Upperfold Nursery is a small plant nursery on the edge of Oswestry owned by Owain. It grows and sells bedding plants, shrubs and fruit trees, and also sells compost and garden tools. It does most of its trade in spring and early summer. Many of the people who shop there are retired, keen gardeners, and some of them no longer drive.
Last year the nursery made a profit of £18,500, but its sales have fallen. A DIY chain store two miles away has opened a large garden section, which sells compost for £6 a bag compared with £8 at Upperfold. Owain has spoken to some regular customers. Several said the chain is cheaper, but others said their biggest problem is getting heavy bags of compost and large plants home.
Owain has worked out that cutting the prices of compost and bedding plants by 15% would cost about £5,000 a year in lost revenue if sales stayed the same. A delivery service would need a second-hand van costing £6,500 and a part-time driver, and customers could book deliveries by phone or on the nursery's website.
In order to increase its sales, Upperfold Nursery is considering two options:
Option 1: cut the prices of compost and bedding plants by 15%
Option 2: offer a home delivery service.
Justify which one of these two options Upperfold Nursery should choose.
Model answer
Upperfold Nursery should choose Option 2, a home delivery service.
Many of Owain's customers are retired gardeners, and some no longer drive, so their biggest problem is getting heavy bags of compost and large plants home. A delivery service would meet their need for convenience, because they could book a delivery by phone or on the website and have their shopping brought to their door. Therefore Upperfold would offer something the DIY chain's garden section does not, so it would not have to compete on price. As a result, it could keep charging £8 for a bag of compost, or charge for delivery, and win back customers who stopped coming because they could not carry their shopping home. These customers may also buy more in each order, such as several bags of compost or a fruit tree, which increases sales without reducing the revenue from each item.
However, the service would be expensive to set up. The second-hand van costs £6,500, which is more than a third of last year's £18,500 profit, and Owain would also have to pay a part-time driver every week, as well as fuel and insurance. If only a few customers book deliveries, these extra costs could be higher than the extra revenue, so the nursery's profit would fall.
Overall, Option 2 is still better than cutting prices by 15%, which would lose about £5,000 of revenue a year unless sales rose, and would still leave compost 80p a bag dearer than at the chain, which could simply cut its own prices again. However, the choice depends on how many customers would pay for delivery outside the busy spring and early summer. Owain should first ask his regular customers how often they would use it; if enough would book all year round to cover the driver's wages, the service could pay back the cost of the van and give Upperfold a lasting advantage over the chain.
Explanation
A top answer picks one option, explains its benefits and drawbacks with the case figures (the retired customers who no longer drive, the £6,500 van, the £5,000 of lost revenue, the chain's £6 compost) and ends with a conclusion that adds a new 'it depends' point. Either option can earn 9 marks, but listing the benefits of both options without comparing them gives no evaluation.