Freya and Tom own Puffling Marshmallows in Bowness-on-Windermere, where they make about 20 flavours of marshmallow by hand in the shop window. Most of their customers are tourists visiting the Lake District. Sales are high in the summer but fall by about 40% between November and February.
Many tourists ask whether they can order more marshmallows once they get home. A home-delivery service would need a website with online payments, costing £2,500 to set up, and each parcel would be sent by courier at about £4.50. Marshmallows can be squashed if a parcel is handled roughly, and in hot weather they can turn sticky in the post.
At Christmas, local customers often ask for gift boxes. Freya and Tom could widen the range by adding local jams, biscuits and hot chocolate to make gift hampers. This would need about £4,000 of extra stock, and the shop has little spare shelf space.
Several other shops nearby sell sweets and fudge, some of them factory-made and sold at lower prices.
In order to increase sales, Puffling Marshmallows is considering two options:
Option 1: offer a home-delivery service across the UK
Option 2: widen its product range to include gift hampers.
Justify which one of these two options Puffling Marshmallows should choose.
Model answer
Puffling Marshmallows should choose Option 1, a home-delivery service across the UK.
Many tourists already ask whether they can order more marshmallows once they get home. With a website and home delivery, these customers could reorder at any time of year, so the business would no longer depend on people visiting Bowness. Therefore sales could continue through the winter, when shop sales fall by about 40%. As a result, Freya and Tom would have more revenue in their quietest months to cover fixed costs such as rent, and the £2,500 website is a one-off cost that could be paid back over several years.
However, every parcel costs about £4.50 to send. If this is added to the price, customers may not bother ordering a small bag of marshmallows, and if the shop pays it, the profit on each order falls. Marshmallows can also be squashed or turn sticky in the post, which would mean refunds and poor online reviews that put off new customers.
Overall, home delivery is the better choice because it tackles the 40% winter fall, while hampers would only lift sales for the few weeks before Christmas and tie up £4,000 in stock in a shop with little spare space. However, its success depends on whether tourists really do reorder once they are home. Freya and Tom could test this by collecting email addresses from summer customers, setting a minimum order such as £20 so that the £4.50 courier cost is a small part of each order, and sending marshmallows in sturdy tins in the hottest months.
Explanation
A top answer chooses one option, uses the case to explain its benefits and its drawbacks, and ends with a conclusion that adds something new, such as testing demand with summer customers' email addresses. Listing the benefits of both options without comparing them gives no evaluation, and a one-sided answer cannot reach the top level. Either option can score 9 marks if it is justified well.