A hospital plans to use artificial intelligence (AI) software to examine patients' X-ray scans and point out possible signs of disease to doctors. The software was trained using scans from thousands of previous patients.
Evaluate the use of the AI software in the hospital.
You should include the following in your answer:
- the impact on patients and on hospital staff
- ethical and privacy issues
- a conclusion.
Model answer
The AI software could help patients by examining scans very quickly, at any time of day, so results are ready sooner and waiting times are shorter. It might also spot early signs of disease that a tired doctor could miss, so treatment can start earlier. For staff, it takes over a repetitive task, freeing doctors to spend more time with patients.
However, the software can make mistakes. A false alarm would worry a patient and lead to unnecessary tests, while a missed disease could be very serious, and it is not clear who would be responsible: the doctor, the hospital or the software company. Doctors might rely on the software too much and lose some of their own skills. If the training scans did not include enough patients from some groups, the software could be less accurate for them, which would be unfair.
There are privacy issues too. Thousands of previous patients' scans were used to train the software, and those patients may not have known or agreed, so the scans should have been anonymised. Health data is very sensitive, so it must be kept secure under the Data Protection Act 2018, especially if it is shared with the software company.
Overall, I think the hospital should use the software, but only to support doctors: a doctor should check every result and make the final decision. Patients then get faster results without losing human judgement, and responsibility stays clear.
Explanation
'Evaluate' means weighing up the benefits and drawbacks and reaching a judgement. Strong answers cover patients and staff, include ethical issues (mistakes, responsibility, bias, over-reliance) and privacy issues (training data, consent, security), and end with a justified conclusion. A list of points with no conclusion stays in Level 2 at best.