Source A: two marble metopes from the south side of the Parthenon (about 447-442 BC). In the first, a young Lapith grips a rearing centaur by the head from behind and draws back his arm to strike, while the centaur twists back in pain. In the second, a centaur rears up in triumph over the body of a Lapith lying on the ground, an animal skin hanging from his arm.
'The Centauromachy shows civilisation defeating barbarism.' To what extent is this true of the south metopes of the Parthenon? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
The statement is largely true, but the south metopes show civilisation's victory as a hard and uncertain struggle rather than a simple triumph.
The first metope in Source A fits the statement well. The young Lapith, with an idealised human body, overpowers the half-animal centaur, gripping him by the head and preparing to strike, while the centaur twists in pain. This contrast between man and beast expresses reason and self-control defeating wild passion. The myth itself supports this reading: the centaurs, invited as guests to Peirithous' wedding, got drunk and tried to carry off Hippodameia and the other women, breaking the civilised laws of hospitality and marriage, and the Lapiths, helped by the Athenian Theseus, restored order. The other metope series on the Parthenon - gods against giants, Greeks against Amazons and the Trojan War - share this theme, and after the Persians burned the Acropolis in 480 BC Athenians could see their own victory over the 'barbarians' in it.
However, the second metope in Source A shows a centaur rearing in triumph over a dead Lapith, and several metopes show centaurs winning. The series therefore presents a battle whose outcome is in doubt, and civilisation suffers losses. The 'barbarism' reading is also partly an interpretation: the centaurs were the Lapiths' relatives, and the myth could equally be a warning about wine or about the sanctity of marriage. The central metopes, lost in 1687, may even have shown a different story.
Overall, the metopes do show civilisation defeating barbarism, but their power comes from showing how hard-won that victory was. This made the message stronger for Athenians who had themselves suffered before defeating Persia.
Explanation
Source A gives one scene supporting the statement and one complicating it, so the best answers use both. Strong answers explain the symbolism (human versus beast, breach of xenia, the Persian parallel) and then evaluate it, noting the scenes of centaur victory and other possible meanings. A judgement that addresses 'to what extent' directly is needed for Level 4.