Question 1
4 marksSource B: From Soviet Communism: A New Civilisation? by Sidney and Beatrice Webb, published in Britain in 1935. The Webbs were British socialists who admired the Soviet system. Here they describe how the Soviet authorities treated the engineers and other experts who had been trained before the revolution.
It was, however, inevitable that persons holding their opinions should, in the atmosphere of mingled hatred and fear that prevailed, become objects of suspicion. ... Whether or not there was often sabotage, it was inevitable that this should be popularly suspected. In 1927-1928 the widely advertised Shakhty prosecution of Russian technicians in the Donets coal mines, in conspiracy with certain Germans, further inflamed popular feeling. There ensued a steady dispensing with the services of all whose loyalty was not completely beyond question. A foreign journalistic critic of the Soviet Government declared, in 1931 - probably with some exaggeration - that "hundreds of so-called 'spetsies' [specialists] of all kinds have disappeared during this last year from places in which they had long been working for the Soviet Government. Either they have been simply dismissed because a Red professor, a Red engineer, a Red librarian had meantime grown up out of the ranks of proletarian youth to take their positions; or else they have been arrested on some flimsy charge."
Source C: From a report by Joseph Stalin to the Eighteenth Congress of the Communist Party, 10 March 1939. Here he describes what had happened to the 'old intelligentsia', the educated experts of the years before the revolution. This English translation was published in Moscow in 1947.
The most influential and qualified section of the old intelligentsia broke away from the main body in the very first days of the October Revolution, proclaimed war on the Soviet government, and joined the ranks of the saboteurs. They met with well-deserved punishment for this; they were smashed and dispersed by the organs of Soviet power. ... Another section of the old intelligentsia, less qualified but more numerous, long continued to mark time, waiting for "better days"; but then, apparently giving up hope, decided to go and serve and to live in harmony with the Soviet government. ... Hundreds of thousands of young people coming from the ranks of the working class, the peasantry and the working intelligentsia entered the universities and technical colleges, from which they emerged to reinforce the attenuated ranks of the intelligentsia.
Interpretation 1: From The Hunt for Wreckers: Experts and the Party, 1928-38 by Alistair Dalgarno (fictional), published in 1979.
Stalin's revolution treated the old experts as enemies. From the Shakhty trial of 1928 to the Industrial Party trial of 1930, engineers trained under the tsars were publicly accused of 'wrecking' and of spying for foreign powers, and thousands were dismissed or arrested. They were blamed for the breakdowns and accidents that the impossible targets of the First Five-Year Plan made inevitable. Although Stalin called a halt in 1931, the old specialists never felt safe, and in the Great Terror of 1937-38 managers and engineers were again arrested in large numbers. For the expert, the 1930s were years of fear.
Interpretation 2: From Engineers of the New Order by Frances Ormsby (fictional), published in 2005.
The persecution of the old experts was short-lived, and the main story of the 1930s is the rise of a new technical elite. In June 1931 Stalin told managers to show 'the utmost care and solicitude' for the old engineers who were turning towards the working class, and their pay and status rose. At the same time hundreds of thousands of young workers and peasants were trained as engineers and technicians. These newly promoted men and women filled the posts left by the old experts and by the victims of the purges, and many rose to run factories and ministries. For them, Stalin's revolution brought education, good salaries and power.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the position of engineers and other specialists in the Soviet Union in the years 1928-39. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because their authors have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 could be based on evidence like Source B. The Webbs describe 'the atmosphere of mingled hatred and fear', the Shakhty prosecution that 'inflamed popular feeling', and specialists who were 'arrested on some flimsy charge'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the old experts were treated 'as enemies' and that 'thousands were dismissed or arrested'. Interpretation 2 is closer to Source C, in which Stalin says that 'hundreds of thousands of young people' from the working class and peasantry entered the universities and technical colleges to reinforce the intelligentsia. This supports Interpretation 2's view that the main story of the 1930s was the training of 'hundreds of thousands of young workers and peasants' who formed a new technical elite.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason, such as the use of different sources or a focus on different groups of specialists, and support it by matching details in the sources to details in the interpretations. Repeating the difference of view, or saying that one historian 'used Source B' without matching details, scores little. Reasons based on dates of publication or an assumed bias are not valid.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because their authors have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the Webbs describe 'the atmosphere of mingled hatred and fear', the Shakhty prosecution that 'inflamed popular feeling', 'a steady dispensing with the services of all whose loyalty was not completely beyond question', and specialists who had 'disappeared' or been 'arrested on some flimsy charge'; this matches Interpretation 1's 'treated the old experts as enemies', the Shakhty trial and 'thousands were dismissed or arrested'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: Stalin says that 'hundreds of thousands of young people' from the working class and peasantry entered universities and technical colleges to reinforce the intelligentsia, and that much of the old intelligentsia 'decided to go and serve' the Soviet government; this matches Interpretation 2's 'hundreds of thousands of young workers and peasants were trained' and 'newly promoted men and women filled the posts'. A student may also note that each source contains material for the other view (Source B mentions the 'Red engineer' who replaced the old expert; Source C shows the regime boasting that the old experts were 'smashed and dispersed'). The interpretations may differ because they focus on different groups: Interpretation 1 on the old pre-revolutionary experts, Interpretation 2 on the new Soviet-trained specialists who benefited. They may differ because they stress different periods: Interpretation 1 the campaigns of 1928-30 and 1937-38, Interpretation 2 the change after Stalin's speech of June 1931. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations (and, if used, matched details from the sources). Answers that only say 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on dates of publication or assumed bias.