Question 1
4 marksSource A: From a letter written in English by the tsarina, Alexandra, to her husband, Nicholas II, 14 December 1916 (Russian calendar). Nicholas was at army headquarters. Her letters were published in 1923. Lvov, Samarin, Miliukov (Milyukov), Gutchkov (Guchkov) and Polivanov were well-known public figures who had criticised the government; Samarin and Polivanov had been dismissed from the government in 1915-16.
Be Peter the Great, John the Terrible, Emperor Paul [three tsars remembered for ruling harshly] - crush them all under you - now don't you laugh, noughty one - but I long to see you so with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary. ... Disperse the Duma at once ... I should have quietly & with a clear conscience before the whole of Russia have sent Lvov to Siberia (one did so for far less grave acts), taken Samarin's rank away (he signed that paper fr. Moscou), Miliukov, Gutchkov & Polivanov also to Siberia. It is war and at such a time interior war is high treason, why don't you look at it like that, I really cannot understand. I am but a woman, but my soul & brain tell me it wld. be the saving of Russia ... we have been placed by God on a throne & we must keep it firm & give it over to our Son untouched - if you keep that in mind you will remember to be the Sovereign - & how much easier for an autocratic sovereign than one who has sworn the Constitution.
Give two things you can infer from Source A about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government.
Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:
Model answer
What I can infer: The tsarina saw the government's critics as traitors and enemies to be crushed, not as loyal subjects whose views should be heard.
Details in the source that tell me this: She says that 'at such a time interior war is high treason' and that she would have sent Lvov, Miliukov and Gutchkov 'to Siberia'.
What I can infer: She believed that Nicholas was too weak with his critics and was allowing them to control him.
Details in the source that tell me this: She writes that she longs to see him firm 'with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary'.
Explanation
Top answers explain what the tsarina's words reveal about her attitude, for example that calling opposition 'high treason' shows she saw critics as enemies rather than loyal subjects, and support each inference with a short quotation. Simply repeating that 'she wanted to send them to Siberia' without saying what this shows is comprehension, not inference.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid inference about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government, e.g. she wanted them punished harshly, not listened to / she saw criticism of the government in wartime as treason / she wanted the Duma closed down / she believed the tsar was too weak with them and was being pushed around by them / she believed that giving in to demands for reform would endanger the autocracy and her son's inheritance / she was confident that repression would work and did not understand how widespread the opposition was.
Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. She wanted the critics punished, not listened to (1). She would have 'sent Lvov to Siberia', and 'Miliukov, Gutchkov & Polivanov also to Siberia'; 'crush them all under you' (1). She regarded criticism of the government in wartime as treason (1). 'It is war and at such a time interior war is high treason' (1). She wanted the Duma silenced (1). 'Disperse the Duma at once' (1). She thought Nicholas was too weak and was being controlled by his critics (1). 'I long to see you so with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary' (1). She saw any concession towards a constitution as a threat to the autocracy and to her son's future (1). 'Give it over to our Son untouched'; 'how much easier for an autocratic sovereign than one who has sworn the Constitution' (1). She was sure that harsh measures would succeed and did not see how much support the critics had (1). 'My soul & brain tell me it wld. be the saving of Russia'; 'quietly & with a clear conscience' (1). An inference must go beyond what the source says: 'she wanted to send Milyukov to Siberia' or 'she wanted the Duma dispersed' on its own repeats the source and earns no mark unless the student says what this shows about her attitude (e.g. that she saw the critics as enemies to be crushed). Own knowledge alone (e.g. that she trusted Rasputin) is not an inference from Source A; keep the focus on her attitude to the critics. Accept other appropriate alternatives.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. 'crush them all under you' / 'sent Lvov to Siberia' / 'interior war is high treason' / 'Disperse the Duma at once' / 'all those men who try to govern you' / 'give it over to our Son untouched'.
Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a short quotation or a close reference to Source A). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.
-
1 mark
A second valid inference about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).
The second inference must be a different point, not the first reworded (e.g. 'she wanted them exiled' and 'she wanted them punished' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for paraphrase or own knowledge.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.
Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it.