Amara and Luke are starting Spoke & Parcel Deliveries, a partnership in Oxford that will use electric cargo bikes to deliver parcels for independent shops in the city centre. They need £24,000 for four cargo bikes and a small storage unit. Eighteen local shops have said they would use the service, and the business's Instagram account already has 900 followers.
A crowd funding website could raise the £24,000 from members of the public. Supporters would receive rewards, such as discount vouchers from the shops that use the service. The website keeps 5% of the money raised, and if the target is not reached in 30 days the money is returned to supporters. Running the campaign would take up much of the partners' time for two months.
Their bank would lend them £24,000 over five years, repaid at about £500 a month. It has asked to see their business plan first. Amara and Luke have no other borrowing.
In order to finance the start-up costs, Spoke & Parcel Deliveries is considering two options:
Option 1: raise the money through crowd funding
Option 2: take out a bank loan.
Justify which one of these two options Spoke & Parcel Deliveries should choose.
Model answer
Spoke & Parcel Deliveries should choose Option 1, crowd funding.
With crowd funding, supporters receive rewards such as discount vouchers from local shops, so Amara and Luke have no loan to repay. This means about £500 a month that would have gone on loan repayments stays in the business. Therefore, in the first months, when the cargo bikes are only just starting deliveries for the eighteen shops, their cash outflows are much lower. As a result, they are less likely to run short of cash and need an expensive overdraft while they build up customers.
However, the website keeps 5% of the money raised, so they would need to raise about £25,300 to end up with £24,000. If they miss the target within 30 days, they receive nothing, and they would have spent two months on the campaign instead of preparing to launch.
Overall, crowd funding is the better choice, because a new delivery service with uncertain sales is safer without £500 of fixed repayments every month for five years. It depends, though, on whether their support turns into money. The 900 Instagram followers and eighteen shops are a good start, but if the shops also promote the campaign to their own customers, the target is much more likely to be reached; if after the first two weeks the campaign is far from its target, the partners should go back to the bank and use the business plan they have prepared to take the loan instead.
Explanation
A strong answer chooses one option, uses the case to explain its main benefit (no repayments, or certain and full finance) and weighs a real drawback (the 5% fee and all-or-nothing target, or five years of repayments). The conclusion should add something new, such as how the partners could make the campaign succeed or when they should switch to the loan. Either option can score full marks.