Source A: Virgil, Aeneid 11.502-510 (Camilla speaks to Turnus before the battle)
'"Turnus, if the brave may rightly have confidence in themselves, I dare, and I promise, to meet the squadron of Aeneas' men and to ride out alone against the Etruscan cavalry. Let me try the first dangers of war with my own hand; you stay on foot by the walls and guard the city." ... Turnus replied: "Maiden, glory of Italy, what thanks can I find to speak or to repay you? But now, since your spirit rises above everything, share the labour with me."'
To what extent does Virgil present Camilla as a hero equal to the male warriors of the Aeneid? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
Source A suggests that Camilla is the equal of any male warrior. She volunteers to face Aeneas' squadron and the Etruscan cavalry alone, and tells Turnus, the Italian leader, to stay by the walls. Turnus himself calls her 'glory of Italy' and asks her to share his command. In battle Virgil gives her a full aristeia, like a male hero: she exults in the slaughter, hurling javelins and wielding a double axe, and kills a long list of men. Over Ornytus she makes a boast just like a male epic hero, and the simile of the hawk tearing apart a dove shows her complete dominance over the son of Aunus. Her success is so great that the Etruscans flee and Tarchon has to shame them, and Arruns dares to attack her only by stalking her. Even dying she thinks of the battle, and the last line of her death is repeated for Turnus at the end of the poem, putting her on a level with him.
However, Virgil never lets us forget that she is a woman. Tarchon treats being routed by a woman as a disgrace, Arruns calls her a 'plague' and wants none of her spoils, and she is constantly called 'the maiden'. Above all, Virgil explains her death by 'a woman's love of plunder and spoils', which makes her flaw a female one - although male heroes such as Euryalus and Turnus are also ruined by spoils. She also fights on the losing side, against the ancestors of the Romans.
In conclusion, Camilla is presented as the equal of male heroes in courage, skill and glory, but not in status: her heroism is always seen as extraordinary for a woman, and her death is explained in terms of her sex.
Explanation
Strong answers balance the evidence of Camilla's heroic status (Turnus' praise, her aristeia, the echo with Turnus' death) against the ways her gender is stressed (Tarchon, Arruns, 'a woman's love of plunder'). Comparing her desire for spoils with Euryalus or Turnus shows the kind of critical analysis needed for Level 4.