Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From The Kaiser's Gamble: Germany and the Russian Revolution by Victor Hensby (fictional), published in 1988.
Lenin's success in 1917 owed a great deal to the German government. In April it allowed him and other Russian exiles to cross Germany from Switzerland in a 'sealed' train, because it hoped that he would weaken Russia's war effort. Without German help he might have spent months trying to get home. German money mattered too. Documents from the German Foreign Ministry, published after the Second World War, show that Germany spent millions of marks on propaganda in Russia, and German officials believed that their funds had helped the Bolsheviks to build up Pravda and their other newspapers. The Bolsheviks' campaign for an immediate peace suited Germany's war aims perfectly. In this sense, the October Revolution was partly a German victory.
Interpretation 2: From Revolution from Below: Petrograd in 1917 by Clare Ruddington (fictional), published in 2011.
The story that Lenin was a German agent was spread by his enemies in 1917, and the Provisional Government's investigation never brought the case to court. Germany certainly let him travel home across its territory, and money from German sources may have reached the party through business contacts in Stockholm, but nobody knows how much. German help was a burden as well as a benefit: the 'sealed' train allowed Lenin's opponents to call him a traitor, and in July the accusation drove him into hiding. Money cannot explain why hundreds of thousands of workers, soldiers and sailors came to back the Bolsheviks by the autumn. They did so because the Bolsheviks promised the peace, bread and land that the Provisional Government failed to deliver.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about the importance of German help to Lenin and the Bolsheviks in 1917. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees German help as a major reason for Lenin's success, while Interpretation 2 argues that its importance has been exaggerated and that the Bolsheviks succeeded because of genuine popular support. Interpretation 1 says Lenin's success 'owed a great deal to the German government', which brought him home in the 'sealed' train and spent 'millions of marks' on propaganda that officials believed helped the Bolsheviks build up Pravda, so that October was 'partly a German victory'. Interpretation 2 accepts that Germany let Lenin travel home, but says 'nobody knows how much' money reached the party and that German help was 'a burden as well as a benefit', because it let his enemies call him a traitor. It argues that 'Money cannot explain' why so many backed the Bolsheviks: they did so for 'peace, bread and land'.
Explanation
Top answers identify the overall difference (German help as a major cause of Bolshevik success v. a minor and even harmful factor compared with popular support) and back it up from both interpretations. Answers that only point out that both mention the sealed train, or that list details without stating the difference, stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees German help as a major reason for Lenin's success, so that October was 'partly a German victory', while Interpretation 2 argues that German help was limited, uncertain and even a burden, and that the Bolsheviks succeeded because of genuine popular support for their promises. Interpretation 1: Lenin's success 'owed a great deal to the German government'; the 'sealed' train got him home quickly ('Without German help he might have spent months'); German Foreign Ministry documents show 'millions of marks' spent on propaganda and officials believed it helped build up Pravda; the peace campaign 'suited Germany's war aims perfectly'. Interpretation 2: the 'German agent' story was spread by enemies and never 'brought ... to court'; 'nobody knows how much' money reached the party; German help was 'a burden as well as a benefit' (Lenin called a traitor, driven into hiding in July); 'Money cannot explain' mass support; people backed the Bolsheviks because of 'the peace, bread and land' the government failed to deliver. Level 2 needs this difference of view, supported from both interpretations. Note that both accept that Germany let Lenin travel home; the difference lies in how much German help explains Bolshevik success. Answers that give only surface differences (e.g. 'Interpretation 2 mentions Stockholm') or summarise each interpretation in turn without stating the difference stay in Level 1. Answers that explain why the views differ are answering a different question.