Source A: Aristophanes, Assemblywomen, from the rehearsal scene (lines 1-240). A woman has put on the garland worn by speakers in the Assembly.
WOMAN: 'So where's the drink?'
PRAXAGORA: 'Drink? Did you think you'd come here to drink?'
WOMAN: 'Well, don't men drink in the Assembly?'
PRAXAGORA: 'Oh, so they drink, do they?'
WOMAN: 'Yes, by Artemis, and unmixed wine too! That's why all their decisions, if you think about them, are crazy, like the decisions of drunk men. And they pour libations - why else would they pray so much, if there were no wine? And they shout abuse at each other like drunks, and the archers carry out anyone who has had too much.'
PRAXAGORA: 'Go and sit down. You're useless.'
To what extent is Assemblywomen simply a joke at women's expense? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
Source A is partly a joke at women's expense. The woman puts on the speaker's garland and immediately assumes it means a party, playing on the stereotype, found throughout the opening of the play, that women are secret drinkers. Elsewhere in lines 1-240 the women give themselves away by swearing by the two goddesses and wanting to card wool in the Assembly, the lamp speech presents them as secretive, lustful and fond of wine, and even Praxagora's own list of women's virtues ends with lovers, unmixed wine and sex. The basic joke of the play - women disguised as men taking over the Assembly - only works if the audience thinks women in politics are absurd, and every role was played by a man for a mainly male audience.
However, Source A also turns the joke against men. The woman's 'evidence' that men drink is that their decisions are 'crazy, like the decisions of drunk men', that they shout abuse at each other and that the archers have to carry out the drunk. This is a sharp attack on how the Athenian Assembly actually behaved. Praxagora's speech continues this satire, complaining that Athenian politicians are fickle and that the city is always chasing new ideas, and the play was written in the 390s, after Athens' defeat in the Peloponnesian War, when many Athenians were disillusioned with their leaders. Praxagora herself is the cleverest and most persuasive character on stage and wins the vote.
Overall, Assemblywomen constantly laughs at women, using stereotypes the audience shared, but it is not simply a joke at women's expense. Its sharpest satire is aimed at Athenian men and their democracy, and women are the comic device that lets Aristophanes show how badly the men were running the city.
Explanation
Strong answers notice that the same joke can have two targets: Source A mocks women as drinkers and men as drunk decision-makers. They balance the play's reliance on stereotypes against its satire of male politics and Praxagora's competence, and place it in its context. Listing jokes about women without weighing them stays in Level 2.