Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a speech by Stalin to the First All-Union Conference of Stakhanovites in the Kremlin, Moscow, on 17 November 1935. Alexei Stakhanov was a coal miner in the Donbass who, on 31 August 1935, was reported to have cut 102 tonnes of coal in one shift, about fourteen times the normal amount. This English translation was published in Moscow in 1947 in Problems of Leninism, a collection of Stalin's writings.
What first of all strikes the eye is the fact that this movement began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below, without any pressure whatsoever from the administrators of our enterprises. More than that - this movement in a way arose and began to develop in spite of the administrators of our enterprises, even in opposition to them. ... The lot of Stakhanov himself was no better, for in his progress he had to defend himself not only against certain officials of the administration, but also against certain workers, who jeered and hounded him because of his "new-fangled ideas." ...
... How did it begin? Stakhanov raised the technical standard of output of coal five or six times, if not more. ...
1. The basis for the Stakhanov movement was first and foremost the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers. Life has improved, comrades. Life has become more joyous. And when life is joyous, work goes well. Hence the high rates of output. Hence the heroes and heroines of labour.
Source C: From an article, 'The Stakhanovist Movement', by N. Markin, published in The New International, an American Trotskyist magazine, in February 1936; the article is dated 12 December 1935. 'N. Markin' was a pen name of Lev Sedov, the son of Leon Trotsky. Sedov lived in exile in Paris and, like his father, bitterly opposed Stalin, although he supported the Soviet planned economy. He based his article on reports in the Soviet press. 'Shoring' meant putting up timber props to hold up the roof of a mine.
Let us examine in greater detail the work of Stakhanov himself. A driller, as Stakhanov relates, used to work no more than 2½ or 3 hours maximum with his pneumatic drill, and the rest of the time he had to do shoring, i.e., had to perform auxiliary tasks while the drill remained idle. ... At the present time, Stakhanov's drill functions during the full 6 hours (instead of 2½), and the work of shoring is performed by others. ...
Another essential cause for the records must be sought in the fact that we are dealing here not with an average workday under normal conditions of production, but with a very special preparation, often over a considerable period of time ... Thus, the records, in their majority, are obtained under entirely special and artificial conditions, and by means of enormous intensity. ...
... it is not surprising that the Stakhanovist movement should be received in a hostile manner by the working mass. This the Soviet press is unable to dissimulate.
Interpretation 1: From Heroes of Labour: The Stakhanovites in Soviet Industry by Neil Wetherall (fictional), published in 1992.
The Stakhanovite movement drew on a real wish among many workers to do well and to be rewarded for it. Stakhanov's record was publicised by the Party, but within weeks thousands of workers in mines, factories, railways and farms were setting records of their own. Many were young men and women only recently arrived from the villages, who had taken technical courses and wanted to show what the new machinery could do. Stakhanovites earned high wages and bonuses, received better flats, holidays and goods, and were celebrated in the newspapers and at the conference in the Kremlin in November 1935. For ambitious workers the movement offered a path upwards, and in a number of industries output per worker rose in 1936.
Interpretation 2: From The Record-Breakers: Propaganda and Production in Stalin's Factories by Alison Hallowell (fictional), published in 2010.
The Stakhanovite movement was a piece of stage management. Stakhanov's famous shift on the night of 30-31 August 1935 was arranged in advance by the mine's Party organiser: two helpers put up the props while Stakhanov did nothing but cut coal, and the whole team's output was credited to him. Other records were set in the same way, under special conditions that ordinary workers could not repeat. Records often disrupted production, and in 1936 the government used them as a reason to raise output norms for everyone, which in practice cut many workers' pay. Many workers resented the Stakhanovites, and some record-breakers were attacked by their workmates.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the Stakhanovite movement was a genuine movement of workers in the years 1935-36. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which Stalin claims that the movement 'began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below', even against the managers, and that its basis was 'the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the movement 'drew on a real wish among many workers' and quickly spread to 'thousands of workers', who were rewarded with high wages, flats and goods. The author of Interpretation 2 seems to have used evidence like Source C, in which Markin shows that Stakhanov's drill could work 'the full 6 hours' only because 'the work of shoring is performed by others', and that records came from 'very special preparation' under 'artificial conditions'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that the record was 'arranged in advance', that 'two helpers put up the props', and that ordinary workers could not repeat such records.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details: Stalin's claim that the movement came 'from below' with Interpretation 1, and Markin's evidence about helpers and special preparation with Interpretation 2. Answers can also note that Stalin himself admits that some workers 'jeered and hounded' Stakhanov. Simply saying which source each historian 'used', or repeating the difference of view, stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: Stalin claims that the movement 'began somehow of itself, almost spontaneously, from below', even 'in opposition to' managers, that Stakhanov raised output 'five or six times', and that its basis was 'the radical improvement in the material welfare of the workers' ('Life has become more joyous'); this matches Interpretation 1's view that the movement 'drew on a real wish among many workers to do well and to be rewarded', spread to 'thousands of workers' and offered 'a path upwards', with high wages and goods. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Markin argues that Stakhanov's record depended on others doing the 'shoring' while his drill worked 'the full 6 hours', that records were obtained after 'very special preparation' under 'entirely special and artificial conditions', and that the movement was 'received in a hostile manner by the working mass'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the record was 'arranged in advance', that 'two helpers put up the props', that records were set 'under special conditions that ordinary workers could not repeat', and that 'many workers resented the Stakhanovites'. A student may also note that Source B itself admits that some workers 'jeered and hounded' Stakhanov, which an author like the author of Interpretation 2 could use, and that Source B is a public speech by Stalin while Source C is a hostile analysis by Trotsky's son based on the Soviet press. The interpretations may differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 looks at the Stakhanovites themselves and their rewards, while Interpretation 2 looks at how records were set and at the effects on other workers (norms, pay, resentment). They may also differ because they judge the movement by different criteria: what it offered ambitious workers, or how it was organised and used by the regime. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.