Source A: an Athenian black-figure amphora by Exekias, about 530-525 BC (British Museum)
Achilles, in full armour, his face hidden by a crested helmet, lunges forward and drives his spear into the throat of the Amazon queen Penthesilea. She has sunk to one knee in front of him. She wears a helmet that leaves her face uncovered, a short tunic and a leopard skin, and her skin is painted white. Her head is turned up towards him and their eyes meet. Their names are painted beside them.
To what extent do Greek sources present Penthesilea as an admirable heroine rather than simply a defeated enemy? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
Greek sources do present Penthesilea as admirable, but her admirable qualities are always shown in the moment of her defeat. Exekias treats her with great respect. She is armed like a warrior, with a helmet and leopard skin, and her name is written beside her, as Achilles' is, as if she were a hero of equal rank. While Achilles' face is hidden behind his helmet, hers is uncovered, so the viewer's sympathy is drawn to her, and the meeting of their eyes suggests the tradition that Achilles fell in love with her as she died. Literary sources also honour her: in the Aethiopis, as Proclus summarises it, she is a daughter of Ares who comes as an ally of the Trojans and is killed while performing great deeds, an aristeia like that of a male hero. Only Achilles, the greatest Greek, can kill her, and the Trojans give her burial; Apollodorus adds that she killed many Greeks, including Machaon.
On the other hand, she is always the defeated party. In Source A she has sunk to her knee, the spear is already in her throat and Achilles towers over her, so the scene celebrates his victory. Achilles' love comes only when she is helpless or dead, which suggests that Greeks could admire her as a beautiful woman only once she was no longer a warrior; Thersites even mocks Achilles for it. Her story also exists to show off Achilles' strength.
Overall, Penthesilea is presented as an admirable, even tragic, heroine, but never on equal terms: Greek sources admire her courage and beauty precisely because her defeat by a Greek man is certain, which reinforces the idea that women, however brave, must give way to men.
Explanation
The best answers analyse how Exekias directs sympathy (faces, eyes, names) and use literary knowledge (the Aethiopis, Achilles' love, Thersites) to judge whether admiration outweighs the message of defeat. A conclusion that admiration and defeat go together, rather than simply choosing one, is a strong substantiated judgement.