In the UK, many homes are heated by gas boilers, which burn natural gas (mainly methane).
A heat pump is an electrical device that heats a home by transferring energy from the air outside. A heat pump transfers about three times as much energy to the home as the electrical energy it uses.
In 2024, about half of the UK's electricity was generated from renewable resources and about one third was generated by burning fossil fuels, mainly natural gas (Department for Energy Security and Net Zero).
Evaluate replacing gas boilers with heat pumps as a way of reducing the UK's carbon dioxide emissions.
Model answer
Heat pumps would mean no natural gas is burned in homes, so no carbon dioxide is released there. About half of UK electricity comes from renewable resources, which release almost no carbon dioxide, and a heat pump gives about three times as much energy as it uses.
However, about a third of the electricity is still made by burning fossil fuels, so some carbon dioxide is still released at power stations. Heat pumps are also expensive to fit, and changing millions of homes would take a long time.
Overall, heat pumps would reduce carbon dioxide emissions, and the benefit will grow as more electricity comes from renewable resources, but the change will be slow and costly.
Explanation
An evaluation needs both sides and a judgement. Use the information given: renewable electricity and the heat pump's high output are advantages, while the electricity still made from fossil fuels, the cost and the scale of the change are disadvantages. Answers that give only advantages or only disadvantages cannot get full marks.