Question 1
4 marksSource B: From Soviet Communism: A New Civilisation? by Sidney and Beatrice Webb, published in Britain in 1935. The Webbs were leading British socialists who admired the Soviet system and believed that Stalin was not a dictator. They wrote the book after visiting the USSR in the early 1930s. By 'the governing junta' they mean the small group of Communist leaders around Stalin.
At this point it is necessary to observe that, although Stalin is, by the constitution, not in the least a dictator, having no power of command, and although he appears to be free from any desire to act as a dictator, and does not do so, he may be thought to have become irremovable from his position of supreme leadership of the Party, and therefore of the government. Why is this? We find the answer in the deliberate exploitation by the governing junta of the emotion of hero-worship, of the traditional reverence of the Russian people for a personal autocrat. ... After Lenin's death, it was agreed that his place could never be filled. But some new personality had to be produced for the hundred and sixty millions to revere. There presently ensued a tacit understanding among the junta that Stalin should be 'boosted' as the supreme leader of the proletariat, the Party and the state. His portrait and his bust were accordingly distributed by tens of thousands, and they are now everywhere publicly displayed along with those of Marx and Lenin.
Source C: From The Revolution Betrayed by Leon Trotsky, written in 1936 and soon published in translation in several countries (translated for this course). Trotsky, Stalin's main rival in the 1920s, had been expelled from the USSR in 1929 and was living in exile in Norway. By 'the bureaucracy' and 'the caste' he means the Party officials and managers who ran the Soviet state.
The ruling caste strives to strengthen and perpetuate the organs of compulsion. To secure its power and its income it spares nothing and no one. ... Like the Catholic Church, it put forward the dogma of infallibility in the period of its decline, but it at once raised it to a height of which the Pope of Rome cannot even dream. The ever more insistent deification of Stalin is, for all its elements of caricature, a necessary element of the regime. The bureaucracy needs an inviolable super-arbiter, a first consul if not an emperor, and it raises on its shoulders the man who best answers its claim to dominance. ... Each of them at his post thinks: 'I am the state.' In Stalin each of them easily finds himself. ... Stalin is the personification of the bureaucracy: that is what his political personality consists of.
Interpretation 1: From The Father of the Peoples: Tradition and the Stalin Cult by Andrew Pomfret (fictional), published in 1975.
The Cult of Stalin grew out of Russian traditions as much as out of Stalin's ambition. For centuries the peasants had looked to the tsar as a 'little father' who would protect them from cruel officials, and Lenin had been honoured almost as a saint after his death in 1924. The Bolshevik leaders understood that a vast, mainly peasant population, much of it barely literate, would follow a person more readily than an idea. By building up Stalin as the wise father of the Soviet peoples, they gave the regime a familiar face during the upheavals of collectivisation and industrialisation, when millions of people were uprooted from their old way of life.
Interpretation 2: From The Leader and the Apparatus: Power in Stalin's USSR by Lucy Quayle (fictional), published in 2010.
The cult served the interests of those who ruled the Soviet Union. A new class of Party officials, managers and police chiefs had gained power and privileges in the 1930s, and they needed a leader who stood above all criticism. By making Stalin infallible, they made the policies they carried out unquestionable, and any complaint against them could be treated as an attack on Stalin himself. Officials competed to praise him because their careers depended on showing loyalty. The cult was not mainly a response to popular feeling; it was a way of protecting a system of power.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the purpose of the Cult of Stalin. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because their authors have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 could be based on evidence like Source B, in which the Webbs explain the cult by 'the traditional reverence of the Russian people for a personal autocrat'. They argue that after Lenin's death 'some new personality had to be produced for the hundred and sixty millions to revere', so the leaders agreed that Stalin should be 'boosted'. This supports Interpretation 1's view that the cult drew on the tradition of the tsar as a 'little father' and that the leaders knew the people 'would follow a person more readily than an idea'. Interpretation 2 is closer to Source C, in which Trotsky argues that the 'deification of Stalin' was 'a necessary element of the regime' because 'the bureaucracy needs an inviolable super-arbiter' to protect 'its power and its income'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that officials 'needed a leader who stood above all criticism' and that the cult was 'a way of protecting a system of power'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching details in each source to details in an interpretation, such as the Webbs' 'traditional reverence ... for a personal autocrat' and Interpretation 1's 'little father'. A strong answer may add that the Webbs, as admirers of the USSR, and Trotsky, as Stalin's exiled enemy, explained the cult in very different ways. Repeating the difference of view is not enough.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: the Webbs explain the cult by 'the traditional reverence of the Russian people for a personal autocrat' and 'the emotion of hero-worship', note that after Lenin's death 'some new personality had to be produced for the hundred and sixty millions to revere', and say that the leaders deliberately 'boosted' Stalin; this matches Interpretation 1's 'little father' tradition, Lenin 'honoured almost as a saint' and the leaders who 'understood that a vast ... population ... would follow a person more readily than an idea'. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: Trotsky says the 'deification of Stalin' is 'a necessary element of the regime' because 'the bureaucracy needs an inviolable super-arbiter', that the 'ruling caste' acts 'to secure its power and its income', and that 'Stalin is the personification of the bureaucracy'; this matches Interpretation 2's 'new class of Party officials, managers and police chiefs' who 'needed a leader who stood above all criticism' and its conclusion that the cult was 'a way of protecting a system of power'. A student may note the provenance: the Webbs admired the USSR and looked for explanations in Russian tradition, while Trotsky, Stalin's exiled enemy, saw the regime as the betrayal of the revolution by a privileged bureaucracy; a historian following either would reach a different view. The interpretations may differ because of a different focus: Interpretation 1 looks at the people the cult was aimed at (the peasant masses), Interpretation 2 at those who organised it (the officials). They may differ because of a different approach: Interpretation 1 explains the cult culturally (tradition, religion, literacy), Interpretation 2 politically (power and privilege). Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations (and, if used, matched details from the sources). Answers that only say 'Interpretation 2 used Source C' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on dates of publication or assertions of bias.