Question 1
6 marksTwo ice skaters, Aled and Bryony, are at rest on a horizontal ice rink, 14 m apart, each holding one end of a light rope. Aled has mass 60 kg and Bryony has mass 45 kg. Aled pulls the rope in, hand over hand, so that the rope stays horizontal and straight and the tension in it is a constant 45 N. The skaters are modelled as particles moving along the straight line joining them, and the ice is modelled as smooth.
Find the time that passes before the skaters meet, and the distance that Aled moves in this time.
[Constant acceleration: \(v = u + at\), \(s = ut + \dfrac{1}{2}at^2\), \(s = vt - \dfrac{1}{2}at^2\), \(v^2 = u^2 + 2as\), \(s = \dfrac{1}{2}(u + v)t\)]
Model answer
The rope is light, so the tension is 45 N at both ends: it pulls each skater towards the other.
Aled: \(45 = 60a_A\), so \(a_A = 0.75\ \text{m s}^{-2}\)
Bryony: \(45 = 45a_B\), so \(a_B = 1\ \text{m s}^{-2}\)
Both start from rest and move towards each other, so they meet when their distances add up to 14 m:
\(\dfrac{1}{2}(0.75)t^2 + \dfrac{1}{2}(1)t^2 = 14\)
\(0.875t^2 = 14\), \(t^2 = 16\), \(t = 4\) s
Aled moves \(\dfrac{1}{2} \times 0.75 \times 4^2 = 6\) m (and Bryony moves 8 m).
Explanation
By Newton's third law the rope pulls Aled towards Bryony as he pulls on it, and because the rope is light the same 45 N tension pulls Bryony towards Aled, so each skater accelerates with 45 N divided by their own mass. They meet when the distances they move from rest add up to 14 m. Common errors are treating the skaters as one body with a single acceleration, and thinking that only Bryony moves because only Aled is pulling.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
M1 Newton's second law for one skater, with the tension of 45 N as the only horizontal force on that skater: \(45 = 60a_A\) or \(45 = 45a_B\); or correct answers of 4 s and 6 m with no working
Correct answers of 4 s and 6 m with no working score 2 marks (the final A marks). M0 if the skater's mass is omitted, or if the skaters are treated as one body with a single acceleration (\(45 = 105a\)).
-
1 mark
A1 Aled: \(a_A = 0.75\ \text{m s}^{-2}\) (towards Bryony)
-
1 mark
A1 Bryony: \(a_B = 1\ \text{m s}^{-2}\) (towards Aled), with the same tension of 45 N acting on her
Depends on the M mark. The rope is light, so the tension is the same at both ends (and by Newton's third law the rope pulls Aled as hard as he pulls it). A tension other than 45 N on Bryony, or \(a_B = 0\), is A0.
-
1 mark
M1 Uses \(s = ut + \dfrac{1}{2}at^2\) from rest for each skater and sets the sum of their distances equal to 14: \(\dfrac{1}{2}(0.75)t^2 + \dfrac{1}{2}(1)t^2 = 14\)
With their accelerations. M0 for equating the two distances, or for one skater's distance alone equal to 14.
-
1 mark
A1 \(t = 4\) s
-
1 mark
A1 Aled moves \(\dfrac{1}{2} \times 0.75 \times 4^2 = 6\) m
Depends on the second M mark. ft \(\dfrac{1}{2} \times\) their \(a_A \times\) their \(t^2\). 8 m (Bryony's distance) as the answer is A0. No \(g\) is used, so the answers are exact.