Question 1
4 marksSource B: From History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks): Short Course, the official history of the Soviet Communist Party, published in Moscow in 1938 and in English in 1939. Stalin closely supervised its writing. When it was published, Molotov was the head of the Soviet government and one of Stalin's closest allies. Here it describes the February Revolution in Petrograd. It gives dates in the Russian calendar, with the Western calendar dates in brackets.
On International Women's Day, February 23 (March 8), at the call of the Petrograd Bolshevik Committee, working women came out in the streets to demonstrate against starvation, war and tsardom. The Petrograd workers supported the demonstration of the working women by a city-wide strike movement. The political strike began to grow into a general political demonstration against the tsarist system. ... On February 25 (March 10) the whole of working-class Petrograd had joined the revolutionary movement. ... Over the masses of workers floated red banners bearing the slogans: "Down with the tsar!" "Down with the war!" "We want bread!" ... A most energetic and persistent drive was made to win over the troops, especially by the working women, who addressed themselves directly to the soldiers, fraternized with them and called upon them to help the people to overthrow the hated tsarist autocracy. The practical work of the Bolshevik Party at that time was directed by the Bureau of the Central Committee of our Party which had its quarters in Petrograd and was headed by Comrade Molotov. On February 26 (March 11) the Bureau of the Central Committee issued a manifesto calling for the continuation of the armed struggle against tsardom and the formation of a Provisional Revolutionary Government.
Source C: From The Russian Turmoil, the memoirs of General Anton Denikin, published in English in 1922. In February 1917 Denikin commanded an army corps on the Romanian front, far from Petrograd; in April 1917 he became chief of staff to the commander-in-chief of the Russian army. Here he is writing about the events in Petrograd in late February 1917.
Nevertheless, the rebellion started as an elemental force and caught everybody unawares. Several days later, when General Kornilov visited the Executive Committee of the Petrograd Soviet of Workmen and Soldiers' Deputies, prominent members of that body incidentally explained that "the soldiers mutinied independently of the workmen, with whom the soldiers had not been in touch on the eve of the rebellion," and that the "mutiny had not been prepared - hence the absence of a corresponding administrative organ." ... On that decisive day [27 February] there were no leaders - there was only the tidal wave. Its terrible progress appeared to be devoid of any definite object, plan, or watchword. The only cry that seemed to express the general spirit was "Long live Liberty."
Interpretation 1: From A Revolution Without Leaders? Russia, 1917 by Peter Aldbourne (fictional), published in 1968.
No party planned the February Revolution. The best-known revolutionary leaders were far away: Lenin was in Switzerland and others were in exile in Siberia. On 23 February the local Bolshevik leaders in the Vyborg district even advised the women workers not to strike, fearing a clash with the police that they could not win. The protests grew out of hunger, anger and war-weariness, and they spread from factory to factory without any central direction. When the soldiers mutinied on 27 February, they did so on their own initiative, and their first instinct was to look for leadership at the Duma. The revolution was made by the crowd, and the politicians hurried to catch up with it.
Interpretation 2: From Underground Petrograd: Socialists at War, 1914-1917 by Helena Pyecroft (fictional), published in 1998.
The February Revolution was not simply an explosion of anger. Although the famous leaders were in exile, the factories of Petrograd contained thousands of experienced socialist activists - Bolsheviks, Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries and others - who had organised strikes throughout 1916 and early 1917. When the protests began, these activists held meetings, printed leaflets and called out workers from factory after factory. They gave the movement its slogans, 'Down with the war!' and 'Down with the autocracy!'. They also worked among the soldiers of the garrison, many of whom came from the same working-class districts. Without this network of organisers, the bread protests of February might have died away as quickly as earlier ones had.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the February Revolution was planned and organised. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians may have given more weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source C. Denikin says the rebellion 'started as an elemental force and caught everybody unawares', that the soldiers 'mutinied independently of the workmen' and that on 27 February 'there were no leaders'. This matches Interpretation 1's view that 'no party planned the February Revolution' and that the soldiers mutinied 'on their own initiative'. The author of Interpretation 2 may have relied more on evidence like Source B, the Communist Party's official history, which claims that the women came out 'at the call of the Petrograd Bolshevik Committee' and that 'a most energetic and persistent drive was made to win over the troops'. This supports Interpretation 2's argument that socialist activists 'called out workers from factory after factory' and 'worked among the soldiers of the garrison'.
Explanation
Top answers give a clear reason and support it by matching specific details in the sources with specific details in the interpretations, or by showing a difference of focus (famous leaders and parties v. local activists in the factories). They may add why the sources differ, for example that the Short Course was written under Stalin to show the Bolsheviks leading the revolution, so a historian who relies on it will see more organisation. Weaker answers repeat the difference between the views, make vague claims that one author 'used Source B', or base the reason only on the publication dates.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source C supports Interpretation 1: Denikin says the rebellion 'started as an elemental force and caught everybody unawares', that the soldiers 'mutinied independently of the workmen' and that on the decisive day 'there were no leaders', which matches Interpretation 1's view that 'no party planned' the revolution and that the soldiers acted 'on their own initiative'. Source B supports Interpretation 2: the Short Course claims that the women came out on 23 February 'at the call of the Petrograd Bolshevik Committee', that the banners carried the slogans 'Down with the tsar!' and 'Down with the war!', that 'a most energetic and persistent drive was made to win over the troops' and that 'the practical work of the Bolshevik Party' was directed by the Bureau of the Central Committee, which matches Interpretation 2's view that socialist activists 'called out workers from factory after factory', 'gave the movement its slogans' and 'worked among the soldiers of the garrison' (Source B gives only some support: it credits the Bolsheviks alone, while Interpretation 2 also names Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries and others). Answers may develop this reason by explaining why the two sources point in different directions: Source B is the Communist Party's official history, written under Stalin's supervision to show the Bolsheviks leading the revolution (it credits Molotov, head of the Soviet government in 1938, with directing the party's work, although the Bureau was led by Shliapnikov, who was executed in 1937), and its claim that the women came out at the Bolsheviks' call conflicts with the evidence, used in Interpretation 1, that the Vyborg Bolsheviks advised against striking on 23 February; Source C comes from a general who saw the revolution as an uncontrolled 'tidal wave'. A historian who gives more weight to sources like B is likely to see more organisation. Credit such provenance points only when they are linked to the interpretations. The interpretations may differ because they focus on different people and levels of the movement: Interpretation 1 looks at the famous leaders and the parties' central organisations (Lenin abroad, Bolshevik leaders advising against the strike), while Interpretation 2 looks at local activists inside the factories and barracks. They may differ because they emphasise different stages: Interpretation 1 stresses the outbreak on 23 February and the mutiny of 27 February, Interpretation 2 the way the protests were turned into a political movement with slogans. Level 2 needs a reason explained and substantiated with details from the interpretations (and, where used, the matching details in the sources). Simply saying 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source C' without matching details, or describing the difference again (as in the main-difference question), stays in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or the titles of the books, or assertions that a historian is biased.