Question 1
1 markWhich is an advantage of using a flame photometer rather than a flame test to analyse a solution of metal ions?
Choose your answer.
- A it can also identify halide ions
- B it measures the concentration of ions
- C it needs no reference data
- D it works on undissolved solids
Model answer
B
A flame photometer measures the concentration of the metal ions; a flame test only identifies them.
Explanation
A flame test is qualitative, but a flame photometer gives readings that can be turned into concentrations using a calibration curve, and its data can be compared with reference data to identify metal ions. It works on solutions of metal ions only, so it cannot identify negative ions such as halides.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B / it measures the concentration of ions (1)
The only correct answer is B: a flame photometer, with a calibration curve, gives the concentration of a metal ion in a solution, whereas a flame test only shows which metal ion is present. A is not correct because a flame photometer analyses metal ions, not halide ions; C is not correct because metal ions are identified by comparing the data with reference data; D is not correct because a flame photometer analyses ions in dilute solution. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.