Question 1
1 markTwo people push on the same revolving door at the same time, from different sides. The door turns about a vertical axis at its centre. Seen from above:
• Person P pushes at right angles to the door with a force of 60 N, at a distance of 1.2 m from the axis. On its own, this force would turn the door anticlockwise.
• Person Q pushes at right angles to the door with a force of 80 N, at a distance of 0.80 m from the axis. On its own, this force would turn the door clockwise.
What is the resultant moment on the door, seen from above?
Choose your answer.
- A 8 N m anticlockwise
- B 8 N m clockwise
- C 20 N m clockwise
- D 136 N m anticlockwise
Model answer
A (8 N m anticlockwise)
Moment of P's force = 60 × 1.2 = 72 N m anticlockwise
Moment of Q's force = 80 × 0.80 = 64 N m clockwise
Resultant moment = 72 − 64 = 8 N m anticlockwise
Explanation
Work out each moment with moment = force × perpendicular distance from the pivot (here the axis of the door), and give each one a direction. Moments in opposite directions are subtracted, and the door turns the way of the larger moment. Q pushes with the larger force, but P pushes further from the axis, so P's moment is larger: a common error is to decide the direction from the forces alone.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / 8 N m anticlockwise
The only correct answer is A: moment = force × perpendicular distance from the axis, so the moment of P's force = 60 × 1.2 = 72 N m anticlockwise and the moment of Q's force = 80 × 0.80 = 64 N m clockwise. The moments act in opposite directions, so the resultant moment = 72 − 64 = 8 N m, in the direction of the larger moment (anticlockwise). B is not correct because it gives the direction of the larger force, not of the larger moment; C is not correct because 80 − 60 = 20 compares only the forces and ignores the distances; D is not correct because 72 + 64 = 136 adds two moments that act in opposite directions. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.