Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the memoirs of General Pyotr Wrangel, published in 1928 (translated for this course). In 1919 Wrangel commanded one of the White armies in southern Russia under General Anton Denikin, the White commander-in-chief there, and in April 1920 he replaced Denikin. Here he writes about the first half of 1919 and the statements of aims issued by Denikin's government. The Special Council was the body that governed the areas held by Denikin's forces.
While the most urgent practical questions remained unsettled, the high command was trying to settle a series of questions on an all-Russian scale, which were to cover every area of the organisation of the Russian state. These questions were being worked out by the Special Council, which the Commander-in-Chief had formed from people chosen personally by General Denikin. ... A little later a 'special declaration' was issued on 'the aims pursued by the command of the Armed Forces in the South of Russia in the armed struggle against Soviet power and in building the state'. None of these documents offered anything real; they were limited to generalities such as 'the destruction of Bolshevik anarchy in the country and the establishment of legal order in the country', 'the restoration of a mighty, United and Indivisible Russia', 'broad local self-government', 'guarantees of freedoms', 'an immediate start on land reform to remove the land shortage of the working population', 'the immediate introduction of labour laws protecting the working classes from exploitation by the state and by capital ...'. All this was as indisputable as it was vague. The programme of the high command set out in these documents was to guide the work of 'Osvag', the propaganda department, whose task was to counter the propaganda of the Bolsheviks.
Source C: From Russia To-day and To-morrow by Pavel Milyukov, published in the USA in 1922. Milyukov was the leader of the Kadets, Russia's main liberal party, and had been Foreign Minister in the Provisional Government in 1917. Until 1920 he supported the White armies and hoped that they would defeat the Bolsheviks. The book is based on lectures he gave in Boston in 1921, when he was living in exile.
There was little reason for suspicion at the beginning of the anti-Bolshevist struggle. There were reactionary elements among the "whites" but they kept quiet; the enthusiasm of the Revolution was as yet too strong in the "white" ranks to encourage that particular group. All the political elements, socialistic, democratic, liberal and conservative, stood together and there was no difference of opinion between them as to the admissibility of Allied help, which had not yet been called "intervention." However, gradually the military anti-Bolshevist movement degenerated into a purely reactionary movement. As a consequence, the socialist groups were the first to change their attitude towards it. They declared themselves neutral. For the Russian non-socialist liberal democracy, to which I belong, it also became increasingly difficult to identify itself with the reactionary tendencies of the "white" movement.
Interpretation 1: From The Old Order in Arms: The White Movement, 1918-20 by Hugh Tarrington (fictional), published in 1971.
Whatever their leaders promised, the White armies were fighting to bring back the old Russia. They were commanded by generals and officers of the tsar's army, many of them monarchists, and their governments were staffed by former tsarist officials. Behind the advancing armies came the landowners, demanding the return of their estates and a share of the peasants' harvest. Kolchak came to power in November 1918 by overthrowing the Socialist Revolutionaries in his own camp, and neither he nor Denikin would confirm the peasants' right to the land they had seized in 1917. Their slogan of 'Russia, One and Indivisible' meant restoring the empire and refusing independence to the Finns, Ukrainians and other peoples. To most Russians, a White victory meant the return of the landlord, the general and the policeman.
Interpretation 2: From Patriots in Epaulettes: The White Leaders, 1918-20 by Alison Coverdale (fictional), published in 2004.
It is a mistake to see the White leaders simply as servants of the old regime. Neither Kolchak nor Denikin promised to restore the tsar. They saw themselves as patriots who were fighting to rebuild a united Russian state, to end what they called Bolshevik anarchy and to restore the rule of law. Both said that the future form of government, and the land question, must be decided by a national assembly elected by the whole people once the Bolsheviks had been defeated. In 1919 Denikin's government promised local self-government, civil freedoms, land reform and laws to protect workers. In 1918 liberals and some moderate socialists took part in the anti-Bolshevik governments, and many officers believed that they were fighting for Russia, not for the Romanovs.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the aims of the White movement. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason the interpretations differ is that the historians may have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 2 argues that the White leaders were patriots, not servants of the old regime, and that Denikin's government 'promised local self-government, civil freedoms, land reform and laws to protect workers'. This is supported by Source B, which lists the aims Denikin's command declared in 1919: 'legal order', 'a mighty, United and Indivisible Russia', 'broad local self-government', 'guarantees of freedoms', 'land reform' and 'labour laws'. Interpretation 1 argues that the Whites were 'fighting to bring back the old Russia'. This fits Source C, where Milyukov, a liberal who had supported the Whites, admits that the movement 'degenerated into a purely reactionary movement'. A historian relying on the Whites' official declarations would reach Interpretation 2's view, while one relying on their former allies would reach Interpretation 1's.
Explanation
Top answers explain one reason and support it precisely, for example by matching the aims listed in Denikin's declaration in Source B to Interpretation 2, and Milyukov's admission that the movement 'degenerated into a purely reactionary movement' in Source C to Interpretation 1. Answers that simply say the historians used different evidence, or that point to the dates of publication without explanation, stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 2: the aims that Denikin's command declared in 1919 - 'legal order', 'a mighty, United and Indivisible Russia', 'broad local self-government', 'guarantees of freedoms', 'land reform' for 'the working population' and 'labour laws' protecting workers from 'exploitation by the state and by capital' - match Interpretation 2's view that the White leaders were patriots who 'promised local self-government, civil freedoms, land reform and laws to protect workers' and did not promise to restore the tsar. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 1: Milyukov, a liberal who had backed the Whites, says the military anti-Bolshevik movement 'degenerated into a purely reactionary movement', so that the socialists 'declared themselves neutral' and liberals found it hard to accept its 'reactionary tendencies' - matching Interpretation 1's view that the Whites were 'fighting to bring back the old Russia'. A historian who relied on the Whites' own declarations would stress their stated aims; one who relied on what supporters and observers saw happening would stress reaction. Each source also contains material for the other view (Wrangel calls the declarations 'vague' and says they offered 'nothing real' and were written to guide propaganda; Milyukov says that at first 'all the political elements ... stood together'), so the difference may come from which parts of the evidence each historian selected. The interpretations may also differ because of their focus: Interpretation 2 looks at what the leaders, Kolchak and Denikin, said they intended, and at 1918, when liberals and moderate socialists still took part; Interpretation 1 looks at what the White armies and governments did in practice (officers, officials, landowners returning with the armies, Kolchak's overthrow of the Socialist Revolutionaries, the land question, 'Russia, One and Indivisible'). Level 2 needs a reason explained and supported from the interpretations (and, if used, matched to details in the sources). Answers that only say 'they used different sources' or point to the dates of publication without explaining how this produced the difference stay in Level 1. Do not credit answers that simply repeat the difference between the interpretations.