Practise 12 exam-style questions on Beethoven: the development for AQA GCSE Music. Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.
12 questions
2–8 marks each
Instant marking
No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go
Sample questions with model answers
Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.
Question 1
2 marks
Beethoven: Symphony No. 1, movement 1.
Identify two features of the harmony at the start of the Development.
Model answer
The chords move round a circle of fifths (A, D, G, then C minor and F minor), and the soft answering chords are dissonant diminished sevenths.
Explanation
AQA's study guide identifies a circle of fifths (A - D - G - C minor - F minor - B flat) with a slow harmonic rhythm, and diminished seventh chords (for example C#-E-G-Bb) in the opening of the Development. Harmony answers were weak in AQA's June 2025 report, so learn these named devices; a vague 'the chords change' earns nothing.
Mark scheme
2 marks
Any two of: a circle of fifths (chord roots falling by fifths: A, D, G, C minor, F minor, B flat); diminished seventh chords; chromatic harmony / dissonance; slow harmonic rhythm (chords last several bars); loud major chords answered by soft dissonant chords; minor chords borrowed from C minor (C minor, F minor)
1 mark for each different correct feature, max 2. Accept Bb / B flat / B♭ and C# / C sharp / C♯ in any chord spellings (e.g. C#-E-G-Bb). Accept 'cycle of fifths'. Do not accept 'perfect cadences in C major', 'tonic pedal' or 'tierce de Picardie'.
Question 2
2 marks
Beethoven: Symphony No. 1, movement 1.
Identify two features of the tonality of the Development.
Model answer
The Development modulates frequently and avoids the home key, C major. It favours minor keys such as C minor and F minor, and near the end it uses E major as the dominant of A minor.
Explanation
AQA's study guide lists C minor, F minor and G minor (the tonic, subdominant and dominant minor keys), B flat and E flat major (more distant keys), and E major as the dominant of A minor near the end; B flat major arrives where the violin canon begins, then E flat major and G minor while the dotted motif passes round the orchestra. Frequent modulation, often to minor keys, is what makes a development sound unsettled, and the home key is saved for the Recapitulation. 'Atonal' is wrong: every passage is in a key, it just keeps changing.
Mark scheme
2 marks
Any two of: frequent modulation / it moves through many keys; minor keys related to the home key - the tonic, subdominant and dominant minors (C minor, F minor, G minor); keys further from C major (B flat major, E flat major); the tonic key, C major, is avoided until the Recapitulation; E major is used as the dominant of A minor near the end (A minor chords are heard, but the key is never firmly established); the music is unstable / never settles in one key
1 mark for each different correct feature, max 2. Naming a key that is visited (C minor, F minor, G minor, B flat major, E flat major, E major, D minor, A minor) counts as a feature; two different named keys can score both marks. AQA's study guide for the Development names the first six and points to A minor, and the score bears each out: C minor and F minor chords in the circle of fifths at the start; a quiet B flat major chord, with B flat repeated in the bass, where the violin canon begins; E flat major (the violins outline E flat-G-B flat while the bassoon's dotted figure rises to E flat) where the three-note motif starts to pass round the woodwind; G minor a little later (the violins outline G-B flat-D while the cellos and basses play the 1st subject's opening figure on G, with F sharp); D minor then A minor just before the horns and trumpets enter (the violas' and cellos' dotted figures A-C sharp and E-G sharp rise to D and to A); E major chords (G sharp) over the horns' and trumpets' held E. Accept Bb / B flat / B♭ and Eb / E flat / E♭. Do not accept 'stays in C major', 'atonal' or G major as a key of the Development.
Question 3
2 marks
Beethoven: Symphony No. 1, movement 1.
Identify two features of the music in the final bars of the Development, just before the Recapitulation.
Model answer
The woodwind hold long notes (semibreves), playing sf and dying away to p before a crescendo, while the rest of the orchestra is silent. Then the strings play a quick flourish of four semiquavers that leads into the Recapitulation.
Explanation
AQA's study guide notes that the Development ends with the woodwind playing semibreves - longer values than at the end of the Exposition - with sf, diminuendo, p and crescendo leading to ff at the Recapitulation. The strings' four falling semiquavers (G-F-E-D) echo the same four notes, played as demisemiquavers, at the end of the Introduction. Any two accurate features score.
Mark scheme
2 marks
Any two of: sustained / long woodwind notes (semibreves); the woodwind play sf, then diminuendo to p, then crescendo; legato woodwind lines moving downwards; the rest of the orchestra (strings, brass) is silent; a quick string flourish of four semiquavers leads into the Recapitulation; the crescendo leads to ff at the start of the Recapitulation
1 mark for each different correct feature, max 2. Accept 'semi-breves' or 'held notes'. The flourish earns its mark without a note value; its notes are semiquavers (the demisemiquavers are in the flourish that ends the Introduction). Do not accept 'timpani roll', 'the 2nd subject returns' or 'a pause/fermata' (there is none).
Question 4
8 marks
Beethoven: Symphony No. 1, movement 1.
Explain how Beethoven has used tonality, harmony and rhythm to create a sense of restlessness in the Development section of the movement.
Model answer
Tonality: the Development never settles in one key. Beethoven moves through C minor and F minor - minor versions of the tonic and subdominant - and on to more distant keys such as B flat major. Near the end he prepares A minor with its dominant, E major, but then the Recapitulation bursts in on C major instead. Because the home key is withheld, the music feels as if it is searching for somewhere to rest.
Harmony: the opening chords move round a circle of fifths (A, D, G, C minor, F minor), so each chord pulls towards the next. The soft answering chords are diminished sevenths, such as C#-E-G-Bb, which are chromatic and dissonant and demand resolution. Later a dominant pedal on E, held by the horns and trumpets, keeps the tension high.
Rhythm: the 1st subject's rhythm is broken up: the dotted quaver-semiquaver figure is cut down to a short three-note motif that jumps from instrument to instrument. The answering chords are syncopated (crotchet-minim-crotchet, tied across the barline), so the pulse is unsettled, and continuous staccato quavers in the strings keep the music driving forward.
Explanation
Strong answers keep tonality (which keys) separate from harmony (which chords and devices) and link each to restlessness: no settled key, dissonant diminished sevenths, syncopated and fragmented rhythms. AQA's study guide notes that Beethoven uses the minor forms of the tonic, subdominant and dominant keys. Avoid repeating the same point under two headings, which AQA's mark schemes do not credit twice.
Mark scheme
8 marks
Levels of response (8 marks). Level 4 (7-8 marks): A comprehensive response which is consistently coherent and logically structured. Level 3 (5-6 marks): A wide-ranging response which is mostly coherent and well structured. Level 2 (3-4 marks): A relevant response despite some inaccuracy/omission and weaknesses in terms of coherency and structure. Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited response with some significant inaccuracy/omission and a lack of clarity. 0 marks: No work submitted or worth credit.
Max 6 if the answer writes about only two of the three named elements (AQA June 2025 report: "for students to access the top band, all elements need to be written about, to make the response comprehensive"). Indicative content (credit other valid points): Tonality: frequent modulation; the tonic key (C major) is avoided until the Recapitulation; minor keys related to the tonic (C minor, F minor, G minor - tonic, subdominant and dominant minor instead of their majors); more distant keys (B flat major, E flat major); E major as the dominant of A minor near the end, a key that is then never firmly established - the Recapitulation arrives in C major instead. Harmony: a circle of fifths at the start (A - D - G - C minor - F minor - B flat), with a slow harmonic rhythm; diminished seventh chords (e.g. C#-E-G-Bb, F#-A-C-Eb, B-D-F-Ab) - chromatic, dissonant, unstable; chromatic harmony; a dominant pedal on E (horns and trumpets) under E major chords, building tension. Rhythm: the 1st subject's rhythm broken into fragments; the dotted quaver-semiquaver figure used on its own as a short motif (dotted quaver, semiquaver, crotchet); syncopated answering chords (crotchet-minim-crotchet, tied over the barline); continuous staccato quavers in the strings; long tied notes (semibreves) in the brass and woodwind near the end; four semiquavers in the strings leading into the Recapitulation. Any other valid point under any of these three headings. Ensure there is no repetition of points across different elements. Ensure that responses refer only to the three given elements. Guidance (not a cap): a list of terms with no explanation ('scattergun' listing, AQA June 2025 report) stays in the lower levels; no introduction or summary is needed (AQA June 2025 report).
Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.
Ctrl + Enter to check
Study HelperHints first, answers after you try
Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.