The big idea
Nobody can see inside an atom, so scientists use models of it. Over about 200 years the model of the atom has changed several times, each time because new experimental evidence could not be explained by the old model. You need to describe each model, explain why it changed, and compare the plum pudding model with the nuclear model.
From solid spheres to the plum pudding
Before the discovery of the electron, atoms were thought to be tiny spheres that could not be divided.
The discovery of the electron showed that atoms contain even smaller particles, so they can be divided. Electrons are negative, but atoms have no overall charge, so atoms must also contain positive charge. This led to the plum pudding model: the atom is a ball of positive charge with negative electrons embedded in it. There is no nucleus. The positive charge and the mass are spread through the whole atom.
The alpha particle scattering experiment
Scientists fired a beam of alpha particles (small, positively charged particles) at a very thin sheet of gold foil and detected where they went. If the plum pudding model were correct, almost all of them should pass straight through with little or no deflection, because the charge and mass in each atom are spread out thinly.
| Result | Conclusion |
|---|
| Most alpha particles passed straight through | Most of the atom is empty space |
| Some were deflected | The centre of the atom has a concentrated positive charge that repels them |
| A very small number bounced back | The mass is concentrated in a very small nucleus at the centre |
The plum pudding model could not explain the alpha particles that bounced back. So it was replaced by the nuclear model: the mass of the atom is concentrated at the centre in a tiny, positively charged nucleus, with electrons around it.
Later changes
- Niels Bohr adapted the nuclear model by suggesting that electrons orbit the nucleus at specific distances (the shells or energy levels used today). His model was accepted because his theoretical calculations agreed with experimental observations.
- Later experiments showed that the positive charge of any nucleus can be subdivided into a whole number of smaller particles, each with the same amount of positive charge. These particles were named protons.
- The experimental work of James Chadwick provided the evidence for neutrons in the nucleus. This was about 20 years after the nucleus became an accepted scientific idea. Neutrons have no charge, which made them harder to detect.
You do not need to know details of the experiments behind Bohr's model or Chadwick's work.
Comparing the two models
| Plum pudding model | Nuclear model |
|---|
| Nucleus | none | a tiny nucleus at the centre |
| Positive charge | spread through the whole atom | concentrated in the nucleus |
| Mass | spread evenly through the atom | almost all in the nucleus |
| Electrons | embedded in the ball of positive charge | outside the nucleus (in shells, after Bohr) |
| Empty space | none: a solid ball of charge | the atom is mostly empty space |
A model is kept while it explains the evidence. When new evidence cannot be explained, the model is adapted (as Bohr did) or replaced (as the nuclear model replaced the plum pudding model). A replaced model was still useful: the plum pudding model explained the evidence of its time, and testing its predictions led to the scattering experiment.
Writing a comparison
Compare the model of the atom used before the electron was discovered with the plum pudding model.
A "compare" answer needs both models in every point, linked by a word such as "whereas":
- In the earlier model atoms could not be divided, whereas the plum pudding model had smaller particles (electrons) inside the atom.
- The earlier model said nothing about charges inside the atom, whereas the plum pudding model had negative electrons in a ball of positive charge.
- One similarity: neither model had a nucleus, because in both the matter of the atom filled a solid sphere.
Remember
The order of the models, and the evidence for each change:
- Tiny spheres that cannot be divided.
- The electron is discovered: the plum pudding model.
- Alpha particle scattering: the nuclear model.
- Bohr: electrons orbit at specific distances.
- Protons, then neutrons (Chadwick, about 20 years after the nucleus was accepted).
Common mistakes
- Describing a nucleus in the plum pudding model. It has none: the positive charge is spread through the whole atom.
- Saying the Bohr model replaced the plum pudding model. The nuclear model replaced it; Bohr later adapted the nuclear model.
- Saying alpha particles bounced back because the nucleus is negative. Like charges repel, so a positive nucleus turns back the positive alpha particles.
- Saying most alpha particles bounced back. Only a very small number did; most went straight through.
- Answering a "compare" question by describing only one model.
Exam tip
In the 6-mark question on the scattering experiment, link every result to a conclusion ("most passed straight through, so most of the atom is empty space"), then finish with the scientific idea: the plum pudding model could not explain the new evidence, so it was replaced by the nuclear model.