Question 1
1 markGoing down group 1, the number of protons in the nucleus of each atom increases. However, the attraction between the nucleus and the outer electron becomes weaker, so the outer electron is lost more easily and the metals become more reactive.
Which statement explains why the attraction becomes weaker?
Choose your answer.
- A electron further away and shielded
- B extra protons repel the electron
- C more electrons in the outer shell
- D neutrons cancel out the protons
Model answer
A electron further away and shielded
Explanation
The nuclear charge increases down group 1, but each atom also has one more occupied shell. The outer electron is therefore further from the nucleus and shielded by more inner electrons, so overall it is attracted less strongly and is lost more easily. Thinking that more protons must always mean a stronger attraction, or that neutrons cancel positive charge, are common errors.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / electron further away and shielded (1)
The only correct answer is A: each atom further down the group has one more occupied shell, so the outer electron is further from the nucleus and is shielded by more inner electrons; these effects outweigh the larger number of protons, so the attraction is weaker. B is not correct because protons attract electrons (opposite charges attract); they do not repel them. C is not correct because every alkali metal atom has only one electron in its outer shell. D is not correct because neutrons have no charge, so they cannot cancel the charge of the protons. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.