Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/16

The growth of opposition to the tsar in early 1917

Practise 18 exam-style questions on The growth of opposition to the tsar in early 1917 for Edexcel GCSE History (Russia and the Soviet Union 1917-41). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 4–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

4 marks

Source A: From a letter written in English by the tsarina, Alexandra, to her husband, Nicholas II, 14 December 1916 (Russian calendar). Nicholas was at army headquarters. Her letters were published in 1923. Lvov, Samarin, Miliukov (Milyukov), Gutchkov (Guchkov) and Polivanov were well-known public figures who had criticised the government; Samarin and Polivanov had been dismissed from the government in 1915-16.

Be Peter the Great, John the Terrible, Emperor Paul [three tsars remembered for ruling harshly] - crush them all under you - now don't you laugh, noughty one - but I long to see you so with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary. ... Disperse the Duma at once ... I should have quietly & with a clear conscience before the whole of Russia have sent Lvov to Siberia (one did so for far less grave acts), taken Samarin's rank away (he signed that paper fr. Moscou), Miliukov, Gutchkov & Polivanov also to Siberia. It is war and at such a time interior war is high treason, why don't you look at it like that, I really cannot understand. I am but a woman, but my soul & brain tell me it wld. be the saving of Russia ... we have been placed by God on a throne & we must keep it firm & give it over to our Son untouched - if you keep that in mind you will remember to be the Sovereign - & how much easier for an autocratic sovereign than one who has sworn the Constitution.

Give two things you can infer from Source A about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government.

Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:

Model answer

What I can infer: The tsarina saw the government's critics as traitors and enemies to be crushed, not as loyal subjects whose views should be heard.
Details in the source that tell me this: She says that 'at such a time interior war is high treason' and that she would have sent Lvov, Miliukov and Gutchkov 'to Siberia'.

What I can infer: She believed that Nicholas was too weak with his critics and was allowing them to control him.
Details in the source that tell me this: She writes that she longs to see him firm 'with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary'.

Explanation

Top answers explain what the tsarina's words reveal about her attitude, for example that calling opposition 'high treason' shows she saw critics as enemies rather than loyal subjects, and support each inference with a short quotation. Simply repeating that 'she wanted to send them to Siberia' without saying what this shows is comprehension, not inference.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid inference about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government, e.g. she wanted them punished harshly, not listened to / she saw criticism of the government in wartime as treason / she wanted the Duma closed down / she believed the tsar was too weak with them and was being pushed around by them / she believed that giving in to demands for reform would endanger the autocracy and her son's inheritance / she was confident that repression would work and did not understand how widespread the opposition was.

    Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. She wanted the critics punished, not listened to (1). She would have 'sent Lvov to Siberia', and 'Miliukov, Gutchkov & Polivanov also to Siberia'; 'crush them all under you' (1). She regarded criticism of the government in wartime as treason (1). 'It is war and at such a time interior war is high treason' (1). She wanted the Duma silenced (1). 'Disperse the Duma at once' (1). She thought Nicholas was too weak and was being controlled by his critics (1). 'I long to see you so with all those men who try to govern you - & it must be the contrary' (1). She saw any concession towards a constitution as a threat to the autocracy and to her son's future (1). 'Give it over to our Son untouched'; 'how much easier for an autocratic sovereign than one who has sworn the Constitution' (1). She was sure that harsh measures would succeed and did not see how much support the critics had (1). 'My soul & brain tell me it wld. be the saving of Russia'; 'quietly & with a clear conscience' (1). An inference must go beyond what the source says: 'she wanted to send Milyukov to Siberia' or 'she wanted the Duma dispersed' on its own repeats the source and earns no mark unless the student says what this shows about her attitude (e.g. that she saw the critics as enemies to be crushed). Own knowledge alone (e.g. that she trusted Rasputin) is not an inference from Source A; keep the focus on her attitude to the critics. Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. 'crush them all under you' / 'sent Lvov to Siberia' / 'interior war is high treason' / 'Disperse the Duma at once' / 'all those men who try to govern you' / 'give it over to our Son untouched'.

    Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a short quotation or a close reference to Source A). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.

  3. 1 mark

    A second valid inference about the tsarina's attitude towards the critics of the tsar's government, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).

    The second inference must be a different point, not the first reworded (e.g. 'she wanted them exiled' and 'she wanted them punished' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for paraphrase or own knowledge.

  4. 1 mark

    Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.

    Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it.

Question 2

4 marks

Source B: From My Mission to Russia by Sir George Buchanan, the British Ambassador to Russia from 1910 to 1918, published in 1923. Here he is writing about September 1915 (Western calendar), soon after the tsar had suspended the Duma. The zemstvos and town councils were elected local councils that organised help for the army, the wounded and refugees during the war.

About the same time the Union of Zemstvos and the Union of Town Councils had held a meeting at Moscow, in which a resolution was passed demanding the immediate convocation of the Duma and the appointment of a Government that possessed the confidence of the nation. Each union had further deputed three of its members to submit the above demands orally to the Emperor. Acting on the advice tendered by Goremykin [the Prime Minister], His Majesty refused to receive them, while he commanded Prince Scherbatoff [the Minister of the Interior] to summon the respective presidents of the two unions - Prince Lvoff and the mayor of Moscow, M. Chelnokoff - to Petrograd, and to read to them the following message: "I place a very high value on the noble work which the zemstvos and town councils have done and are doing for the wounded and refugees (from the provinces in German occupation); but I do not consider that they have any right to interfere in political matters, which are centred in the Government. ..." ... Chelnokoff, a man of very moderate views, subsequently summed up the situation by saying that it was intolerable that Russia should be governed by a doting reactionary like Goremykin and by a drunken scoundrel like Rasputin.

Source C: From a speech by Pavel Milyukov in the Duma on 1 November 1916 (Russian calendar) (translated for this course). Milyukov was the leader of the Kadets (Constitutional Democrats), a liberal party, and one of the leaders of the Progressive Bloc, the group formed in 1915 by a majority of the Duma's members. The censors banned the speech from being published, but copies of it circulated across Russia.

We have lost faith that this government can lead us to victory (Voices: 'True'), because the attempts we have made here both to correct this government and to improve it have not succeeded. ... this government has now sunk below the level at which it stood in the normal times of our Russian life (Voices on the left: 'True, right'), and the gulf between us and it has widened and become impassable. ... We say to the government, as the declaration of the Bloc said: we will fight you, we will fight with all lawful means until you go. ... When the Duma reminds the government with ever greater insistence that the rear [the home front] must be organised for the struggle to succeed, and the government goes on repeating that to organise means to organise a revolution, and deliberately prefers chaos and disorganisation - what is this, stupidity or treason? ... And all the particular reasons come down to this single one: the incompetence and the ill will of the present government (Voices on the left: 'Right').

Interpretation 1: From Loyal Opposition: Russian Liberals at War, 1914-1917 by Adrian Pellingham (fictional), published in 1981.

Russia's liberal politicians did not set out to destroy the monarchy. In 1914 they rallied behind the war effort, and through the zemstvos and town councils they organised hospitals, care for refugees and supplies for the army that the government itself could not provide. The Progressive Bloc, formed in 1915 by a majority of the Duma, asked only for a 'ministry of public confidence' - ministers the nation could trust - so that the war could be won. Again and again Nicholas II refused. He suspended the Duma, would not even receive the delegates of the zemstvos and town councils, and dismissed the ministers who sympathised with them. It was the tsar's refusal to work with moderate men that turned loyal critics into opponents.

Interpretation 2: From Dark Forces? Rumour and Politics in Wartime Russia by Gillian Pennock (fictional), published in 2019.

The liberal leaders of the Duma did more to undermine the monarchy than they later admitted. They used the war to press for a share of power, and when the tsar refused, they turned to attacks that went far beyond fair criticism. In November 1916 Milyukov told the Duma that the government's actions could be explained only by 'stupidity or treason', hinting at a pro-German conspiracy at court for which he had no real proof. Banned from the newspapers, his speech was copied and passed round the country, spreading the belief that the tsar's own circle was betraying Russia. Some liberals, such as Guchkov, even discussed plans to force the tsar to abdicate. Their campaign did much to destroy the trust on which the regime depended.

Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the part played by Russia's liberal politicians in weakening the tsar's government in the years 1915-16. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.

Model answer

One reason is that the historians may have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 argues that the liberals were loyal moderates who 'asked only for a "ministry of public confidence"' and that the tsar 'would not even receive the delegates of the zemstvos and town councils'. This is supported by Source B, where the unions ask for 'a Government that possessed the confidence of the nation' and Nicholas refuses to receive them, saying they have no 'right to interfere in political matters'. Interpretation 2, however, argues that the liberals 'turned to attacks that went far beyond fair criticism'. This fits Source C, in which Milyukov tells the government 'we will fight you ... until you go' and asks whether its actions are 'stupidity or treason'.

Explanation

Top answers explain one reason and support it with matched details from both interpretations and the sources, for example showing that Buchanan's account of the moderate zemstvo delegates supports Interpretation 1, while Milyukov's 'stupidity or treason' speech supports Interpretation 2. Weaker answers repeat the difference between the views, state that a historian 'used' a source without showing how, or base their answer on the dates or titles of the books.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B, which shows the zemstvos and town councils asking only for the recall of the Duma and 'a Government that possessed the confidence of the nation', the tsar refusing even to receive their delegates and saying they had no 'right to interfere in political matters', and describes Chelnokoff as 'a man of very moderate views', supports Interpretation 1's view that the liberals were loyal moderates who 'asked only for a "ministry of public confidence"' and that the tsar 'would not even receive the delegates of the zemstvos and town councils'. Source C, in which Milyukov declares 'we will fight you ... until you go' and asks whether the government's actions were 'stupidity or treason', supports Interpretation 2's view that the liberals 'turned to attacks that went far beyond fair criticism' and spread the belief that the court was betraying Russia. The interpretations may differ because they focus on different periods and aspects: Interpretation 1 concentrates on 1914-15, the liberals' war work and the tsar's refusals, while Interpretation 2 concentrates on late 1916 and the effect of the liberals' attacks and rumours on trust in the regime. They may differ because of different emphasis on who was responsible: Interpretation 1 puts the responsibility on Nicholas ('It was the tsar's refusal'), Interpretation 2 on the liberal leaders ('did more to undermine the monarchy than they later admitted'). Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with matched details from the interpretations (and the sources, if used). Answers that only say which source 'supports' which interpretation without matching details, that repeat the difference between the views, or that rely on the dates of publication or titles of the books stay in Level 1.

Question 3

12 marks

Explain why Russia's town workers had become so discontented by the start of 1917.

You may use the following in your answer:
- rising prices
- conditions in the factories

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

By the start of 1917 Russia's town workers were deeply discontented because the war had made their lives much harder, while the government seemed both unable and unwilling to help them.

The most immediate reason was rising prices. To pay for the war, the government printed huge amounts of paper money, and it had also lost its income from vodka after banning its sale in 1914. As a result, inflation soared. Wages rose, but the prices of bread, meat, fuel and rent rose much faster, so most workers could buy less with their pay in 1916 than in 1914. This meant that even workers in well-paid war industries felt poorer, and they blamed the government for allowing it.

The second reason was the shortage of food and fuel in the cities. The railways were overloaded with military traffic and could not bring enough grain and coal to Petrograd and Moscow. Workers' wives and daughters had to queue for hours in freezing weather for small amounts of bread or sugar, often to find nothing left. This daily hardship turned economic problems into anger at the authorities.

Conditions in the factories added to this anger. War production meant long shifts of ten to twelve hours or more, compulsory overtime and strict discipline. Workers who went on strike could lose their exemption from military service and be sent to the front. At the same time, the war industries drew in thousands of peasants, women and refugees, so housing in cities such as Petrograd became overcrowded and expensive.

The way the government treated protest made workers more hostile still. Strikes were broken up by the police and sometimes by troops, as at Ivanovo-Voznesensk in 1915, when soldiers fired on striking textile workers. In January 1917 the government even arrested the Workers' Group of the Central War Industries Committee, moderate workers' representatives who had co-operated with the war effort. This suggested that peaceful ways of improving conditions were closed.

Finally, discontent became more political. Rumours about Rasputin, the 'German' tsarina and treason at court convinced many workers that their suffering was the fault of a corrupt government. Bolsheviks and other socialists working secretly in factory districts such as Vyborg spread anti-war slogans. As a result, the strikes of October 1916 and the strike of over 100,000 Petrograd workers on 9 January 1917, the anniversary of Bloody Sunday, combined demands for bread with calls for an end to the war and to the autocracy.

Explanation

Top answers explain how each factor made workers more discontented, for example linking inflation to falling real wages and the government's war finance, and they go beyond the stimulus points (e.g. food queues, repression of strikes, political agitation). Weaker answers describe conditions without saying why they caused discontent, or drift into the events of February 1917, which belong to a different question. No judgement about the most important reason is needed.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Rising prices: to pay for the war the government printed money and borrowed (and lost the vodka revenue after prohibition in 1914), so inflation soared; the prices of food, fuel and rent rose much faster than wages, so most workers' real wages fell and families struggled to buy necessities (accept any reasonable indication that prices rose much faster than wages, e.g. food prices more than doubled between 1914 and the summer of 1916 while real wages fell; do not insist on exact figures). Conditions in the factories: war production meant long shifts (often 10-12 hours or more, with compulsory overtime), speed-ups, accidents and strict discipline; striking workers could lose their exemption from military service and be sent to the front. Shortages and queues: the overloaded railways could not bring enough grain and fuel to the cities, so workers' families (often the women) queued for hours in the cold for bread, sugar and meat, and some factories stopped for lack of fuel. Overcrowding: the war industries drew in peasants, women and refugees, so the population of Petrograd grew rapidly and housing became overcrowded and expensive. Repression: the police and troops broke up strikes (e.g. troops fired on textile workers at Ivanovo-Voznesensk in August 1915), strike leaders were arrested, and in late January 1917 (Russian calendar) the government arrested the Workers' Group of the Central War Industries Committee. War weariness: heavy casualties among workers' families and defeats at the front. Anger at the government: rumours of treason at court, the tsarina and Rasputin, and profiteering convinced many workers that the hardships were the government's fault. Political agitation: Bolsheviks and other socialists in factory districts such as Vyborg spread anti-war and anti-tsarist slogans, so strikes became more political (the strikes of October 1916; the strike of well over 100,000 Petrograd workers on 9 January 1917, the anniversary of Bloody Sunday; figures of about 140,000-150,000 are often given). Answers must explain why each factor caused discontent, not just describe conditions. The question is about the causes of discontent before the February Revolution: narrative of the events of 23 February 1917 onwards (International Women's Day, the mutiny, the abdication) does not answer it. Do not credit claims that workers were paid less in money terms than before the war (money wages generally rose, but more slowly than prices), or that the Bolsheviks controlled the strike movement.

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 4

20 marks

Interpretation 1: From The Fragile Autocracy: Russia at War, 1914-1917 by Douglas Penhallow (fictional), published in 1983.

Opposition to Nicholas II certainly grew during the war, but by early 1917 it was divided and, for the most part, still loyal to the monarchy. The liberals of the Progressive Bloc wanted ministers whom the country could trust, not a republic, and they feared that a revolution in wartime would lead to defeat. The nobles and grand dukes who attacked Rasputin and the tsarina were trying to save the throne, not to overthrow it. Most peasants grumbled about prices and requisitioning, but there was no great rising in the countryside, and the army at the front was still holding the line. The revolutionary parties were small and their leaders were in exile. The government still controlled the police and the army, and few of its critics expected it to collapse within weeks.

Interpretation 2: From A Throne Without Friends: Nicholas II, 1915-1917 by Harriet Wexcombe (fictional), published in 2012.

By the beginning of 1917 Nicholas II had lost the confidence of almost every group on which his throne depended. The Duma's moderate majority had given up hope of working with his ministers, and Milyukov's speech of November 1916, asking whether the government's actions showed 'stupidity or treason', was copied and passed round the country. Even the conservative State Council and the congress of the nobility demanded that the 'dark forces' around the throne be removed. Members of the royal family warned the tsar, the British Ambassador told him that his throne was in danger, and in December a group of monarchists, including a grand duke, murdered Rasputin. In the factories, strikes had become political. When the tsar ignored every warning, politicians and officers began to talk of forcing him to abdicate. Nicholas was isolated long before the crowds filled the streets of Petrograd.

How far do you agree with Interpretation 2 about the strength of opposition to Nicholas II by early 1917? Explain your answer, using both interpretations and your knowledge of the historical context.

Spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this question.

Model answer

Interpretation 2 argues that by early 1917 Nicholas II 'had lost the confidence of almost every group on which his throne depended', while Interpretation 1 argues that opposition was 'divided' and 'still loyal to the monarchy'. I largely agree with Interpretation 2 about how widespread opposition had become, although Interpretation 1 is right that most of it was not yet aimed at overthrowing the tsar.

Interpretation 2 is convincing about the breadth of the opposition. In 1915 the moderate majority in the Duma formed the Progressive Bloc and asked for a 'ministry of public confidence', but Nicholas ignored it and suspended the Duma. By November 1916 Milyukov was asking whether the government's actions showed 'stupidity or treason', and although his speech was cut from the newspaper reports, copies were passed all over the country. Even conservative bodies turned against the government: the State Council and the congress of the nobility demanded the removal of the 'dark forces', and the British Ambassador warned Nicholas that he was endangering his throne. When Prince Yusupov, Grand Duke Dmitri and the monarchist Purishkevich murdered Rasputin in December 1916, it showed that even the tsar's natural supporters had lost patience. In Petrograd, strikes had become political: on 9 January 1917, the anniversary of Bloody Sunday, well over 100,000 workers came out.

However, Interpretation 1 makes important points. Most of this criticism was aimed at the tsar's ministers, the tsarina and Rasputin rather than at the monarchy itself. The Progressive Bloc wanted ministers the country could trust, not a republic, and the conservative nobles who condemned the 'dark forces' wanted to change the tsar's advisers, not to remove the tsar. The men who killed Rasputin hoped to save the dynasty, not to destroy it. The opposition was also divided: the liberals feared that a revolution in wartime would lead to defeat, while the socialist parties were split over the war, small in number and led from exile. The government still controlled the police and the army, and in January 1917 it arrested the Workers' Group of the Central War Industries Committee.

The two interpretations convey their views differently. Interpretation 2 stresses isolation - 'almost every group', 'ignored every warning' - while Interpretation 1 stresses the limits of the opposition. Overall, Interpretation 1 is right that the opposition was divided and that most critics wanted reform rather than revolution. But Interpretation 2 better describes the tsar's position, because what mattered was that almost no important group still trusted him or would defend his government. Nicholas had not yet been overthrown, but he had become isolated, so that when serious unrest came there were few people willing to save him. I therefore largely agree with Interpretation 2.

Explanation

Top answers test Interpretation 2's claim that the tsar had lost the confidence of almost every group with precise knowledge (e.g. the Progressive Bloc, Milyukov's speech, the resolutions of the State Council and the nobility, the murder of Rasputin) and weigh it against Interpretation 1's point that the opposition was divided and mostly wanted reform, reaching a judgement with clear criteria. Weaker answers narrate the events of February 1917, write a general essay on the causes of the revolution, or treat the interpretations as sources to be judged for reliability.

Mark scheme
  1. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO4: 16 marks.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation reviewing the alternative views in coming to a substantiated judgement. Precise analysis of the interpretations is shown, indicating how the differences of view are conveyed and deploying this material to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is precisely selected to support the evaluation. An overall judgment is justified and the line of reasoning is coherent, sustained and logically structured.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Answer provides an explained evaluation, agreeing or disagreeing with the interpretation. Good analysis of the interpretations is shown indicating difference of view and deploying this to support the evaluation. Relevant contextual knowledge is used directly to support the evaluation. An overall judgement is given with some justification and a line of reasoning is generally sustained.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Answer offers valid evaluative comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Some analysis is shown in selecting and including details from both interpretations to support this comment. Some relevant contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation. An overall judgement is given but its justification is insecure or undeveloped and a line of reasoning is not sustained.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Answer offers simple valid comment to agree with or counter the interpretation. Limited analysis of one interpretation is shown by selection and inclusion of some detail in the form of simple paraphrase or direct quotation. Generalised contextual knowledge is included and linked to the evaluation.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Interpretation 2 argues that by early 1917 Nicholas II 'had lost the confidence of almost every group on which his throne depended' and was 'isolated'. Points from the interpretations and own knowledge that support Interpretation 2: the Progressive Bloc (formed in August 1915 by 236 deputies, a majority of the Duma) asked for a 'ministry of public confidence' and was ignored, and the Duma was suspended in September 1915; Milyukov's speech of 1 November 1916 was cut from the press reports but passed round in copies; the monarchist Purishkevich attacked the 'dark forces' at court in the Duma on 19 November 1916; in November-December 1916 the State Council and the Congress of the United Nobility, both conservative bodies, called for the 'dark forces' to be removed and for a government with the people's confidence; Prince Yusupov, Purishkevich and Grand Duke Dmitri murdered Rasputin on 16-17 December 1916; Guchkov and others discussed forcing the tsar to abdicate; political strikes in Petrograd in October 1916 and on 9 January 1917; British consuls reported in late 1916 that peasants were beginning to lose faith in the tsar. Points that counter it (including Interpretation 1): most critics attacked the ministers, Rasputin and the tsarina rather than the monarchy itself - the Progressive Bloc wanted a government the country could trust, not a republic, and the conservative State Council and nobility attacked the 'dark forces' around the throne, not the monarchy itself; the men who murdered Rasputin hoped to save the dynasty; the liberals feared that revolution in wartime would bring defeat; the opposition was divided (e.g. the socialists were split over the war); the revolutionary parties were small and their leaders were in exile or in Siberia; there was no widespread peasant rising before 1917; the front was still holding; the government still controlled the police and in late January 1917 (Russian calendar) arrested the Workers' Group of the Central War Industries Committee. Answers may note how the views are conveyed: Interpretation 2 stresses isolation ('almost every group', 'ignored every warning'), Interpretation 1 limits and divisions ('divided', 'still loyal to the monarchy'). A substantiated judgement might use criteria such as whether the critics had turned against Nicholas himself or only his government, or whether the opposition was united enough to remove him; e.g. almost no important group still trusted the tsar, but the opposition was divided and mostly wanted reform rather than revolution. Do not credit narrative of the events of 23 February-2 March 1917 (the strikes, the mutiny, the abdication) beyond brief reference, or treatment of the interpretations as sources to be judged for reliability. Dates may be given in either calendar (e.g. Milyukov's speech: 1 November 1916 in the Russian calendar, 14 November in the Western; the murder of Rasputin: the night of 16-17 December 1916, or 29-30 December).

    Pearson's marking instructions (part of the mark scheme): No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the interpretations. In all levels, the second sentence relates to analysis and while the rest relate to evaluation. The following rules will apply: In Level 1, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis without evidence of evaluation should be awarded 1 mark. In other levels, answers that meet the requirements only in relation to analysis (but that also fully meet the descriptors for evaluation of the level below) should be awarded no more than the bottom mark in the level.

  2. 4 marks

    SPaG. Spelling, punctuation, grammar and the use of specialist terminology (4 marks).
    High performance (4 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with effective control of meaning overall. Learners use a wide range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with general control of meaning overall. Learners use a good range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    Threshold performance (1 mark): Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy. Learners use rules of grammar with some control of meaning and any errors do not significantly hinder meaning overall. Learners use a limited range of specialist terms as appropriate.
    0 marks: The learner writes nothing. The learner's response does not relate to the question. The learner's achievement in SPaG does not reach the threshold performance level, e.g. errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar severely hinder meaning.

    SPaG is marked separately from the 16 marks for the answer, on the whole response.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.