Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From The People's Verdict: The Elections of November 1917 by Clive Hebblethwaite (fictional), published in 1962.
The elections to the Constituent Assembly in November 1917 were the freest that Russia had ever held. More than 40 million people voted, and their verdict was clear. The Socialist Revolutionaries, the party that most peasants trusted, came first by a wide margin. The Bolsheviks, despite having seized power only weeks earlier, won only about a quarter of the votes. Together, the parties that opposed one-party Bolshevik rule had a large majority. Whatever the Bolsheviks later claimed, most Russians had not voted for a Bolshevik government. When Lenin closed the Assembly after a single day, he was not correcting a faulty election; he was overturning the clearly expressed wishes of the Russian people.
Interpretation 2: From Votes and Power: The Bolsheviks and the Constituent Assembly by Rosalind Ingleby (fictional), published in 1998.
The election results are less straightforward than they first appear. The Socialist Revolutionaries' lists of candidates had been drawn up before the party split, so peasants voting for the SRs could not choose between its right wing and the Left SRs, who were allied to the Bolsheviks. In many remote villages, news of the October Revolution had barely arrived when voting took place. Where politics was most intense, the picture was different: the Bolsheviks won in Petrograd and Moscow and took a large share of the soldiers' votes, especially in the armies closest to the capitals. The results showed a country deeply divided, with the Bolsheviks strongest in the places that mattered most for holding power.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about what the elections to the Constituent Assembly showed about support for the Bolsheviks. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees the elections as a clear democratic rejection of the Bolsheviks, while Interpretation 2 argues that the results were misleading and showed a divided country in which the Bolsheviks were strong where it mattered. Interpretation 1 says that the elections were 'the freest that Russia had ever held' and that the 'verdict was clear': the Bolsheviks won 'only about a quarter of the votes', so Lenin was 'overturning the clearly expressed wishes of the Russian people'. Interpretation 2 says the results are 'less straightforward than they first appear', because the SR lists were drawn up 'before the party split' and news of October had 'barely arrived' in remote villages. It stresses that the Bolsheviks won 'Petrograd and Moscow' and many soldiers' votes, so they were 'strongest in the places that mattered most for holding power'.
Explanation
Top answers identify the overall difference (a clear verdict against the Bolsheviks v. an unclear result that hid their strength in the cities and the army) and support it from both interpretations. Answers that simply note that both mention the Socialist Revolutionaries, or that list details without stating the difference, stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees the election results as a clear democratic verdict that most Russians rejected Bolshevik rule, while Interpretation 2 argues that the results were misleading or out of date and show a divided country in which the Bolsheviks were strongest where it mattered for power. Interpretation 1: the elections were 'the freest that Russia had ever held'; 'More than 40 million people voted, and their verdict was clear'; the SRs 'came first by a wide margin' and the Bolsheviks won 'only about a quarter'; 'most Russians had not voted for a Bolshevik government'; Lenin was 'overturning the clearly expressed wishes of the Russian people'. Interpretation 2: the results are 'less straightforward than they first appear'; the SR lists were drawn up 'before the party split', so voters could not choose the Left SRs; news of October 'had barely arrived' in remote villages; the Bolsheviks 'won in Petrograd and Moscow' and many soldiers' votes; the results showed 'a country deeply divided', with the Bolsheviks 'strongest in the places that mattered most for holding power'. Level 2 needs this difference of view (a clear rejection of the Bolsheviks v. an unclear result with the Bolsheviks strong where it counted), supported from both interpretations. Both accept that the SRs won more votes; the difference lies in what the results mean. Answers that give only surface differences (e.g. 'Interpretation 1 gives a number of voters') or summarise each in turn without stating the difference stay in Level 1. Answers that explain why the views differ are answering a different question.