Source A: Ovid, Fasti 2.547-556 (on the Parentalia)
'But once, while they were waging long wars with fighting weapons, they neglected the days of the Parentalia. It did not go unpunished: for they say that from that ill omen Rome grew hot with funeral pyres outside the city. I can hardly believe it, but they say our ancestors came out of their tombs and complained in the silent night, and that shapeless ghosts, an empty crowd, howled through the streets of the city and the wide fields. Afterwards the honours that had been left out were paid to the tombs again, and there was an end to the portents and the deaths.'
To what extent did the Romans believe that the living had a duty to look after the dead? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
Source A suggests that Romans believed the living had a serious duty to the dead. When the Parentalia was neglected during a long war, the ancestors came out of their tombs and complained, ghosts howled through the streets and Rome 'grew hot with funeral pyres', meaning many people died. Only when the honours were paid again did the portents stop. The dead, then, depended on the living, and neglecting them brought disaster.
There is much other evidence for this duty. At the Parentalia every family visited its tombs with simple gifts such as wreaths, grain, salt, bread soaked in wine and violets; Ovid says the dead ask for little, but devotion pleases them. The most basic duty was proper burial: in Virgil's underworld the unburied must wander for a hundred years before Charon will ferry them across, and in Pliny's ghost story a haunting ends only when the bones are found and buried. Families placed a coin for Charon with the body, held feasts at the tomb on the day of the funeral and on the ninth day, and dedicated tombs Dis Manibus, to the spirits of the dead. Even slaves joined burial clubs to make sure they would be buried; one club promised a funeral 'for the image' of a slave whose master refused to hand over the body.
However, the duty was not only loving care. At the Lemuria the head of the household drove restless spirits out of the house at midnight, so the dead were also feared. Beliefs also varied: some epitaphs say 'I was not, I was, I am not, I do not care', showing that some Romans did not believe in an afterlife at all, and Ovid himself says he can 'hardly believe' the ghost story.
In conclusion, Romans believed to a great extent that the living had a duty to look after the dead, through burial, offerings and festivals. This duty came from a mixture of family love, piety and fear, and it was kept up even by those who doubted that the dead felt anything.
Explanation
Strong answers use Source A's story of neglect and punishment and range across burial, the Parentalia, offerings, epitaphs and burial clubs, then evaluate: was the duty based on love, fear or tradition, and did all Romans believe it? Note Ovid's own scepticism as a point of critical analysis.