet education in the 1930s. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is about what Soviet education was mainly for. Interpretation 1 argues that its aim was political control. It says that 'the main purpose of Soviet schools under Stalin was political' and that every lesson was meant to 'produce loyal citizens who accepted the Party's version of the truth'. It supports this with history 'rewritten to glorify Stalin', portraits of Stalin 'in every classroom' and the example of Pavlik Morozov, concluding that education was 'above all, a means of control'. Interpretation 2, however, argues that education was driven mainly by economic needs. It says that the government 'needed millions of skilled workers, technicians and engineers', which is why it made primary schooling compulsory and returned to traditional teaching in 'mathematics, science and Russian'. It also presents education as an opportunity, opening 'the way to promotion' for workers' and peasants' children.
Explanation
Top answers state the overall difference (indoctrination and control v. training skilled workers and opening opportunities) and support it with details from both interpretations. Simply listing what each one mentions, such as portraits in one and technical colleges in the other, without stating the difference in purpose stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is about the main purpose of Soviet education. Interpretation 1 argues that its aim was political control and indoctrination: 'the main purpose ... was political'; schools were to 'produce loyal citizens who accepted the Party's version of the truth'; history 'rewritten to glorify Stalin', portraits in 'every classroom', songs of thanks to Stalin, teachers who strayed risking 'dismissal or arrest', loyalty to the Party before the family (Pavlik Morozov); 'a means of control'. Interpretation 2 argues that its aim was practical and economic, to meet the needs of industrialisation: education was 'driven above all by the needs of a country that was industrialising'; the government 'needed millions of skilled workers, technicians and engineers'; compulsory primary schooling, technical colleges and traditional teaching in 'mathematics, science and Russian'; rising literacy; education as a route to 'promotion'. Level 2 needs this difference of view (indoctrination and control v. skills for industrialisation and opportunity) supported from both interpretations. Answers that give only surface differences (e.g. 'Interpretation 1 mentions Pavlik Morozov and Interpretation 2 mentions 1930') or that summarise each in turn without stating the difference stay in Level 1. Do not credit answers that explain why the views differ.