Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/16

Changes in industry

Practise 20 exam-style questions on Changes in industry for Edexcel GCSE History (Russia and the Soviet Union 1917-41). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 20 questions
  • 4–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

4 marks

Source B: From a speech by Stalin to the First All-Union Conference of Stakhanovites in the Kremlin, Moscow, on 17 November 1935. Alexei Stakhanov was a coal miner in the Donbass who, on 31 August 1935, was reported to have cut 102 tonnes of coal in one shift, about fourteen times the normal amount. This English translation was published in Moscow in 1947 in Problems of Leninism, a collection of Stalin's writings.

What first of all strikes the eye is the fact that this movement began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below, without any pressure whatsoever from the administrators of our enterprises. More than that - this movement in a way arose and began to develop in spite of the administrators of our enterprises, even in opposition to them. ... The lot of Stakhanov himself was no better, for in his progress he had to defend himself not only against certain officials of the administration, but also against certain workers, who jeered and hounded him because of his "new-fangled ideas." ...

... How did it begin? Stakhanov raised the technical standard of output of coal five or six times, if not more. ...

1. The basis for the Stakhanov movement was first and foremost the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers. Life has improved, comrades. Life has become more joyous. And when life is joyous, work goes well. Hence the high rates of output. Hence the heroes and heroines of labour.

Source C: From an article, 'The Stakhanovist Movement', by N. Markin, published in The New International, an American Trotskyist magazine, in February 1936; the article is dated 12 December 1935. 'N. Markin' was a pen name of Lev Sedov, the son of Leon Trotsky. Sedov lived in exile in Paris and, like his father, bitterly opposed Stalin, although he supported the Soviet planned economy. He based his article on reports in the Soviet press. 'Shoring' meant putting up timber props to hold up the roof of a mine.

Let us examine in greater detail the work of Stakhanov himself. A driller, as Stakhanov relates, used to work no more than 2½ or 3 hours maximum with his pneumatic drill, and the rest of the time he had to do shoring, i.e., had to perform auxiliary tasks while the drill remained idle. ... At the present time, Stakhanov's drill functions during the full 6 hours (instead of 2½), and the work of shoring is performed by others. ...

Another essential cause for the records must be sought in the fact that we are dealing here not with an average workday under normal conditions of production, but with a very special preparation, often over a considerable period of time ... Thus, the records, in their majority, are obtained under entirely special and artificial conditions, and by means of enormous intensity. ...

... it is not surprising that the Stakhanovist movement should be received in a hostile manner by the working mass. This the Soviet press is unable to dissimulate.

Interpretation 1: From Heroes of Labour: The Stakhanovites in Soviet Industry by Neil Wetherall (fictional), published in 1992.

The Stakhanovite movement drew on a real wish among many workers to do well and to be rewarded for it. Stakhanov's record was publicised by the Party, but within weeks thousands of workers in mines, factories, railways and farms were setting records of their own. Many were young men and women only recently arrived from the villages, who had taken technical courses and wanted to show what the new machinery could do. Stakhanovites earned high wages and bonuses, received better flats, holidays and goods, and were celebrated in the newspapers and at the conference in the Kremlin in November 1935. For ambitious workers the movement offered a path upwards, and in a number of industries output per worker rose in 1936.

Interpretation 2: From The Record-Breakers: Propaganda and Production in Stalin's Factories by Alison Hallowell (fictional), published in 2010.

The Stakhanovite movement was a piece of stage management. Stakhanov's famous shift on the night of 30-31 August 1935 was arranged in advance by the mine's Party organiser: two helpers put up the props while Stakhanov did nothing but cut coal, and the whole team's output was credited to him. Other records were set in the same way, under special conditions that ordinary workers could not repeat. Records often disrupted production, and in 1936 the government used them as a reason to raise output norms for everyone, which in practice cut many workers' pay. Many workers resented the Stakhanovites, and some record-breakers were attacked by their workmates.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the Stakhanovite movement was a genuine movement of workers in the years 1935-36. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which Stalin claims that the movement 'began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below', even against the managers, and that its basis was 'the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the movement 'drew on a real wish among many workers' and quickly spread to 'thousands of workers', who were rewarded with high wages, flats and goods. The author of Interpretation 2 seems to have used evidence like Source C, in which Markin shows that Stakhanov's drill could work 'the full 6 hours' only because 'the work of shoring is performed by others', and that records came from 'very special preparation' under 'artificial conditions'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that the record was 'arranged in advance', that 'two helpers put up the props', and that ordinary workers could not repeat such records.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details: Stalin's claim that the movement came 'from below' with Interpretation 1, and Markin's evidence about helpers and special preparation with Interpretation 2. Answers can also note that Stalin himself admits that some workers 'jeered and hounded' Stakhanov. Simply saying which source each historian 'used', or repeating the difference of view, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Stalin claims that the movement 'began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below', even 'in opposition to' managers, that Stakhanov raised output 'five or six times', and that its basis was 'the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers' ('Life has become more joyous'); this matches Interpretation 1's view that the movement 'drew on a real wish among many workers to do well and to be rewarded', spread to 'thousands of workers' and offered 'a path upwards', with high wages and goods. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Markin argues that Stakhanov's record depended on others doing the 'shoring' while his drill worked 'the full 6 hours', that records were obtained after 'very special preparation' under 'entirely special and artificial conditions', and that the movement was 'received in a hostile manner by the working mass'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the record was 'arranged in advance', that 'two helpers put up the props', that records were set 'under special conditions that ordinary workers could not repeat', and that 'many workers resented the Stakhanovites'. A student may also note that Source B itself admits that some workers 'jeered and hounded' Stakhanov, which an author like the author of Interpretation 2 could use, and that Source B is a public speech by Stalin while Source C is a hostile analysis by Trotsky's son based on the Soviet press. The interpretations may differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 looks at the Stakhanovites themselves and their rewards, while Interpretation 2 looks at how records were set and at the effects on other workers (norms, pay, resentment). They may also differ because they judge the movement by different criteria: what it offered ambitious workers, or how it was organised and used by the regime. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.

Question 2

4 marks

Source B: From Soviet Communism: A New Civilisation by Sidney and Beatrice Webb, first published in London in 1935 (this text is from the third edition, 1944). The Webbs were leading British socialists, founders of the London School of Economics, who greatly admired the Soviet system and visited the USSR in 1932 and 1934. Here they describe the shock brigades in Soviet industry.

In nearly every industrial establishment of any magnitude there have been formed one or more "shock brigades", the members of which (udarniki) are recruited from volunteers among the trade unionists. These shock brigades take as their function the acceleration of production, coupled with improvement in quality and lessening of cost. They undertake collectively special tasks in their own establishment, or they may volunteer to go to some other establishment which has fallen behind. They bring to their work exceptional energy, speed or skill; they labour more assiduously than is common; or they put in extra time in subbotniki (voluntary work). They do this out of zeal, for which they receive honour and applause. They seldom or never have a higher wage-rate and usually no extra bonus, though when working by the piece their increased output automatically brings higher earnings. They often receive preference in the allocation of places in the holiday rest-houses ... Of these shock brigaders, or udarniki, there are reported to be, in the USSR, many millions.

Source C: From an article by Gareth Jones published in the Western Mail, a newspaper in Cardiff, on 11 April 1931. Jones, a Welsh journalist who spoke Russian, had spent three weeks in the USSR in the summer of 1930. Here he describes the progress of the First Five-Year Plan, which had begun in October 1928.

While the first year of the Plan was a success, the second was disappointing to the Communists. Production did increase, but it was at the expense of quality and at the expense of the standard of living of the workers. Transport was disorganised throughout the country. The lack of skilled labour was felt keenly. These difficulties are going to increase with the extra burdens which the Plan places on the country.

The rapid speed at which Stalin is trying to industrialise Russia has led to great hunger and suffering. Food is scarce. The health of the nation may be affected by the present privations. The discontent of the masses has been tremendous, and there has been talk of revolution against the Communists.

Interpretation 1: From Shock Troops of the Plan: Workers and Socialist Competition, 1929-32 by Brian Grimshaw (fictional), published in 1977.

Shock brigades were the driving force of the First Five-Year Plan. From 1929 groups of workers, many of them young Communists, formed brigades that promised to beat their targets, cut waste and work extra shifts, and they challenged other workshops and factories to 'socialist competition'. In 1930 many brigades drew up 'counter-plans' promising more than the planners had asked for. Shock workers were sent to help factories and building sites that had fallen behind, and their example set the pace for the millions of raw recruits arriving from the villages. Without their energy the Plan's huge targets would have stayed on paper. It was largely thanks to them that the government could announce at the start of 1933 that the Plan had been completed in four years and three months.

Interpretation 2: From Paper Records: Socialist Competition in Soviet Industry by Valerie Ashdale (fictional), published in 2001.

The shock brigades did far less to raise output than Soviet propaganda claimed. Enthusiasm was real among some young activists, but by 1931-32 so many workers had been enrolled as shock workers that the title meant little: whole workshops were declared shock brigades, and agreements to compete were signed and then forgotten. Many workers joined because shock workers received bigger rations and first place in the queue for scarce goods. Industrial output grew mainly because millions of new workers were taken on and enormous sums were invested, not because each worker produced more. The rush to beat targets wore out machines, wasted materials and lowered the quality of what was produced.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the importance of shock brigades in increasing industrial output during the First Five-Year Plan (1928-32). You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

One reason is that the historians have given weight to different kinds of evidence. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on admiring accounts like Source B, in which the Webbs describe shock brigades in 'nearly every industrial establishment', 'recruited from volunteers', working 'out of zeal' for 'the acceleration of production, coupled with improvement in quality', and even going to help an establishment 'which has fallen behind'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the brigades were 'the driving force' of the Plan and were sent to help factories 'that had fallen behind'. The author of Interpretation 2 seems closer to evidence like Source C, in which Jones reports that production rose 'at the expense of quality', that 'the lack of skilled labour was felt keenly' and that 'the discontent of the masses has been tremendous'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that the rush to beat targets 'lowered the quality of what was produced' and that output grew because of new workers and investment rather than enthusiasm. The Webbs also say only that there 'are reported to be' many millions of shock workers, a claim that a historian like the author of Interpretation 2 would treat with suspicion.

Explanation

Top answers give one clear reason, such as the different sources the historians rely on or their different focus (what the brigades promised against what they added to output), and support it with matched details: the Webbs' volunteers working 'out of zeal' with Interpretation 1, and Jones's production 'at the expense of quality' with Interpretation 2. Noting that the Webbs only report the 'many millions' of shock workers strengthens an answer. Simply saying which source each historian 'used', or repeating the difference of view, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the Webbs describe shock brigades in 'nearly every industrial establishment of any magnitude', 'recruited from volunteers', whose function is 'the acceleration of production, coupled with improvement in quality and lessening of cost', who may 'volunteer to go to some other establishment which has fallen behind', who work 'out of zeal' and who number 'many millions'; this matches Interpretation 1's view that the brigades were 'the driving force of the First Five-Year Plan', promised to beat their targets and cut waste, and were sent to help factories 'that had fallen behind'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Jones reports that production increased but 'at the expense of quality and at the expense of the standard of living of the workers', that transport was disorganised, that 'the lack of skilled labour was felt keenly', and that rapid industrialisation brought 'great hunger and suffering' and 'tremendous' discontent; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the rush to beat targets 'lowered the quality of what was produced' and that output grew because of new workers and investment, 'not because each worker produced more'. A student may note that Source B also gives evidence an author like the author of Interpretation 2 could use: shock workers on piecework earned more and received 'preference' for places in holiday rest-houses, which fits the view that many joined for the rewards, and the Webbs only say that there 'are reported to be' many millions of them, relying on official claims, while Jones was an outside observer who was critical of the regime. The interpretations may also differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 concentrates on the activists, their promises and counter-plans and on the official claim that the Plan was completed in four years and three months, while Interpretation 2 concentrates on what the title of shock worker came to mean, on output per worker and on quality, and accepts that 'enthusiasm was real among some young activists'. They may differ because they judge the brigades by different criteria: the effort and enthusiasm they showed, or what they added to output. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.

Question 3

12 marks

Explain why there were serious shortages of consumer goods in the USSR in the years 1928-41.

You may use the following in your answer:
- the priority given to heavy industry
- the closing of private businesses

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

There were serious shortages of consumer goods in the USSR between 1928 and 1941 mainly because the Five-Year Plans deliberately put heavy industry and defence first, and because the policies that destroyed private business and peasant farming cut supplies.

The most important reason was the priority given to heavy industry. The Plans poured investment into coal, steel, electricity and machinery, which Stalin saw as the foundation of a strong and independent country. In the First Plan, he claimed, heavy industry fulfilled its targets by 108 per cent, but the targets for consumer goods fell well short. The Second Plan promised more clothes, shoes and household goods, but less was actually invested in them than planned, and from 1936-37 spending on armaments rose sharply. The Third Plan, drawn up in 1938-39, cut the share of investment for consumer goods even further.

Secondly, the end of the NEP closed many of the businesses that had supplied ordinary people. From 1928 the Nepmen were driven out by heavy taxes and arrests, private trade was banned, and small craftsmen and workshops, which had made many of the shoes, clothes and household items of the 1920s, were closed or forced into co-operatives. The state shops could not take their place.

Thirdly, collectivisation cut the supply of food and raw materials. Peasants slaughtered millions of animals in 1929-33, so meat, milk, leather and wool became scarce, and food was exported to pay for foreign machinery even during the famine. Light industry was short of materials, and the shops were short of food.

Fourthly, demand grew much faster than supply. The urban population roughly doubled between 1926 and 1939 as peasants moved into the towns, and wages paid in money rose while the goods available did not. The state printed money to pay for the Plans, so prices rose and goods vanished from the shelves.

Finally, the planning system itself produced shortages. Factories were judged on the quantity they produced, not its quality, so many goods were badly made, and planners concentrated on big targets rather than the small items people needed. Transport bottlenecks meant that even goods that were made did not always reach the shops.

As a result bread and other foods were rationed from 1929 until 1935, and queues and the black market became part of everyday life. The shortages were the price of the regime's choice to build heavy industry first.

Explanation

Top answers explain why consumer goods were scarce, linking the Plans' priorities, the destruction of private trade and crafts, the effects of collectivisation and rapid urban growth, rather than describing queues and rationing. They go beyond the two stimulus points, for example with livestock losses or inflation. Avoid claiming that no consumer goods were produced; no overall judgement is needed.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Priority to heavy industry: the Five-Year Plans put most investment into 'means of production' (coal, steel, machinery, electricity) rather than consumer goods; in the First Plan heavy industry's targets were reported as overfulfilled (108 per cent, by Stalin's figure) while consumer-goods targets fell well short; the Second Plan promised more consumer goods, but less was invested in them than planned (about 18 per cent of investment against 23 per cent planned, according to the US Embassy's summary; credit approximate figures); the Third Plan (1938-42) cut this further as rearmament grew. Closing of private businesses: from 1928-30 Nepmen were driven out by taxes and arrests, private shops and trade were banned, and craftsmen and small workshops, which had made many of the shoes, clothes and household goods of the 1920s, were closed or forced into co-operatives; state shops and co-operatives could not replace them. Collectivisation: the slaughter of livestock and the fall in output cut supplies of meat, milk, leather, wool and other raw materials for light industry; food was exported to pay for machinery. Rapid urban growth: the urban population roughly doubled between 1926 and 1939, so millions of new town-dwellers needed food, clothing and housing. Money and prices: wages paid in roubles grew faster than the goods available, and the state printed money, so there was inflation and goods disappeared from the shops; queues and the black market. Quality and planning: factories judged on quantity produced poor-quality goods; planners neglected small items; transport problems; defence spending rose sharply from 1936-37. Results (credit when linked): rationing of bread and other foods from 1929 to 1935; Torgsin shops selling goods for gold and foreign currency (1930-36); long queues; special shops for officials. Answers that describe shortages without explaining their causes should not go beyond Level 2. Do not credit claims that no consumer goods were produced, or that rationing lasted until 1941. No overall judgement is required.

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 4

20 marks

Interpretation 1: From Keeping Their Heads Down: Soviet Workers and the Five-Year Plans by Colin Rowntree (fictional), published in 1980.

Most Soviet workers did not share the enthusiasm that filled the newspapers. Their main response to the Five-Year Plans was to look after themselves and their families. In the early 1930s millions changed jobs every year in search of better pay, food or a room, and absenteeism was so common that from November 1932 a single day's absence could lead to dismissal. In 1932 textile workers in the Ivanovo region went on strike against cuts in their bread rations. Many workers resented the shock workers and record-breakers, who received bigger rations and bonuses and whose achievements were used to justify higher output norms for everyone. Reports by the secret police recorded constant grumbling about low pay, queues and shortages. Workers put up with the Plans because they had no choice.

Interpretation 2: From Building Socialism: Youth, Labour and Enthusiasm, 1928-37 by Margaret Urquhart (fictional), published in 2007.

The Five-Year Plans released a wave of genuine enthusiasm among Soviet workers, above all the young. Millions of workers enrolled in shock brigades and 'socialist competitions', promising to beat their targets, and young Communists volunteered to build new towns such as Magnitogorsk and Komsomolsk-on-Amur in the harshest conditions. For a generation of peasants' sons and daughters, the factories offered training, promotion and a sense of building a new world, while the capitalist countries sank into depression and mass unemployment. Hardship was real, but many workers believed that their sacrifices would build socialism and that their children would live better lives as a result.

How far do you agree with Interpretation 2 about the attitudes of Soviet industrial workers towards the Five-Year Plans in the years 1928-37? Explain your answer, using both interpretations and your knowledge of the historical context.

Spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this question.

Model answer

Interpretation 2 argues that the Five-Year Plans 'released a wave of genuine enthusiasm' among Soviet workers, especially the young, who 'believed that their sacrifices would build socialism'. Interpretation 1 argues that most workers 'did not share the enthusiasm that filled the newspapers' and put up with the Plans 'because they had no choice'. I agree with Interpretation 2 only in part: enthusiasm was real for some groups, but most workers' attitudes were shaped by hardship and self-interest.

There is evidence for Interpretation 2. From 1929 shock brigades and 'socialist competitions' spread through the factories, and some brigades drew up 'counter-plans' promising more than the planners asked. Young Communists volunteered for building sites such as Magnitogorsk and in 1932 founded the new town of Komsomolsk-on-Amur. For young workers from the villages, the factories offered training and promotion: technical schools and workers' faculties expanded, and future leaders such as Khrushchev and Brezhnev studied in these years. Unemployment, which had been over a million under the NEP, disappeared by 1930, while workers in the West suffered the Depression, so many could believe that the Soviet system was building a better future.

However, Interpretation 1 is right that most workers looked after themselves. Labour turnover was so high in the early 1930s that many workers changed jobs more than once a year, searching for better pay, food or housing. The government had to introduce harsh laws: from November 1932 one day's absence could lead to dismissal and the loss of a ration card and room, and labour books followed in 1938. In April 1932 textile workers in the Ivanovo region went on strike when their bread rations were cut. Real wages had fallen to about half their 1928 level by 1932-33, and many workers joined shock brigades for the bigger rations rather than out of belief. Record-breakers were often resented, especially when their achievements were used to raise norms in 1936, and secret police reports recorded constant grumbling.

The interpretations convey their views differently. Interpretation 2 uses positive words such as 'genuine', 'volunteered' and 'believed', while Interpretation 1 sets the newspapers' enthusiasm against workers who put up with the Plans because they had 'no choice'.

Overall, I only partly agree with Interpretation 2. Its view fits young Komsomol members and the workers who were trained and promoted, and attitudes probably improved after rationing ended in 1935. But for the millions of former peasants in overcrowded barracks in the early 1930s, Interpretation 1 is more convincing: the need for harsh discipline laws shows that the state could not rely on enthusiasm alone.

Explanation

Top answers test Interpretation 2 against evidence of enthusiasm (shock brigades, Komsomol volunteers, training and promotion) and against Interpretation 1's evidence of self-interest and resistance (labour turnover, the absence law of 1932, the Ivanovo strikes), and reach a judgement that distinguishes between groups of workers or periods. Weaker answers describe working conditions without linking them to workers' attitudes.

Mark scheme
  1. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO4: 16 marks.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation reviewing the alternative views in coming to a substantiated judgement. Precise analysis of the interpretations is shown, indicating how the differences of view are conveyed and deploying this material to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is precisely selected to support the evaluation. An overall judgment is justified and the line of reasoning is coherent, sustained and logically structured.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation, agreeing or disagreeing with the interpretation. Good analysis of the interpretations is shown indicating difference of view and deploying this to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is used directly to support the evaluation. An overall judgement is given with some justification and a line of reasoning is generally sustained.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Answer offers valid evaluative comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Some analysis is shown in selecting and including details from both interpretations to support this comment. Some relevant contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation. An overall judgement is given but its justification is insecure or undeveloped and a line of reasoning is not sustained.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Answer offers simple valid comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Limited analysis of one interpretation is shown by selection and inclusion of some detail in the form of simple paraphrase or direct quotation. Generalised contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Interpretation 2 argues that the Plans 'released a wave of genuine enthusiasm', especially among the young. Points that support Interpretation 2: shock brigades and 'socialist competition' spread from 1929, and some brigades drew up 'counter-plans' promising more than the planners asked; the Komsomol sent volunteers to building sites such as Magnitogorsk and founded Komsomolsk-on-Amur (1932); there was pride in the giant projects (Dnieprostroi, the Stalingrad Tractor Works) and in slogans such as 'The Five-Year Plan in four years'; unemployment, over a million under the NEP, disappeared and the labour exchanges closed in 1930, while the West suffered the Depression; millions of young workers gained training and promotion (factory schools, workers' faculties, technical colleges; future leaders such as Khrushchev and Brezhnev studied in these years); the Stakhanovite movement (from 1935) attracted thousands of workers seeking higher pay and recognition; some foreign observers described real enthusiasm. Points that counter it (including Interpretation 1): very high labour turnover in the early 1930s (many workers changed jobs more than once a year) and absenteeism; the law of 15 November 1932 (dismissal, with loss of ration card and housing, for one day's absence without good reason), the internal passport (December 1932) and the labour book (1938) were needed to control workers; strikes such as those in the Ivanovo region (April 1932) over ration cuts; real wages in 1932-33 fell to roughly half the 1928 level, with rationing and overcrowded barracks; shock-worker status brought bigger rations, so many joined for material reasons; record-breakers were resented and sometimes attacked, and higher norms (1936) cut many workers' pay; secret police reports recorded widespread grumbling and jokes; fear of being accused of 'wrecking'. Answers may note how the views are conveyed: Interpretation 2 uses words such as 'genuine', 'volunteered' and 'believed'; Interpretation 1 sets 'the enthusiasm that filled the newspapers' against workers who put up with the Plans 'because they had no choice'. A substantiated judgement might distinguish between groups (young Komsomol members and promoted skilled workers v. older workers and peasants new to the factories) or between periods (the hungry early 1930s v. the better years after 1934). Do not credit treatment of the interpretations as sources to be judged for reliability.

    Pearson's marking instructions (part of the mark scheme): No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the interpretations. In all levels, the second sentence relates to analysis and while the rest relate to evaluation. The following rules will apply: In Level 1, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis without evidence of evaluation should be awarded 1 mark. In other levels, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis (but that also fully meet the descriptors for evaluation of the level below) should be awarded no more than the bottom mark in the level.

  2. 4 marks

    SPaG. Spelling, punctuation, grammar and the use of specialist terminology (4 marks).
    High performance (4 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with effective control of meaning overall. Learners use a wide range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with general control of meaning overall. Learners use a good range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Threshold performance (1 mark): Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with some control of meaning and any errors do not significantly hinder meaning overall. Learners use a limited range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    0 marks: The learner writes nothing. The learner's response does not relate to the question. The learner's achievement in SPaG does not reach the threshold performance level, e.g. errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar severely hinder meaning.

    SPaG is marked separately from the 16 marks for the answer, on the whole response.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.