Source A: Plutarch, Life of Alcibiades 8
Hipparete had married the Athenian politician Alcibiades, bringing a very large dowry.
'Hipparete was a well-behaved and loving wife, but she was distressed by her husband's affairs with courtesans, both foreign and Athenian, so she left his house and went to live with her brother. When Alcibiades took no notice and carried on as before, she had to register her divorce with the archon, and to do this not through others but in person. When she appeared in public to do this, Alcibiades came up, seized her and carried her home through the agora, and no one dared to oppose him or take her away from him.'
Explain what this story shows about divorce in Athens.
Model answer
The story shows that an Athenian wife could seek a divorce, but it was very difficult: Hipparete had to register it with the archon 'in person', appearing in public, which a respectable woman would find shaming. It also shows that she depended on her male relatives, since she went to live with her brother. Finally, it shows the husband's power: Alcibiades simply seized her and carried her home through the agora, and 'no one dared to oppose him', perhaps because a divorce would have forced him to return her large dowry.
Explanation
A husband could end a marriage simply by sending his wife back to her family, but a wife had to go through the archon. The dowry had to be returned on divorce, which protected wives to some degree but also gave husbands a motive to keep them. The double standard is clear: Alcibiades' affairs with courtesans were not a crime, while a wife's adultery was severely punished.