Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a report on the village of Ozero, about 60 miles from Samara on the River Volga, written by Charles Roden Buxton and published in London in 1920 in the report of the British Labour Delegation to Russia. Buxton, a British Labour Party member and one of the delegation's two secretaries, stayed in peasants' houses in the district for a week in 1920. A desiatine is a Russian measure of land.
There is bitter resentment at the amount and variety of the demands, the awkward times at which they are made, and the low prices paid. "Commissars - powerful persons - are continually coming here," said one peasant to me, "we don't know what to do with them." ...
The peasants could get far more for their produce, they say, if they could sell in the open market. This is a very sore point. ...
There was a sharp fall in the amount of land ploughed and sown last autumn and spring - i.e., for the harvest of 1920. ... According to the "three-field system," 3,000 desiatines are usually ploughed and sown each year, the rest lying fallow. Last autumn and spring, however, only about 900 desiatines were ploughed and sown. ... This is generally ascribed in the village to the mobilisation of horses and carts for transporting supplies. ...
The majority of peasants in Ozero ... consider that they owe much to the Soviet Government in the matter of the land; ... But they complain bitterly of three things: first, and most important of all, the high cost of living and the absence of many necessities ...; secondly, the compulsory contributions ...; and thirdly, the worry of perpetual orders and appeals, often hard to understand.
Source C: From The Bolshevik Myth by Alexander Berkman, published in 1925. Berkman, an anarchist who had been deported from the USA, lived in Soviet Russia from January 1920 to December 1921 and became a bitter critic of the Bolsheviks. The book is based on his diary. Here he records what Lev Karakhan, the Bolsheviks' Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs, told him in Moscow in February 1920. A muzhik was a peasant (plural muzhiki); graphophones were gramophones.
Referring to the peasantry, Karakhan asserted that the farmer profited by the Revolution more than any other part of the population. "Why," he exclaimed, "in the villages you will find upholstered furniture, French mirrors, graphophones, and pianos, all given to them by the city in exchange for food. The luxuries of the mansion have been transferred to the hovel," he laughed ... "We have declared 'war to the palaces, peace to the huts,'" he continued, "and the muzhik lives like a barin (master) now. But the Russian peasant is backward and deeply imbued with the petty bourgeois spirit of ownership. The kulaki (well-to-do peasants) often refuse to contribute of their surplus, but the Army and the city proletariat must be fed, of course. We have therefore been compelled to resort to the razvyorstka (requisition) - an unpleasant system, forced upon us by the Allied blockade. The peasants must do their share to sustain the soldiers and the workers who are the vanguard of the Revolution, and on the whole they do so. Occasionally the muzhiki resist requisition, and in such cases the military is called upon. Unfortunate occurrences, but not very frequent. ..."
Interpretation 1: From The Hungry Villages: The Russian Peasantry under War Communism by Owen Liddicoat (fictional), published in 1986.
For the peasants, War Communism meant three years of seizure and fear. Armed food detachments arrived in the villages to take whatever grain they could find, often leaving families too little to eat or to sow. The payment, in paper roubles that were almost worthless, could buy nothing, because the towns had no goods to send. Peasants answered by hiding grain and sowing less, so that by 1920 the area under crops had fallen sharply. Thousands rose in revolt, most famously in Tambov province in 1920-21, and the requisitions left the countryside with no reserves when drought struck the Volga region in 1921. The peasants had gained the land in 1917, but War Communism took away most of its fruits.
Interpretation 2: From Winners of the Revolution? The Peasants and the Soviet State, 1917-21 by Margaret Cuthill (fictional), published in 2005.
It is easy to exaggerate the sufferings of the peasants under War Communism. The revolution had given them the landlords' estates, and most villages were better fed than the hungry towns, where workers queued for tiny rations. Requisitioning was harsh, but the state never had enough officials to enforce it everywhere, and peasants became expert at hiding grain and selling it secretly to townspeople at high prices. Above all, the peasants knew that a White victory would bring back the landlords, which is why most of them put up with the Bolsheviks while the Civil War lasted. Only when the Whites had been defeated did the peasants' patience finally run out.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the effects of War Communism on the peasants. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians may have given weight to different kinds of evidence. Interpretation 1, which says War Communism brought 'seizure and fear', is supported by Source B. Buxton stayed in a village and recorded 'bitter resentment' at the demands and 'the low prices paid', and a fall from 3,000 to about 900 desiatines ploughed and sown. This matches Interpretation 1's claim that peasants were 'sowing less' and that 'the area under crops had fallen sharply'. Interpretation 2, which argues that peasant sufferings are easy to exaggerate, is supported by Source C. Karakhan claims that 'the farmer profited by the Revolution more than any other part of the population', that townspeople had handed over pianos and furniture 'in exchange for food', and that most peasants accepted requisitioning. This matches Interpretation 2's view that villages were 'better fed than the hungry towns' and that peasants sold food secretly to townspeople.
Explanation
Top answers explain a reason for the difference and support it precisely, for example by matching Buxton's figures on sowing to Interpretation 1 and Karakhan's claim that the peasants 'profited by the Revolution' to Interpretation 2. Saying only that a historian 'used Source B', or claiming that one historian is biased or wrote later, does not explain the difference.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reasons may include: (1) The historians may have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1, which stresses resentment and the fall in sowing, is supported by Source B: Buxton, who lived in a village for a week, records 'bitter resentment' at the demands and 'the low prices paid', complaints about the 'compulsory contributions', and a fall from 3,000 to about 900 desiatines ploughed and sown, which matches Interpretation 1's 'sowing less' and 'the area under crops had fallen sharply'. Interpretation 2, which says the peasants coped and gained more than others, is supported by Source C: Karakhan says 'the farmer profited by the Revolution more than any other part of the population', that townspeople had given the villages furniture, mirrors and pianos 'in exchange for food' so that 'the muzhik lives like a barin (master) now', and that most peasants accepted requisitioning ('on the whole they do so') with resistance 'not very frequent', which matches Interpretation 2's view that villages were 'better fed than the hungry towns', that peasants sold grain secretly to townspeople, and that most 'put up with the Bolsheviks'. (2) The interpretations have a different focus: Interpretation 1 concentrates on requisitioning and its consequences (revolts, no reserves when drought struck in 1921), while Interpretation 2 concentrates on what the peasants gained from the revolution and how they avoided the state's demands, and compares them with the towns. (3) Different time span: Interpretation 1 follows the story into 1920-21 and the drought, while Interpretation 2 explains why peasants accepted the Bolsheviks 'while the Civil War lasted'. Level 2 needs a reason that is explained and supported with details from the interpretations (and, where used, the sources). Matching must be specific: 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without showing which details match stays in Level 1. Reasons based only on the date of publication or the titles of the books, or bare claims of bias, are not valid. Answers that only describe the difference are answering a different question.