Question 1
1 markA scientist burned equal masses of diamond and graphite separately in excess oxygen. Each produced the same mass of carbon dioxide, and no other product was formed.
What does this result show about diamond and graphite?
Choose your answer.
- A both contain hydrogen
- B both are forms of carbon
- C both have the same structure
- D both are made of molecules
Model answer
B both are forms of carbon
Explanation
Diamond and graphite are different forms of the same element, carbon: both are made only of carbon atoms, so both burn in excess oxygen to give only carbon dioxide, and equal masses give equal masses of carbon dioxide. Their properties are very different because their atoms are arranged and bonded differently, which an experiment like this cannot show. Choosing 'same structure' confuses the element with its structure.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B / both are forms of carbon (1)
The only correct answer is B: both burn to give only carbon dioxide, and equal masses give equal masses of carbon dioxide, so both contain only carbon atoms - they are different forms of the element carbon. A is not correct because a substance containing hydrogen would also form water when it burns; C is not correct because burning shows only which element they contain, not how the atoms are arranged - in diamond each carbon atom is bonded to four others in a 3D network, while graphite has layers with each atom bonded to three others; D is not correct because diamond and graphite are giant covalent substances, not molecules, and burning does not show their structure. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.