Question 1
1 markScientists can classify animals in different ways.
Which of these is an artificial classification?
Choose your answer.
- A grouping bats with whales, because both feed their young on milk
- B grouping crabs with woodlice, because DNA shows that they share a recent common ancestor
- C grouping dolphins with sharks, because both have fins and live in the sea
- D grouping eagles with penguins, because both have feathers and lay eggs with hard shells
Model answer
C
Explanation
A natural classification groups organisms by how closely they are related, using evidence such as DNA and features inherited from common ancestors. An artificial classification groups organisms by a few convenient features, such as having fins or living in water, so it can put unrelated animals together. Dolphins breathe air and feed their young on milk, so they are mammals, not fish.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
C / grouping dolphins with sharks, because both have fins and live in the sea
The only correct answer is C: an artificial classification groups animals by a few features that are easy to see, which can put unrelated animals together; dolphins are mammals and sharks are fish, and they look alike only because both swim in the sea. A is not correct because bats and whales are both mammals, so this grouping shows that they are related (a natural classification); B is not correct because grouping by DNA evidence of a common ancestor is a natural classification; D is not correct because eagles and penguins are both birds, so this grouping also shows that they are related. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.