Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the Constitution of the USSR, approved by the Extraordinary Eighth Congress of Soviets in Moscow on 5 December 1936. It soon became known as the 'Stalin Constitution'. Article 13 went on to list eleven Union Republics, among them the Ukrainian, Byelorussian, Georgian, Uzbek and Kazakh Soviet Socialist Republics. Article 14, not printed here, gave the government of the whole USSR control of foreign affairs, war and peace, defence, foreign trade, state security, the economic plans, the budget and the banks. This English translation was published in London by the Russia To-day Society.
ARTICLE 13
The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics is a federated state, formed on the basis of the voluntary association of Soviet Socialist Republics possessing equal rights ...
ARTICLE 15
The sovereignty of the Union Republics is restricted only within the limits set forth in Article 14 of the Constitution of the U.S.S.R. Outside of these limits, each Union Republic exercises state power independently. The U.S.S.R. protects the sovereign rights of the Union Republics.
ARTICLE 17
To every Union Republic is reserved the right free to secede from the U.S.S.R.
ARTICLE 18
The territory of the Union Republics may not be altered without their consent.
[From ARTICLE 35]
The Soviet of Nationalities is elected by the citizens of the U.S.S.R. according to Union and Autonomous Republics, Autonomous Regions and national areas on the basis of twenty-five deputies from each Union Republic ...
Source C: From the official English record of the trial of the 'Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites', published by the People's Commissariat of Justice in Moscow in 1938. The twenty-one defendants included Akmal Ikramov, the head of the Communist Party of Uzbekistan from 1929 to 1937, and Faizulla Khodjayev, who had headed the government of the Uzbek Soviet Socialist Republic since the 1920s. Both had been arrested in 1937; at the trial they confessed, and they were shot in March 1938. Here the indictment, read at the start of the trial, sets out the charges.
... accused of having on the instructions of the intelligence services of foreign states hostile to the Soviet Union formed a conspiratorial group named the "bloc of Rights and Trotskyites" with the object of espionage on behalf of foreign states, wrecking, diversionist and terrorist activities, undermining the military power of the U.S.S.R., provoking a military attack by these states on the U.S.S.R., dismembering the U.S.S.R. and severing from it the Ukraine, Byelorussia, the Central Asiatic Republics, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan and the Maritime Region of the Far East for the benefit of the aforementioned foreign states ...
The investigation has established that the "bloc of Rights and Trotskyites" united within its ranks underground anti-Soviet groups of Trotskyites, Rights, Zinovievites, Mensheviks, Socialist-Revolutionaries and bourgeois nationalists of the Ukraine, Byelorussia, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan and the Central Asiatic Republics ...
The investigation has revealed considerable undermining wrecking activities in the sphere of agriculture also in Uzbekistan, where the nationalist organizations, which, through their leaders, the accused IKRAMOV and KHODJAYEV, were in alliance with the centre of the anti-Soviet conspiracy, operated.
Interpretation 1: From Nations of the Union: The Soviet Republics in the 1930s by Stephen Wetherall (fictional), published in 1994.
By the late 1930s the Soviet Union's national republics had become real states within a federal union. The 1936 Constitution recognised eleven Union Republics, each with its own constitution, government, budget and official language, and guaranteed their right to leave the Union. Their peoples were represented in Moscow in a Soviet of Nationalities, in which every Union Republic had the same number of deputies, however small its population. The republics ran their own schools, courts, health services and local industry, mostly in their own languages, and by the 1930s many of their officials were local people trained in Soviet universities and Party schools. For many nations of the old empire, this was the first time they had had a state of their own.
Interpretation 2: From Moscow's Republics: Power and Nationality under Stalin by Claire Ansty (fictional), published in 2011.
The republics' self-government existed on paper only. The Constitution gave Moscow control of everything that mattered: defence, foreign policy, the economic plan, the budget and state security. Above all, every republic was run by a branch of one centralised Communist Party, whose leaders obeyed Stalin and the Politburo, and Moscow appointed and removed the republics' leaders as it chose. In 1937-38 most of the republics' leaders were arrested as 'bourgeois nationalists' and accused of plotting to break their countries away from the USSR - the very right that the Constitution had just promised them. The heads of Uzbekistan's Party and government were put on trial in Moscow and shot. No republic was free to choose its own leaders, let alone to leave.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the national republics of the USSR governed themselves in the years 1936-38. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because their authors have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 could be based on evidence like Source B, the 1936 Constitution, which describes the USSR as a 'federated state' formed by the 'voluntary association' of republics 'possessing equal rights', says that each Union Republic 'exercises state power independently' and reserves to every republic 'the right free to secede'. It also gives each Union Republic twenty-five deputies in the Soviet of Nationalities. This supports Interpretation 1's view that the republics were 'real states within a federal union' with the right to leave and equal representation in Moscow. Interpretation 2 is closer to Source C, the official record of the 1938 trial, in which the leaders of Uzbekistan, Ikramov and Khodjayev, were accused of belonging to a conspiracy aimed at 'severing from it the Ukraine, Byelorussia, the Central Asiatic Republics' and others. This fits Interpretation 2's argument that the republics' leaders were arrested as 'bourgeois nationalists' for supposedly plotting to break away, 'the very right that the Constitution had just promised them'. So one historian has relied on what the law said, and the other on what happened to the republics' leaders in practice.
Explanation
Top answers give one reason, such as the use of different sources or a focus on the law rather than on practice, and support it by matching details from the sources to details in each interpretation. Answers that repeat the two views, or rely on dates of publication or bias, stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because their authors have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the 1936 Constitution describes a 'federated state' formed by the 'voluntary association' of republics 'possessing equal rights', says that each Union Republic 'exercises state power independently' outside the limits of Article 14, reserves to every republic 'the right free to secede', protects their territory and gives every Union Republic twenty-five deputies in the Soviet of Nationalities; this matches Interpretation 1's 'real states within a federal union', their 'right to leave the Union' and the equal representation in the Soviet of Nationalities. Source C supports Interpretation 2: the indictment of 1938 accused the defendants of 'dismembering the U.S.S.R. and severing from it the Ukraine, Byelorussia, the Central Asiatic Republics, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan' for the benefit of foreign states, linked 'bourgeois nationalists' of the republics to the conspiracy and named the Uzbek leaders Ikramov and Khodjayev; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the republics' leaders were arrested as 'bourgeois nationalists' accused of plotting to break away, 'the very right that the Constitution had just promised them'. A student may note that B shows what the law said and C what happened to republican leaders whom Moscow saw as disloyal. The interpretations may differ because of a different focus: Interpretation 1 on the legal structure and the work of the republics' own institutions (schools, courts, languages, local officials), Interpretation 2 on where real power lay (the single Party, Moscow's appointments, state security) and on the purges. They may also differ in the evidence they treat as decisive: written rules (Interpretation 1) or the practice of the Terror (Interpretation 2). Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations (and, if used, matched details from the sources). Answers that only repeat the difference of view, or say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on dates of publication or assumed bias.